Wild gyrations in Hong Kong share prices are raising concerns that a new trading link with mainland China is a conduit for questionable trading practices that could undermine the territory’s reputation as a center of global finance.
At least four companies that climbed to dizzying values in only a few months have come abruptly crashing down in the past several weeks for reasons that remain unclear.
The strange trading patterns have gripped Hong Kong’s financial community with a narrative of paper fortunes built quickly and then wiped out in an even shorter time.
Illustration: Tania Chou
The most high-profile case is Chinese solar panel maker Hanergy Thin Film Power Group, now under investigation by the market watchdog. Also affected are two Hong Kong-listed units of Chinese billionaire Pan Sutong’s (潘蘇通) Goldin conglomerate involved in horse breeding and wine trading. The most recent is Digital Domain Holdings, whose main business is a California special effects firm founded two decades ago by Titanic and Avatar director James Cameron, who no longer has a stake after it went bankrupt in 2012. It is perhaps best known more recently for creating a hologram of deceased rapper Tupac Shakur to perform alongside Snoop Dogg at a California music festival. In a little over two months, the shares soared ninefold and then abruptly plunged last week to one-third of their peak.
Market watchers say a tide of money sweeping in from mainland China following the launch of the Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect trading link last year has amplified speculation and increased risks for investors. The link allows investors in each city to trade on the other city’s exchange. Hanergy and the two Goldin companies are among 286 stocks Chinese investors can buy via the link.
“The recent developments have sparked concerns about new dynamics that our regulators need to deal with,” Asian Corporate Governance Association Hong Kong research director Michael Cheng (鄭孟揚) said. “We hope that it will be the two markets upping the game for each other, but with the recent developments, we have a genuine concern that there’s a real risk of a race to the bottom.”
Recent price swings are “unprecedented” in Hong Kong, he said.
The territory, along with London, New York and Tokyo, is a key global financial center, a status underpinned by the reputation of its legal and financial systems which are based on the laws of its former colonial ruler, Britain.
Local traders say the market turbulence is a sign of the larger stock trading frenzy spilling over from China, where the Shanghai benchmark has more than doubled in the past year in a boom powered by borrowed money and a stampede of rookie traders.
Nine of the Hong Kong exchange’s 10 busiest days on record were in April or May as trading on the link surged to a high. After a quiet start, the value of Chinese trades in Hong Kong via the link jumped to US$30 billion in April, out of US$490 billion in total stock market turnover. In May it eased to US$13.2 billion out of US$374 billion.
Experts believe the companies most susceptible to manipulation are those with a relatively small amount of freely traded stock, known as the free float, making them more volatile.
Hong Kong’s market regulator, the Securities and Futures Commission, last week warned that Goldin Properties Holdings stock could “fluctuate substantially” and investors “should exercise extreme caution” because its Chinese billionaire owner and 13 other shareholders own more than 95 percent of outstanding shares.
Even companies not on the official list of stocks eligible for trading on the link, such as Digital Domain, are affected, said David Webb, a former investment banker turned shareholder and corporate governance advocate who believes many Chinese are coming to Hong Kong to open stock trading accounts.
“There are dozens of stocks that are trading far away from fair value,” he said. “It’s a fairly widespread phenomenon at the moment.”
In Hanergy’s case, shares of the solar panel maker backed by Chinese billionaire Li Hejun (李河君) rose more than sixfold since last summer until May 20, when they suddenly halved in the first hour of trading for no apparent reason, wiping out about half his fortune. The shares are now suspended.
In an interview with Chinese state media released a week later, Li dismissed reports that the company was under scrutiny.
The next day, the Securities and Futures Commission took the unusual step of confirming it had launched a formal investigation “into the affairs” of the company.
Separately, Goldin Financial Holdings and Goldin Properties Holdings tumbled more than 40 percent, wiping out a combined US$15 billion of market value. Before the crash, the shares had quadrupled, inflating Pan’s personal fortune. Forbes now estimates it at US$11.2 billion.
It is unclear why Hanergy or the Goldin companies plummeted.
Digital Domain’s sell-off appears to have been sparked by rumors that a Chinese businessman linked to the company was arrested. The businessman, Che Fung, and a partner were the previous owners of the special effects firm, but in an intricate deal, sold their stake two years ago to Digital Domain in exchange for convertible bonds. Under certain conditions, the bonds can be exchanged for stock worth nearly half of the company’s enlarged share capital, giving him the potential to become one of the company’s biggest shareholders.
Digital Domain denied “suggestions in certain media reports” that any executive directors or senior management had been arrested recently. It confirmed Che was a bondholder, but declined to comment on his status.
“For Digital Domain, this is just a very short term bubble” that popped after the arrest rumors triggered the liquidations by speculators, Ample Capital director of asset management Alex Wong (黃國英) said.
“The company is selling a concept in virtual reality, so that is a very long-term story” not matching the company’s brief spike in valuation, he said.
At the end of last month, Paraguayan Ambassador to Taiwan Marcial Bobadilla Guillen told a group of Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislators that his president had decided to maintain diplomatic ties with Taiwan, despite pressure from the Chinese government and local businesses who would like to see a switch to Beijing. This followed the Paraguayan Senate earlier this year voting against a proposal to establish ties with China in exchange for medical supplies. This constituted a double rebuke of the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) diplomatic agenda in a six-month span from Taiwan’s only diplomatic ally in South America. Last year, Tuvalu rejected an
South China Sea exercises in July by two United States Navy nuclear-powered aircraft carriers reminds that Taiwan’s history since mid-1950, and as a free nation, is intertwined with that of the aircraft carrier. Eventually Taiwan will host aircraft carriers, either those built under its democratic government or those imposed on its territory by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its People’s Liberation Army Navy (PLAN). By September 1944, a lack of sufficient carrier airpower and land-based airpower persuaded US Army and Navy leaders to forgo an invasion to wrest Taiwan from Japanese control, thereby sparing Taiwanese considerable wartime destruction. But two
As Taiwan is engulfed in worries about Chinese infiltration, news reports have revealed that power inverters made by China’s Huawei Technologies Co are used in the solar panels on the top of the Legislative Yuan’s Zhenjiang House (鎮江會館) on Zhenjiang Street in Taipei. However, what is even more worrying is that Taiwan’s new national electronic identification card (eID) has been subcontracted to the French security firm and eID maker Idemia, which has not only cooperated with the Chinese Public Security Bureau to manufacture eIDs in China, but also makes the new identification cards being issued in Hong Kong. There might be more
All lives eventually come to an end. Over the years, my friendship with former president Lee Teng-hui (李登輝) had its ups and downs. Lee’s passing was a heavy blow and has left me deeply saddened. We experienced a lot together and the memories have come flooding back. Lee was born several months earlier than me. During World War II, he was studying at Kyoto Imperial University, but halfway through his studies, he was forced to change his name and enter military service. I was studying at Tokyo Imperial University, but went into hiding to avoid military service, and I was later