There is no proof that individualized herbal medicines do any good but a significant risk that they do harm, according to a study published on Thursday.
The study's author, Peter Canter, of the Peninsula medical school in Exeter, believes they should be banned. He says herbalists are promoting their individualized remedies -- cocktails of up to 20 different herbs mixed for specific customers -- on the back of the real evidence on the effect of standardized doses of single herbs such as St John's wort for depression.
He and his colleague, Edzard Ernst, also have concerns about the single herb extracts sold in health food shops and on the shelves of high street chemists. Those that work for conditions including heart disease or depression are powerful medicines and could do damage by interacting with conventional drugs. They should only be prescribed by qualified medical practitioners.
"In my view, self-medication for serious conditions is out of the question," said Ernst. "A depressed patient who takes St John's wort and comes out of depression arguably gathers enough strength to commit suicide, so it is dangerous."
But the UK market in over-the-counter herbal medicines is huge -- worth ?191 million (US$390 million) in the last year -- and is growing rapidly. "It is being promoted every single weekend in UK newspapers by health writers of, I think, dubious repute," he said.
The Prince of Wales, who has a foundation to support complementary medicine, had also had an impact, he said, and so had the 40 million Web sites selling herbal products.
Canter's review, published in Thursday's Postgraduate Medical Journal, found there was an almost total absence of evidence for any benefit from the tailored herbal cocktails prepared by herbalists, including traditional Chinese medicine and Ayurvedic practitioners.
At least 1,000 herbalists are registered in the UK, but many more are unregistered, said Canter. Anyone can set themselves up as a herbalist.
"They make a mixture of herbs individually tailored for you. Often it is made in the back of the shop or clinic. They claim to have an evidence base, so our study was to look at how much evidence there is," he said.
It found hardly any, he said -- even after writing to 15 organizations representing herbalists asking for evidence. Out of 1,300 papers in the scientific literature, only three were properly controlled, randomized trials and one of those was as yet unpublished. In the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee and the relief of cancer chemotherapy side-effects, the herbal mixtures did not work at all. In irritable bowel syndrome, they were better than nothing, but the patients who did best were those on a standardized herbal medicine, not on an individualized cocktail.
The UK drug regulator, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Authority (MHRA), has been looking at herbal medicine, and statutory regulation for herbalists is imminent. Other areas where changes may be made are in manufacturing and import licenses.
Canter said he was concerned about possible harm from individualized herbal medicine. "There are risks in the actual materials in the remedies," he said. "Some are inherently toxic herbs."
There had been "numerous cases" of banned toxic herbs such as aristoclia, which causes cancer, turning up in individualized herbal medicines, he said. There have been well-documented cases of Chinese herbal remedies containing prescription drugs or being polluted by agrochemicals. There was also a danger that some herbs in the cocktail could interact with drugs prescribed by a medical doctor.
He had further concerns that herbalists were not always trained to spot the "red flag signs" of serious disease which meant they must refer the patient to a doctor, and that they might not know how to treat the patient if they suffered serious side-effects from the herbal remedy.
Ann Walker, director of the British Herbal Medicines Association, insisted that most herbalists were well-trained and knew when to refer patients. She said herbalists took a three or four-year degree course before accreditation.
She acknowledged the lack of proof of efficacy for individualized herbal medicine. "The evidence is scanty because the studies have only recently been started," she said. This did not mean there was no efficacy.
Kim Lavely, chief executive of the Prince of Wales' Foundation for Integrated Medicine, said it did not promote complementary medicine or comment on individual treatments. "But we would certainly endorse the conclusion that there is not enough evidence around the effectiveness of this or many of the most popular complementary therapies," she said. "We're working very hard to try to build up the evidence base."
With escalating US-China competition and mutual distrust, the trend of supply chain “friend shoring” in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic and the fragmentation of the world into rival geopolitical blocs, many analysts and policymakers worry the world is retreating into a new cold war — a world of trade bifurcation, protectionism and deglobalization. The world is in a new cold war, said Robin Niblett, former director of the London-based think tank Chatham House. Niblett said he sees the US and China slowly reaching a modus vivendi, but it might take time. The two great powers appear to be “reversing carefully
Taiwan is facing multiple economic challenges due to internal and external pressures. Internal challenges include energy transition, upgrading industries, a declining birthrate and an aging population. External challenges are technology competition between the US and China, international supply chain restructuring and global economic uncertainty. All of these issues complicate Taiwan’s economic situation. Taiwan’s reliance on fossil fuel imports not only threatens the stability of energy supply, but also goes against the global trend of carbon reduction. The government should continue to promote renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power, as well as energy storage technology, to diversify energy supply. It
Former Japanese minister of defense Shigeru Ishiba has been elected as president of the governing Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) and would be approved as prime minister in parliament today. Ishiba is a familiar face for Taiwanese, as he has visited the nation several times. His popularity among Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) lawmakers has grown as a result of his multiple meetings and encounters with legislators and prominent figures in the government. The DPP and the LDP have close ties and have long maintained warm relations. Ishiba in August 2020 praised Taiwan’s
On Thursday last week, the International Crisis Group (ICG) issued a well-researched report titled “The Widening Schism across the Taiwan Strait,” which focused on rising tensions between Taiwan and China, making a number of recommendations on how to avoid conflict. While it is of course laudable that a respected international organization such as the ICG is willing to think through possible avenues toward a peaceful resolution, the report contains a couple of fundamental flaws in the way it approaches the issue. First, it attempts to present a “balanced approach” by pushing back equally against Taiwan’s perceived transgressions as against Beijing’s military threats
RSS