Minister of Justice Chiu Tai-san (邱太三) on Wednesday held a news conference where he provided a summary of the deliberations by the preparatory committees for the National Congress on Judicial Reform. He mentioned six major measures that would inform the reform process: transparency, participation, impartiality, resolving injustice, efficiency and human rights.
The only measure that gets anywhere near the core of reforming the prosecutorial system is the proposed establishment of a citizen review commission, allowing public participation in the prosecutorial review process. The rest are empty slogans that do not reach to the core of reform.
The quality of prosecutors is central to judicial reform, and this is why effective reform is measured in terms of the quality and number of prosecutors, their level of competency, and their sense of vocation and mission.
On May 3, not long after Taipei district prosecutor Su Chen-wen (蘇振文) handed his resignation letter to Chiu, Lee Chun-pu (李俊璞) of the Taoyuan District Prosecutors’ Office, who had taken the unprecedented step of changing occupations from doctor to prosecutor, followed suit.
These were grassroots prosecutors disillusioned with the excessive workload and the opaque way the congress was carrying out its business.
Their resignations sent out a major warning signal, but their concerns were largely ignored in the six measures.
There were 1,389 prosecutors in the nation as of March 13, according to Ministry of Justice statistics.
However, district prosecutors, who are on the front line, made up less than 75 percent of that number, while those working for the High Prosecutors’ Office and the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office account for 13.88 percent and 1.57 percent respectively.
In Japan, the figures are 94.59 percent, 4.75 percent and 0.66 percent respectively, suggesting that Taiwan does not have enough prosecutors and that they are poorly deployed.
The bulk of criminal investigative work, after all, is carried out at the district level.
According to the statistics, prosecutors at the district level take on an average of 52 new cases each month, not including unsolved cases they are working on or those requiring further field work or autopsies.
Lee, for example, was working on 80 cases before he resigned. Even if he took up residency at the office and did nothing else but try to clear his backlog, it was a virtually impossible task. He could not cope with returning cases, rigorous examinations and the excessive workload, and was obliged to repay the cost of his training, a hefty NT$1.5 million (US$49,636 at the current exchange rate).
The statistics also show that prosecutors are expected to handle a minimum of 28 cases each month, with a single case requiring at least 44 days of work.
Is it realistic for the public to expect prosecutors working under these conditions — personnel shortages and mountains of files that cannot be cleared even if they worked 24 hours a day, seven days a week — to get to the bottom of all of the crimes that cross their desks?
Perhaps the nation could take a page from Japan’s book and give the police the power to process cases involving lesser crimes, instead of expecting prosecutors to handle each and every one of them.
In addition, the ministry should improve the conditions of prosecutors, investigators, forensic technicians and inspectors, and share some of the workload of the district prosecutors’ offices to enhance the quality of criminal investigations and the quality of the prosecutors, and to give them more of a sense of mission in their job.
Lin Terng-yaw is a lawyer.
Translated by Paul Cooper
Taiwan faces complex challenges like other Asia-Pacific nations, including demographic decline, income inequality and climate change. In fact, its challenges might be even more pressing. The nation struggles with rising income inequality, declining birthrates and soaring housing costs while simultaneously navigating intensifying global competition among major powers. To remain competitive in the global talent market, Taiwan has been working to create a more welcoming environment and legal framework for foreign professionals. One of the most significant steps in this direction was the enactment of the Act for the Recruitment and Employment of Foreign Professionals (外國專業人才延攬及僱用法) in 2018. Subsequent amendments in
The recent passing of Taiwanese actress Barbie Hsu (徐熙媛), known to many as “Big S,” due to influenza-induced pneumonia at just 48 years old is a devastating reminder that the flu is not just a seasonal nuisance — it is a serious and potentially fatal illness. Hsu, a beloved actress and cultural icon who shaped the memories of many growing up in Taiwan, should not have died from a preventable disease. Yet her death is part of a larger trend that Taiwan has ignored for too long — our collective underestimation of the flu and our low uptake of the
US President Donald Trump on Saturday signed orders to impose tariffs on Canada, Mexico and China effective from today. Trump decided to slap 25 percent tariffs on goods from Mexico and Canada as well as 10 percent on those coming from China, but would only impose a 10 percent tariff on Canadian energy products, including oil and electricity. Canada and Mexico on Sunday quickly responded with retaliatory tariffs against the US, while countermeasures from China are expected soon. Nevertheless, Trump announced yesterday to delay tariffs on Mexico and Canada for a month and said he would hold further talks with
Taiwan’s undersea cables connecting it to the world were allegedly severed several times by a Chinese ship registered under a flag of convenience. As the vessel sailed, it used several different automatic identification systems (AIS) to create fake routes. That type of “shadow fleet” and “gray zone” tactics could create a security crisis in Taiwan and warrants response measures. The concept of a shadow fleet originates from the research of Elisabeth Braw, senior fellow at the Washington-based Atlantic Council. The phenomenon was initiated by authoritarian countries such as Iran, North Korea and Russia, which have been hit by international economic