A startup that threatens to shake up the US television industry with mini antennas for Internet viewing and recording was the object of heated debate on Tuesday at the US Supreme Court.
A powerful coalition of the broadcast and cable TV industries asked the panel to rule against the startup, Aereo Inc, which allows customers to rent a tiny Internet-linked antenna to watch or record over-the-air broadcasts, raising difficult copyright questions.
A similarly strong alliance that includes several technology firms and consumer groups is pressing for a different outcome, saying a ruling for Aereo would send a signal in favor of technological innovation.
At stake are billions of dollars in fees paid by cable and satellite firms, which Aereo circumvents, in what could be the most significant copyright case in decades.
Justices appeared ambivalent at times, questioning whether Aereo was violating copyright law and mulling a possible impact on the burgeoning cloud computing sector, which stores all kinds of materials online.
US Justice Stephen Breyer queried what might happen if Aereo were found to be in violation.
“Are we somehow affecting other things such as the cloud?” he asked attorney Paul Clement, arguing on behalf of the plaintiffs including ABC television, the National Association of Broadcasters, Time Warner and others. “I don’t see how you get out of it.”
US Justice Samuel Alito offered a similar view, saying: “I want to know what impact this will have on other technology.”
Aereo, which is backed by media mogul Barry Diller, launched in early 2012 in the New York area and was immediately sued by the major broadcast networks — ABC, NBC, CBS and Fox — for copyright infringement. The company, which is expanding to other cities, claims its actions are legal because it is not rebroadcasting, but giving subscribers a personal antenna in its New York warehouse that enables them to watch live TV or record it for later viewing.
A US appeals court panel agreed with Aereo, ruling it was not retransmitting “public performances,” which would be banned under copyright law, but merely allowing customers to rent antennas to receive and record free broadcasts.
Clement urged the justices to put aside the issue of cloud computing and simply consider the copyright issue — claiming Aereo gets around royalty fees that similar services such as cable must pay.
“There is a fundamental difference between a company that provides an ongoing service to the public and an online locker,” the attorney said.
However, US Chief Justice John Roberts pondered the Aereo argument that it was merely renting equipment that a consumer could use legally.
“You can go to Radio Shack and buy an antenna and a DVR [digital video recorder], or you could rent those facilities somewhere else from Aereo,” he said.
This point was emphasized by attorney David Frederick, arguing for Aereo.
“We are not a cable service,” he said. “Aereo is an equipment provider.”
The lawyer said Aereo allows consumers “to replicate in the cloud what they could do on their own.”
While the justices expressed concern about impacting the cloud industry, some also voiced skepticism about whether Aereo was designed as a ruse to evade retransmission fees.
“Your technological model is based solely on circumventing legal prohibitions that you don’t want to comply with,” Roberts said.
Much of the debate centered on whether Aereo was in fact transmitting a signal, which would be a “public performance” under copyright law and not a private way of shifting the viewing of a program — the subject of a landmark 1984 ruling on Sony and its Betamax recorders.
The US government, backing the broadcasters, argued that Aereo is in fact a transmission service and violates US copyright law.
US Deputy Solicitor General Malcolm Stewart told the justices Aereo is similar to cable television that uses “one big antenna” and “ought to be paying royalties.”
Breyer said that even if one concedes the notion of public performance, he was at a loss in how to craft an opinion that fails to impact cloud computing.
The National Football League and Major League Baseball have backed the broadcasters, claiming it would upset longstanding copyright traditions.
And some broadcast executives have threatened to end over-the-air transmissions, which would force consumers to watch those channels on cable or satellite. The Computer and Communications Industry Association, which represents tech giants Google, Facebook and Yahoo, is supporting Aereo.
“The case has ramifications reaching far beyond the future of Aereo and change-resistant broadcasters,” Computer and Communications Industry Association president Ed Black said.
“It’s about the future of an essential aspect of Internet commerce: cloud computing,” he said.
The justices are expected to issue a ruling by the end of June.
HSBC Holdings PLC is deepening its commitment to Taiwan as the economy emerges as one of the bank’s fastest-growing markets globally, driven by an artificial intelligence (AI) investment boom, expanding cross-border trade, and rising wealth creation. “The advantage that Taiwan has is a growth story linked to the semiconductor and broader AI industries, strong underlying corporate performance, and wealth creation,” said Surendra Rosha, HSBC’s co-chief executive for Asia and the Middle East, in an exclusive interview with the Taipei Times on June 2, during this year’s HSBC Taiwan Conference. That combination has helped HSBC cement its position as the most profitable international
Taiwanese firms have increased investment in the Philippines in recent years as Manila’s ties with Washington deepen and global supply chains continue to shift away from China, an expert at the Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research (CIER, 中華經濟研究院) said yesterday. The Philippines had not been among Taiwanese investors’ top choices in Southeast Asia, CIER Taiwan ASEAN Studies Center director Kristy Hsu (徐遵慈) said at a seminar in Taipei. However, Taiwan’s investment in the country has grown significantly since the COVID-19 pandemic, reaching US $257 million last year, a high in recent years, she said. Although Taiwan’s total investment in the Philippines still lags
Intel Corp regards Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) as a longstanding partner, as the US chipmaker would continue outsourcing production of advanced chips to TSMC, Intel chief executive officer Lip-Bu Tan (陳立武) said yesterday. “I don’t look at people as competitors. I look at the collaboration... Nvidia is also, you know, a good friend,” Tan told a news conference following his keynote speech at the Computex trade show in Taipei. “It’s a very trusted partnership for us... We are a big, top customer for them, and we’re going to continue doing that,” he said, referring to TSMC, the world’s largest foundry
Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密) yesterday said it would work with US chipmaker Intel Corp to jointly develop and deploy next-generation artificial intelligence (AI) infrastructure and intelligent computing platforms in a move to capture booming demand for AI computing systems. Hon Hai, also known as Foxconn Technology Group (富士康), said in a statement that the partnership would combine its global manufacturing scale, system integration expertise and AI data center deployment capabilities with Intel’s strengths in processor architecture, silicon technologies and software ecosystem. The companies said they plan to work on equipment used in AI data centers, including server racks powered by
RSS