The Control Yuan has caused an uproar by twice voting down a motion to impeach Keelung Mayor Chang Tong-rong (張通榮) after he was convicted for persuading police to release a woman arrested for drunk driving. Even before this case, it was clear that the Control Yuan could not be expected to tackle “tigers” in the central government.
The Control Yuan no longer has the power to impeach the president, since that has been handed over to the legislature. It is obvious that the Control Yuan is also incapable of doing anything about local “snakes” or even swatting a few “flies.”
No wonder even Control Yuan President Wang Chien-shien (王建煊) says that if the Control Yuan cannot uphold fairness and justice, it might as well close down. Perhaps Taiwan really would be better off without it.
The Control Yuan suspended its work between 2005 and 2008 because of political deadlock over nominations, and its performance since it restarted has not been impressive. To make matters worse, news reports about the questionable behavior of certain Control Yuan members have further sullied its reputation.
Looking back on those years when there were no Control Yuan members, their absence did not affect the operation of government departments much. The only problem, really, was that complaints and petitions submitted by members of the public began to pile up. As for cases of illegal acts or breaches of discipline by government officials, when the Control Yuan was not there to deal with them, prosecution and judicial departments handled them instead and meted out punishments in accordance with the law.
The Control Yuan’s supervisory work includes applying impeachments, censures and corrections, as well as accepting and processing complaints and petitions from the public and carrying out tours of inspection. It handles civil servants’ property declarations, verifies political donation declarations and has the power of audit. All these functions and powers could be transferred to existing departments of the judiciary and legislature, such as the Judicial Yuan’s Agency Against Corruption. An independent power of audit could be maintained as it is in Europe and the US. Personnel qualified for service in the Control Yuan could be deployed to other government departments, where they could help fight corruption while avoiding accusations of political patronage.
Taiwan has experienced a series of amendments to its Constitution, so there is no need to make excuses about all the fuss and trouble further amendments might cause. What is to stop the government and opposition parties from seriously reviewing and reforming the system?
The nation’s five-branched constitutional system could be changed into a three-branched one. That would make the whole system a lot more transparent and allow personnel and financial costs to be cut. It would raise efficiency and benefit the public by eliminating duplicated functions in executive, legislative and judicial departments.
It might also be possible to revamp the much-criticized system for electing constituency and at-large legislators, and even to amend the Referendum Act (公投法), to make these systems better suit the needs of the public.
That would be a sensible course to take. Rather than always criticizing the Control Yuan for its failings, it would be better to amend the Constitution to abolish the Control Yuan and Examination Yuan. The country and the public would certainly benefit from such a change.
Lu I-ming is a former publisher and president of Taiwan Shin Sheng Daily News.
Translated by Julian Clegg
From the Iran war and nuclear weapons to tariffs and artificial intelligence, the agenda for this week’s Beijing summit between US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is packed. Xi would almost certainly bring up Taiwan, if only to demonstrate his inflexibility on the matter. However, no one needs to meet with Xi face-to-face to understand his stance. A visit to the National Museum of China in Beijing — in particular, the “Road to Rejuvenation” exhibition, which chronicles the rise and rule of the Chinese Communist Party — might be even more revealing. Xi took the members
A Pale View of Hills, a movie released last year, follows the story of a Japanese woman from Nagasaki who moved to Britain in the 1950s with her British husband and daughter from a previous marriage. The daughter was born at a time when memories of the US atomic bombing of Nagasaki during World War II and anxiety over the effects of nuclear radiation still haunted the community. It is a reflection on the legacy of the local and national trauma of the bombing that ended the period of Japanese militarism. A central theme of the movie is the need, at
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) on Friday used their legislative majority to push their version of a special defense budget bill to fund the purchase of US military equipment, with the combined spending capped at NT$780 billion (US$24.78 billion). The bill, which fell short of the Executive Yuan’s NT$1.25 trillion request, was passed by a 59-0 margin with 48 abstentions in the 113-seat legislature. KMT Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文), who reportedly met with TPP Chairman Huang Kuo-chang (黃國昌) for a private meeting before holding a joint post-vote news conference, was said to have mobilized her
Before the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its People’s Liberation Army (PLA) can blockade, invade, and destroy the democracy on Taiwan, the CCP seeks to make the world an accomplice to Taiwan’s subjugation by harassing any government that confers any degree of marginal recognition, or defies the CCP’s “One China Principle” diktat that there is no free nation of Taiwan. For United States President Donald Trump’s upcoming May 14, 2026 visit to China, the CCP’s top wish has nothing to do with Trump’s ongoing dismantling of the CCP’s Axis of Evil. The CCP’s first demand is for Trump to cease US
RSS