Taiwan has finally got something it has been trying to get for a long time — the right to take part in the World Health Assembly (WHA). Having achieved something the preceding Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) government could not, President Ma Ying-jeou’s (馬英九) administration announced the development with an air of triumph.
While this may be good news for the government, the opposition has raised a number of questions. Was observer status awarded to Taiwan because of a secret memorandum of understanding (MOU) between China and the WHO? What conditions did the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Chinese Communist Party (CCP) agree on in the course of their secret negotiations with the WHO? What exactly is Taiwan’s status in the WHA and in regard to the International Health Regulations (IHR)?
But the main concern for the DPP is this: Did Taiwan have to sacrifice its sovereignty to join the WHA?
The Ma team’s response has, of course, been “no.”
They say the important thing is to take part, and the negotiating process is nothing to be concerned about. The government claims the negotiations could not be made public because this is the “usual international practice.”
They assure us that Taiwan’s status in the WHA will be the same as other observers, who also receive invitations to the annual assemblies.
As Ma’s team combines conceit with an air of mystery, China is being intentionally low key, which only serves to fuel doubts in the DPP. But the misgivings of opposition politicians can be dispelled quite easily.
The WHA is attended by a number of observers every year. Contrary to what the Ma team claims, however, they do not all have the same status. In fact, their status differs considerably.
In the first category are governments with some level of sovereignty. The Holy See is a country but not a member country of the WHO. The Order of Malta was made a permanent observer by a resolution of the assembly, and it enjoys sovereign status.
The other kind of observer includes the International Committee of the Red Cross, the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies and the Inter-Parliamentary Union, which are all NGOs. Then there is the Palestinian Authority, whose status falls somewhere between the two categories.
During emergencies such as the SARS and enterovirus outbreaks, the WHO got a lot of help from the US, whose Centers for Disease Control have greater resources than the WHO does. Taiwan’s healthcare system, like that in the US, is solidly established and well resourced. That being the case, Taiwan does not need much help in disease prevention.
So the main reason we want to attend the WHA and join the WHO is to promote the definition of Taiwan’s international status.
If Taiwan were to seek the same status as the Holy See, China would naturally intervene and block this from happening. On the other hand, joining as an NGO would negate Taiwan’s sovereignty.
Taking part under such conditions would be more damaging to our sovereignty than not participating. At the least, what Taiwan should strive for, as with the Palestinian Authority, is to be invited to take part by a resolution of the assembly, and not to be invited to attend as an NGO each year by the WHO director-general, whom China controls.
It would be worse still if Taiwan were listed not just as an NGO, but as a Chinese one.
Ma’s team has kept quiet about what Taiwan’s status will be, as well as about what went on during negotiations and whether Taiwan will be subservient to China in the IHR. Ma and his colleagues are attempting to justify this secrecy by reference to “international practice.”
The government should move quickly to dispel doubts about this “practice.” Negotiations held entirely in secret are only justifiable when two countries are talking about how to deal with a common enemy.
The KMT and the CCP are engaged in secret diplomacy and are keeping the process and core content to themselves. Who are they hiding it from? The US? Japan? The EU? Obviously not. The DPP? That would be getting closer.
The truth is that they are hiding it from the Taiwanese public.
Are the KMT and CCP really so wary about ordinary Taiwanese? If not, why would they be so cagey about how Taiwan has received access to the WHA and the IHR? It should be welcome news, so what is there to hide?
Ma and his colleagues hate it when anyone suggests that they might sell out Taiwan.
Dispelling such doubts and weakening the government’s detractors would be a simple task: All they have to do is clarify the following points.
1. Now that Taiwan can take part in the WHA and the IHR, there should be no need for a secret MOU between China and the WHO on helping Taiwan take part. Will the MOU now be disregarded?
2. Is Taiwan’s Department of Health, which is designated to deal with the IHR, listed as being under Chinese authority?
3. Is Taiwan’s status in the WHA that of an NGO? This would injure Taiwan’s sovereign status. Will the government therefore release the list of Taiwan’s participants?
It would not take much effort to clarify these details. In fact, it is the government’s duty to do so.
If, on the other hand, the government refuses to reveal the facts and continues to play games with public opinion, then it should not be surprised if people come to distrust and resent it.
If, as some people suspect, Ma’s team has paid for the right to attend the WHA by downgrading this nation’s sovereign status, then the consequences will be a lot worse than this.
Lin Cho-shui is a former Democratic Progressive Party legislator.
TRANSLATED BY JULIAN CLEGG
Minister of Labor Hung Sun-han (洪申翰) on April 9 said that the first group of Indian workers could arrive as early as this year as part of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the Taipei Economic and Cultural Center in India and the India Taipei Association. Signed in February 2024, the MOU stipulates that Taipei would decide the number of migrant workers and which industries would employ them, while New Delhi would manage recruitment and training. Employment would be governed by the laws of both countries. Months after its signing, the two sides agreed that 1,000 migrant workers from India would
In recent weeks, Taiwan has witnessed a surge of public anxiety over the possible introduction of Indian migrant workers. What began as a policy signal from the Ministry of Labor quickly escalated into a broader controversy. Petitions gathered thousands of signatures within days, political figures issued strong warnings, and social media became saturated with concerns about public safety and social stability. At first glance, this appears to be a straightforward policy question: Should Taiwan introduce Indian migrant workers or not? However, this framing is misleading. The current debate is not fundamentally about India. It is about Taiwan’s labor system, its
On March 31, the South Korean Ministry of Foreign Affairs released declassified diplomatic records from 1995 that drew wide domestic media attention. One revelation stood out: North Korea had once raised the possibility of diplomatic relations with Taiwan. In a meeting with visiting Chinese officials in May 1995, as then-Chinese president Jiang Zemin (江澤民) prepared for a visit to South Korea, North Korean officials objected to Beijing’s growing ties with Seoul and raised Taiwan directly. According to the newly released records, North Korean officials asked why Pyongyang should refrain from developing relations with Taiwan while China and South Korea were expanding high-level
Japan’s imminent easing of arms export rules has sparked strong interest from Warsaw to Manila, Reuters reporting found, as US President Donald Trump wavers on security commitments to allies, and the wars in Iran and Ukraine strain US weapons supplies. Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s ruling party approved the changes this week as she tries to invigorate the pacifist country’s military industrial base. Her government would formally adopt the new rules as soon as this month, three Japanese government officials told Reuters. Despite largely isolating itself from global arms markets since World War II, Japan spends enough on its own
RSS