On the heels of International Human Rights Day, the Council of Grand Justices handed down Interpretation 535 of the Consti-tution, a ruling which may express human rights guarantees. Though justice is late in coming, its arrival is nonetheless worthy of celebration. However, the interpretation is not entirely clear.
Legally speaking, any laws by which the government limits people's rights, or increases their obligations, must be enacted through legislation. While the Police Duties Regulations (警察勤務條例) is a special law, its legislative basis is the Police Law (警察 法), which contains no articles authorizing police to conduct warrantless searches and seizures. The 29 articles in the Police Duties Regulations are basically just administrative regulations.
When organizational rules are used as the basis for the external exercise of police power, the officers' authority to act and the legal force of their action are clearly in doubt. It creates problems and easily gives rise to acts that intrude on the rights of those being searched.
Interpretation 535 should have clearly declared those articles of the Police Duties Regulations regarding warrantless searches and seizures unconstitutional. Legislation governing such actions should be enacted in law, in order to give them a legal basis.
The grand justices wrote that "... the execution of warrantless police searches, constitutes search of and interference with persons and their belongings, greatly affecting the people's right to freedom of movement, property and privacy." Nevertheless, it is questionable the way the interpretation tolerates existing abuses of power by calling for "a total review and amendment [of the law] in accordance with this interpretation within two years of the official release of the interpretation."
Police have conducted warrantless search and seizures for years. Spot questioning and searches -- even indulging in ridicule, threats and displays of bad attitude -- have led to public distain for the police. To date, not a single officer has been tried and found guilty of such acts.
But it is not just the police. Although the justices' interpretation is a start, no law can enforce itself. Any attempt to redress the corrupt practice in warrantless search and seizure should at least stress the following:
One, regulations on warrantless police searches and seizures should be quickly enacted and detail the requirements needed for permission to be given for such actions. An administrative procedure for warrantless searches and seizures should be implemented that would require the police to present their IDs, give the reason for such action, tell suspects their rights and maintain decorum during searches. Written notices should also be given to those who are unhappy with a search action, which clearly state the administrative remedies and legal channels available.
Two, regulations should also be enacted regulate media access to raids and seizures. Police officers often invite reporters and photographers to observe search actions as a way of building up their personal reputations. But reporters have been known to forget that they are supposed to be neutral observers and, as a result, they trample on human rights. There have been far too many occasions when reporters or camerapeople have gotten into verbal disputes with the targets of a raid, putting additional pressure on those who refuse to comply with searches. In order to establish a neutral role for journalists, the Journalist Law (新聞記者法), which was frozen in 1945, should be updated and re-enacted.
Judges and prosecutors should also not gloss over abuses by police. Impartiality is the pillar on which a society ruled by law ultimately rests.
The public's ignorance of the law is a key factors contributing to the abuse of police powers. Taiwan's educational system -- even at the university level -- provides almost no instruction on the law and civil rights. Such classes were once compulsory for university students, but the Ministry of Education eliminated the requirement, and, as a result, many students display a shocking level of ignorance and indifference towards the law.
Conducting warrantless searches and seizures is the most challenging of all police duties. Unless such actions are handled skillfully, they can lead to conflicts with the public and waste societal resources. Current police procedures are in need of urgent review.
Legalizing the procedures for warrantless searches and seizures would provide the public with human rights guarantees. It is also the only effective means to preserve police authority.
Hsu Chen-yuan is a professor at the Institute of Public Adminis-tration and Policy of Nan Hua University.
Translated by Scudder Smith
Although former US secretary of state Mike Pompeo — known for being the most pro-Taiwan official to hold the post — is not in the second administration of US president-elect Donald Trump, he has maintained close ties with the former president and involved himself in think tank activities, giving him firsthand knowledge of the US’ national strategy. On Monday, Pompeo visited Taiwan for the fourth time, attending a Formosa Republican Association’s forum titled “Towards Permanent World Peace: The Shared Mission of the US and Taiwan.” At the event, he reaffirmed his belief in Taiwan’s democracy, liberty, human rights and independence, highlighting a
The US Department of Defense recently released this year’s “Report on Military and Security Developments Involving the People’s Republic of China.” This annual report provides a comprehensive overview of China’s military capabilities, strategic objectives and evolving global ambitions. Taiwan features prominently in this year’s report, as capturing the nation remains central to Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) vision of the “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation,” a goal he has set for 2049. The report underscores Taiwan’s critical role in China’s long-term strategy, highlighting its significance as a geopolitical flashpoint and a key target in China’s quest to assert dominance
The Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) last week released the latest job vacancy data in Taiwan, which highlighted how many job openings firms had yet to be filled at the end of August last year. The data also revealed how the vacant positions were closely related to the business climate that industrial and services sectors faced at the time. The DGBAS collects data on job vacancies at the end of February, May, August and November every year. The number of job vacancies includes recruits for expanding operations and additional production lines as well as for openings related to
The Legislative Yuan passed legislation on Tuesday aimed at supporting the middle-aged generation — defined as people aged 55 or older willing and able to work — in a law initially proposed by Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Legislator Wu Chun-cheng (吳春城) to help the nation transition from an aged society to a super-aged society. The law’s passage was celebrated by the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the TPP. The brief show of unity was welcome news, especially after 10 months of political fighting and unconstitutional amendments that are damaging democracy and the constitutional order, eliciting concern
RSS