Like oil, radio spectrum is one of the world's dwindling resources. Why else would five mobile operators have paid the equivalent of US$40 billion for 3G licenses in the UK in 2000, if they didn't think it was a rarity?
Tightly controlled by regulators in each country, spectrum is required by radio and TV broadcasts and mobile-phone networks, microwave ovens, home wireless networks, hospital x-ray machines, satellites, cordless phones, Bluetooth computer keyboards and garage door-openers. And, as Mark Twain said of land, they're not building any more of it.
The explosion in wireless computing and mobile devices has placed even greater strain on this scarce natural resource -- so much so that last week, the US-based Tech CEO Council issued a report, stating: "There are few more important natural resources than our radio spectrum.
An increasingly essential platform for how we work, live, play and learn, radio spectrum may be the most critical infrastructure element of 21st century economies."
The council's idea of a solution to scarcity in the US is for the government there to give up some government-held spectrum to private companies, which, they argue, will use it more productively.
But across the Atlantic, a research group based at Trinity College Dublin, partnering with Bell Labs, has a different approach: spectrum-hopping, or dynamic spectrum allocation. Operators could hop across the frequencies, utilizing unused or underused spectrum.
Scarce resource
"Spectrum is considered a scarce resource," notes Linda Doyle, who leads the spectrum research group within TCD's Center for Telecommunications Value-chain Research (CTVR).
"But some of that scarcity is actually a false scarcity, because spectrum isn't efficiently used," she said.
She displays a chart of spectrum use in London over a 24-hour period, with heavy use marked in red bands, and blue bands indicating no activity. Perhaps 70 percent of the chart is blue.
The US Federal Communication Commission has stated that about 90 percent of spectrum is underutilized, she said.
Most of the congested areas indicate usage in the more desirable spectrum bands. Certain frequencies are valued by some industries because they enable better signal quality or strength -- mobile and TV operators -- or conversely, enable a signal to be received over a longer distance -- shortwave radio broadcasts -- where distance is valued. But even within the very congested bands, not all are used at capacity all the time, and spectrum-hopping is seen as a possible solution as more devices and services clamor for a slice of spectrum.
The central piece of virtual equipment needed for the experiment is what Doyle calls a software radio -- "a bucket of software components that can be put together in many different ways," Doyle said.
This makes the software element highly flexible. For example, it would enable a single device using the software to be marketed in multiple geographies. Now, devices such as mobile phones generally have to be manufactured separately for each region, at greater cost and lower efficiency. The software could be used in any device that uses spectrum, whether passively (to receive) or actively (sending and/or receiving), from handhelds to mobiles to radios to television sets.
What makes the TCD-Bell Labs collaboration unusual is that, in a unique arrangement with Irish communications regulator ComReg, their researchers have been granted a 50MHz swath of spectrum for an experimental software radio license to conduct live experiments. By contrast, the entire FM radio broadcast band in Ireland is 20MHz.
Until now, nobody has been able to experiment with live spectrum, said Donal O'Mahony, director of CTVR. Research groups worldwide have been working in the area of spectrum-hopping for some time, but have had to use computer simulations.
Doyle said there isn't another regulator in the world that has been willing (or able) to grant spectrum for this kind of use. When, at a recent conference, she mentioned the grant to Michael Gallagher, the assistant secretary for communications and information of the US National Telecommunications and Information Administration, "he nearly fell off his chair," she said.
Isolde Goggin, the chair of ComReg, said it was able to offer the spectrum under its "test and trial" research and development program because Ireland "is in a fairly fortunate position": a low population density means there is a lot of uncongested spectrum, and being an island on the western edge of Europe means the spectrum is cleanly isolated from neighboring countries and the experiments are unlikely to cause interference. And it's not a NATO member, so the military won't complain.
New approach
For the same reason, Ireland has more spectrum available than countries with a large military.
Goggin said that ComReg made the decision "to turn spectrum allocation around from a restrictive approach, to saying if we can do it, we will."
Doyle said spectrum-hopping would require a complete rethink of how commercial-use spectrum is allocated and paid for. Rather than a licensing system that lets operators control a fiefdom of spectrum -- the current model, which the Tech CEO Council would like to see expanded -- spectrum-hopping would be more like a frequency timeshare.
One aspect of the research will be to consider the issue of management as well as potential business models, she said.
Goggin notes that hopping is only one possibility for the way spectrum management might develop.
However, "The consensus is that the current model has to change," she said.
Regulators worldwide are moving away from the notion that the regulator's role is to imagine what future uses of spectrum might be, and then reserve chunks for those uses.
"That approach is not very well able to cope with unpredictable fluctuations in demand,'' Goggin said.
Other options for better spectrum management include: ultrawideband (UWB) technology where, rather than hopping around, a signal is broken into incredibly short pieces and simultaneously spread over an enormously wide frequency band, allowing numerous signals to share the same bandwidth at slightly different times; mesh networks, where numerous individual devices form large, ad hoc networks for passing signals around; and new technologies that minimize interference.
Goggin said she imagines a mix of these approaches are likely.
The Irish hope their ability to give researchers access to spectrum will attract investment as well as create opportunities for local companies.
"Because Ireland is an island, it can be a playground for spectrum," Doyle said.
But Goggin has even bigger dreams.
"This could be Ireland's oil," she said.
In a stark reminder of China’s persistent territorial overreach, Pema Wangjom Thongdok, a woman from Arunachal Pradesh holding an Indian passport, was detained for 18 hours at Shanghai Pudong Airport on Nov. 24 last year. Chinese immigration officials allegedly informed her that her passport was “invalid” because she was “Chinese,” refusing to recognize her Indian citizenship and claiming Arunachal Pradesh as part of South Tibet. Officials had insisted that Thongdok, an Indian-origin UK resident traveling for a conference, was not Indian despite her valid documents. India lodged a strong diplomatic protest, summoning the Chinese charge d’affaires in Delhi and demanding
With the Year of the Snake reaching its conclusion on Monday next week, now is an opportune moment to reflect on the past year — a year marked by institutional strain and national resilience. For Taiwan, the Year of the Snake was a composite of political friction, economic momentum, social unease and strategic consolidation. In the political sphere, it was defined less by legislative productivity and more by partisan confrontation. The mass recall movement sought to remove 31 Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislators following the passage of controversial bills that expanded legislative powers and imposed sweeping budget cuts. While the effort
When Hong Kong’s High Court sentenced newspaper owner Jimmy Lai (黎智英) to 20 years in prison this week, officials declared that his “heinous crimes” had long poisoned society and that his punishment represented justice restored. In their telling, Lai is the mastermind of Hong Kong’s unrest — the architect of a vast conspiracy that manipulated an otherwise contented population into defiance. They imply that removing him would lead to the return of stability. It is a politically convenient narrative — and a profoundly false one. Lai did not radicalize Hong Kong. He belonged to the same generation that fled from the Chinese
There is a story in India about a boy called Prahlad who was an ardent worshipper of Lord Narayana, whom his father considered an enemy. His son’s devotion vexed the father to the extent that he asked his sister, Holika, who could not be burned by fire, to sit with the boy in her lap and burn him to death. Prahlad knew about this evil plan, but sat in his aunt’s lap anyway. His faith won, as he remained unscathed by the fire, while his aunt was devoured by the flames. In some small way, Prahlad reminds me of Taiwan
RSS