In 1995, before the handover of Hong Kong to China, Time magazine's sister magazine Fortune published a special report titled The death of Hong Kong.
Early last month, on the eve of the 10th anniversary of Hong Kong's handover, Time did some research and retracted Fortune's 1995 commentary, saying "Hong Kong is more alive than ever."
Late last month, Fortune also published an article saying: "Oops! Hong Kong is hardly dead," and declaring the magazine's prediction as wrong. Leaving aside the issue of whether the political situation is getting worse, how is Hong Kong's economy doing?
When people examine Hong Kong's "liveliness," they often only look at its stock market. It's true that the Hong Kong stock market index and market turnover reached a new high this year and that it has profited from investment in China. But the stock market cannot represent the situation of the entire economy, and especially not the impact of Chinese policies.
Listed Chinese companies are conducting a lot of shady business. In 2003, Liu Jinbao (
This influenced share prices and people who had been in the know were able to make a lot of money out of it. The "double regulations" is a phenomenon unique to China that influences Hong Kong's status as an international financial center.
The nominal GDP per capita reported by the IMF for 1997 and last year were US$27,055 and US$27,466 respectively for Hong Kong, and US$13,835 and US$15,482 respectively for Taiwan, meaning that Hong Kong's growth has not kept up with Taiwan's.
The report that Hong Kong's Hang Seng Bank published at the end of last month said that Hong Kong's economy is reviving.
But there are still problems. The unemployment rate is twice as high as 10 years ago.
Hong Kong's Census and Statistics Department last month reported a Gini coefficient that reflected a vastly unequal distribution of wealth in Hong Kong. It reached a historical high of 0.533, the highest of the "four Asian tigers."
The median household income last year was HK$17,250 (US$2,200), which is HK$250 less than the HK$17,500 it was in 1996.
The gap between high and low income groups is widening. In 1996, 6.7 percent of households had a monthly income of around HK$4,000. Last year, this grew to 9.2 percent, while the number of households with an income of more than HK$40,000 increased from 15 percent to 17 percent.
Information from hospital management offices shows that the number of patients in psychiatric sections of public hospitals has risen by 90 percent. Among the causes cited are the ups and downs of the economy and the psychological pressure this entails.
Politicians and media who keep saying that Taiwan's economy is on the decline and that the nation should open more to China would do well to give these figures some serious thought.
It should also be noted that China and Hong Kong signing the Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement (CEPA) in 2003 gave Hong Kong many advantages. This year saw a fourth agreement, implementing 40 new measures for opening up more. Open travel between Hong Kong and China has been a reality for four years.
For Taiwanese politicians who claim opening up to China would provide a surefire boost to the economy, consider this: Under the powerful control of China and with open economic ties, Hong Kong's economic growth rate is lower than that of Taiwan. How alive is Hong Kong? Economically, Hong Kong is becoming more and more dependent on China.
That is why Chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress Wu Bangguo (
This statement is not only true of Hong Kong's politics, but also of its economy. That's why Milton Friedman, winner of the 1976 Nobel Prize for Economics, wrote in the Asia Wall Street Journal last October that Hong Kong's free economy was dead.
Paul Lin is a political commentator based in Taipei.
Translated by Anna Stiggelbout
The first Donald Trump term was a boon for Taiwan. The administration regularized the arms sales process and enhanced bilateral ties. Taipei will not be so fortunate the second time around. Given recent events, Taiwan must proceed with the assumption that it cannot count on the United States to defend it — diplomatically or militarily — during the next four years. Early indications suggested otherwise. The nomination of Marco Rubio as US Secretary of State and the appointment of Mike Waltz as the national security advisor, both of whom have expressed full-throated support for Taiwan in the past, raised hopes that
Whether in terms of market commonality or resource similarity, South Korea’s Samsung Electronics Co is the biggest competitor of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC). The two companies have agreed to set up factories in the US and are also recipients of subsidies from the US CHIPS and Science Act, which was signed into law by former US president Joe Biden. However, changes in the market competitiveness of the two companies clearly reveal the context behind TSMC’s investments in the US. As US semiconductor giant Intel Corp has faced continuous delays developing its advanced processes, the world’s two major wafer foundries, TSMC and
There is nothing the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) could do to stop the tsunami-like mass recall campaign. KMT Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫) reportedly said the party does not exclude the option of conditionally proposing a no-confidence vote against the premier, which the party later denied. Did an “actuary” like Chu finally come around to thinking it should get tough with the ruling party? The KMT says the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) is leading a minority government with only a 40 percent share of the vote. It has said that the DPP is out of touch with the electorate, has proposed a bloated
Authorities last week revoked the residency permit of a Chinese social media influencer surnamed Liu (劉), better known by her online channel name Yaya in Taiwan (亞亞在台灣), who has more than 440,000 followers online and is living in Taiwan with a marriage-based residency permit, for her “reunification by force” comments. She was asked to leave the country in 10 days. The National Immigration Agency (NIA) on Tuesday last week announced the decision, citing the influencer’s several controversial public comments, including saying that “China does not need any other reason to reunify Taiwan with force” and “why is it [China] hesitant
RSS