Wed, Jun 13, 2012 page9

• Freedom of speech eroding in Turkey

  Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan is using a series of alleged plots to justify a crackdown on dissent that threatens basic freedoms

  • By Mehdi Hasan / The Guardian, LONDON
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Which country in the world currently imprisons more journalists than any other? The People’s Republic of China? Nope. Iran? Wrong again. The rather depressing answer is the Republic of Turkey, where nearly 100 journalists are behind bars, according to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. Yes, that’s right: modern, secular, Western-oriented Turkey, with its democratically elected government, has locked away more members of the press than China and Iran combined.

  However, this isn’t just about the press — students, academics, artists and opposition parliamentarians have all recently been targeted for daring to speak out against the government of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his Islamist Justice and Development Party (AKP).

  There is a new climate of fear in Istanbul. When I visited the city last week to host a discussion show for al-Jazeera English, I found journalists speaking in hushed tones about the clampdown on free speech. Within 24 hours of our arrival, one of my al-Jazeera colleagues was detained by police officers, who went through his bag and rifled through one of my scripts. They loudly objected to a line referring to the country’s “increasingly authoritarian government.” Who says that Turks don’t do irony?

  

  Illustration: Mountain People

  The stock response from members of the AKP government is to blame the imprisonment and intimidation on Turkey’s supposedly “independent” judiciary, but this will not do. For a start, ministers haven’t been afraid of interfering in high-profile prosecutions. In a speech at the Council of Europe in April last year, a defiant Erdogan, commenting on the controversial detention of the investigative journalist Ahmet Sik, compared Sik’s then unpublished book to a bomb: “It is a crime to use a bomb, but it is also a crime to use materials from which a bomb is made.”

  Then there is the behind-the-scenes pressure that is exerted by the government on media organizations.

  “People are afraid of criticizing Erdogan openly,” said Mehmet Karli, a lecturer at Galatasaray University in Istanbul and a campaigner for Kurdish rights. “They might not be arrested, but they will lose their jobs.”

  In February, for example, Nuray Mert, a columnist for the Milliyet newspaper, was sacked and her TV show canceled after she was publicly singled out for criticism by the prime minister. Last month Ali Akel, a conservative columnist for the pro-government newspaper Yeni Safak, was fired for daring to write a rare, critical article about Erdogan’s handling of the Kurdish issue.

  However, the restrictions on freedom of speech don’t stop with the media.

  Exhibit A: Last week, two students were sentenced to eight years and five months in prison by a court in Istanbul for “membership of a terrorist organization,” while a third student was sentenced to two years and two months behind bars for spreading terrorist propaganda. Yet the students, Berna Yilmaz, Ferhat Tuzer and Utku Aykar, had merely unfurled a banner reading “We want free education, we will get it,” at a public meeting attended by Erdogan in March 2010.

  Exhibit B: On June 1 Fazil Say, one of Turkey’s leading classical pianists, was charged with “publicly insulting religious values that are adopted by a part of the nation” after he retweeted a few lines from a poem by the 11th-century Persian poet Omar Khayyam that mocked the Islamic vision of heaven. Say’s trial is scheduled for October, and if convicted, the pianist faces up to 18 months in prison. The irony is not lost on those Turks who remember how Erdogan himself was imprisoned in 1998, when he was mayor of Istanbul, for reading out a provocative poem.

  Erdogan, re-elected as prime minister for the second time in June last year and now considered the most powerful Turkish leader since Kemal Ataturk, has become intolerant of criticism and seems bent on crushing domestic opposition.

  “He is Putinesque,” said Karli, referring to reports that Erdogan plans to emulate the Russian leader’s switch from prime minister to president and thereby become the longest-serving leader in Turkish history.

  “Yes, he wins elections, but he does not respect the rights of those who do not vote [for] or support him,” Karli said.

  Let’s be clear: Turkey in the pre-Erdogan era was no liberal democratic nirvana. Since its creation in 1923, the republic has had to endure three military coups against elected governments: in 1960, 1971, and 1980. The AKP government is the first to succeed in neutering the military. And its paranoia is not wholly unjustified: Turkey’s constitutional court was just one vote from banning the AKP in 2008, and a series of alleged anti-government plots and conspiracies were exposed in 2010 and last year.

  “I am concerned by the numbers [of imprisoned journalists] but they’re not all innocent,” AKP Member of Parliament Nursuna Memecan said. “Many of them were plotting against the government.”

  It’s a line echoed by her party leader.

  “It is hard for Western countries to understand the problem because they do not have journalists who engage in coup attempts and who support and invite coups,” Erdogan said in a speech in January.

  Perhaps, but the AKP’s crackdown on dissent, on basic freedoms of speech and expression, has gone beyond all civilized norms.

  “We do need to expand free speech in Turkey,” Memecan said.

  Those of us who have long argued that elected Islamist parties should not be denied the opportunity to govern invested great hope in Erdogan and the AKP.

  However, what I discovered in Istanbul is that there is still a long way to go.

  The truth is that Turkey cannot be the model, the template, for post-revolutionary, Muslim-majority countries like Tunisia and Egypt until it first gets its own house in order. To inspire freedom abroad, the Turkish government must first guarantee freedom at home.

  Mehdi Hasan is senior editor (politics) at the New Statesman magazine.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Ministry lifts overseas limits on TSMC

  • 2

    New missiles to be deployed in north

  • 3

    Chinese spy prosecutions tripled in four years

  • 4

    TSMC has begun 4-nm chip production in US, official says

  • 5

    Snowfall a reminder of former ski resort on Hehuanshan