An industrial espionage trial between Oracle Corp and SAP AG, two of the world’s biggest business software makers, ended on Friday without the testimony of one of its most anticipated witnesses.
The evidence part of the three-week trial wrapped up on Friday without an in-person appearance by the new CEO of Hewlett--Packard Co (HP), Leo Apotheker, and without Oracle playing a videotaped deposition he gave.
The cat-and-mouse game of Oracle trying to force Apotheker to testify, and HP refusing to allow it, has captivated technology watchers and overshadowed Apotheker’s start as head of the world’s biggest technology company by revenue.
Oracle wanted Apotheker to testify because he was previously SAP’s CEO.
However, Oracle says that HP refused to accept a subpoena on Apotheker’s behalf. HP accused Oracle of harassing Apotheker.
Oracle hired investigators to track down Apotheker, but since he started the HP job on Nov. 1, he wasn’t spotted close enough to the federal courthouse in Oakland, where the case is being tried, for Oracle to serve him with the subpoena.
The subpoena only applies within 161km of the courthouse, which includes HP’s headquarters in Palo Alto.
HP hasn’t disclosed Apotheker’s whereabouts. Representatives have repeatedly said that the company doesn’t discuss its executives’ travel plans.
Oracle is demanding billions of dollars in damages from SAP for software and customer support documents that SAP has admitted to stealing. SAP claims it owes only US$40 million. Closing arguments are expected next week.
HP got roped into the mess when it hired Apotheker to replace HP’s former CEO, Mark Hurd, who was ousted after a sexual-harassment investigation.
Oracle insists that Apotheker oversaw the scheme at SAP. An Oracle lawyer, David Boies, said after Friday’s hearing that Apotheker’s videotaped deposition wasn’t shown because it was taken two years ago, before SAP admitted to the theft. HP has said Apotheker had limited knowledge about the matter.
Oracle has already reaped a public relations bonanza from Apotheker’s absence. The company is using it as another way to attack HP as the companies’ longtime friendship has turned frosty over Oracle’s entry into the HP stronghold of selling computer servers. Earlier, Oracle CEO Larry Ellison blasted HP for firing Hurd and promptly hired him to serve as an Oracle co-president.
HP is scheduled to report quarterly earnings tomorrow. Investors are awaiting commentary from Apotheker about his strategy for the company. HP is the world’s biggest maker of personal computers and printers.
Three experts in the high technology industry have said that US President Donald Trump’s pledge to impose higher tariffs on Taiwanese semiconductors is part of an effort to force Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to the negotiating table. In a speech to Republicans on Jan. 27, Trump said he intends to impose tariffs on Taiwan to bring chip production to the US. “The incentive is going to be they’re not going to want to pay a 25, 50 or even a 100 percent tax,” he said. Darson Chiu (邱達生), an economics professor at Taichung-based Tunghai University and director-general of
‘LEGACY CHIPS’: Chinese companies have dramatically increased mature chip production capacity, but the West’s drive for secure supply chains offers a lifeline for Taiwan When Powerchip Technology Corp (力晶科技) entered a deal with the eastern Chinese city of Hefei in 2015 to set up a new chip foundry, it hoped the move would help provide better access to the promising Chinese market. However, nine years later, that Chinese foundry, Nexchip Semiconductor Corp (合晶集成), has become one of its biggest rivals in the legacy chip space, leveraging steep discounts after Beijing’s localization call forced Powerchip to give up the once-lucrative business making integrated circuits for Chinese flat panels. Nexchip is among Chinese foundries quickly winning market share in the crucial US$56.3 billion industry of so-called legacy
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) yesterday held its first board of directors meeting in the US, at which it did not unveil any new US investments despite mounting tariff threats from US President Donald Trump. Trump has threatened to impose 100 percent tariffs on Taiwan-made chips, prompting market speculation that TSMC might consider boosting its chip capacity in the US or ramping up production of advanced chips such as those using a 2-nanometer technology process at its Arizona fabs ahead of schedule. Speculation also swirled that the chipmaker might consider building its own advanced packaging capacity in the US as part
A move by US President Donald Trump to slap a 25 percent tariff on all steel imports is expected to place Taiwan-made steel, which already has a 25 percent tariff, on an equal footing, the Taiwan Steel & Iron Industries Association said yesterday. Speaking with CNA, association chairman Hwang Chien-chih (黃建智) said such an equal footing is expected to boost Taiwan’s competitive edge against other countries in the US market, describing the tariffs as "positive" for Taiwanese steel exporters. On Monday, Trump signed two executive orders imposing the new metal tariffs on imported steel and aluminum with no exceptions and exemptions, effective