A Delaware judge cleared Hewlett-Packard Co of allegations it acted improperly in the proxy fight over its acquisition of Compaq Computer Corp.
Former HP director Walter Hewlett, who had fought to stop the US$18.4 billion deal, said he would not appeal the ruling, which likely paves the way for completion of the high-tech industry's biggest merger.
"I will therefore now do everything possible to support the successful implementation of HP's acquisition of Compaq and encourage others who have shared my views in the past several months to do the same," the HP heir said in a statement Tuesday night.
Judge William B. Chandler ruled Tuesday that Hewlett failed to support his charges that HP bullied a big investor into supporting the acquisition and lied to investors about the progress of the merger plans.
"The evidence demonstrates that HP's statements concerning the merger were true, complete and made in good faith," wrote the Chancery Court judge, who presided over the three-day trial last week in Wilmington, Delaware.
Palo Alto-based HP and Houston-based Compaq have said they plan to begin working together May 7.
Chandler's ruling concluded another contentious chapter in Hewlett's fight to stop the acquisition. "Clearly we're gratified," HP spokeswoman Rebeca Robboy said. "We look forward to moving on."
After HP narrowly won its shareholder vote on the Compaq acquisition, Hewlett tried to block the deal by suing the computing giant, which his father, William Hewlett, co-founded in 1939. He sued in Delaware because HP is incorporated there.
That step so angered HP management and its other directors that Hewlett was not renominated for another term on the board, leaving the Silicon Valley institution without a Hewlett or Packard in its boardroom for the first time.
A preliminary tally released two weeks ago found that HP won the shareholder vote 51.4 percent to 48.6 percent. That amounted to a lead of 45 million shares -- likely enough to withstand the disqualification of the 17 million to 24 million shares voted by Deutsche Bank, the investor Hewlett claims was coerced.
The tally was being challenged by both sides but Hewlett said Tuesday night he would abandon that effort as well.
The trial in Delaware featured 10 hours of testimony from HP's top two executives, CEO Carly Fiorina and chief financial officer Robert Wayman.
Hewlett alleged that HP threatened to withhold future investment banking business from Deutsche Bank unless the investment firm canceled its vote against the deal and voted for it at the last minute.
In a voice mail for Wayman two nights before the March 19 shareholder vote, Fiorina suggested they do something "extraordinary" for Deutsche Bank.
Then in a conference call with Deutsche money managers about an hour before the shareholder vote began, Fiorina said their decision was "of great importance to our ongoing relationship."
Deutsche Bank was performing a variety of services for HP, including giving "market intelligence" advice for US$1 million, with a US$1 million bonus contingent on the deal's approval. Deutsche's top investment official was recorded saying the firm's vote on the HP-Compaq deal was highly sensitive and needed to be changed "as fast as humanly possible."
Fiorina and Wayman said they asked Deutsche money managers to support the deal on its merits and did not resort to coercive tactics.
The judge agreed: "The plaintiffs can point to nothing in those exchanges that indicates a threat from management that future business would be withheld by HP from Deutsche Bank," he wrote.
However, Chandler said the evidence raised troubling questions "about the integrity of the internal ethical wall that purportedly separates Deutsche Bank's asset management division from its commercial division."
To support his claim that HP misled investors about the chances the Compaq merger would generate its promised financial benefits, lawyers for Hewlett cited internal projections that showed the deal falling far short of its publicly disclosed targets.
Hewlett's team introduced internal memos from Compaq's chief financial officer, Jeff Clarke, calling the projections "ugly" and "a disaster."
But Clarke, Fiorina and Wayman testified that the negative comments were motivational ploys. They also said the weak projections were drawn up by HP and Compaq managers who intentionally set low targets they knew they could beat.
The judge said he found HP's explanation "compelling" and "corroborated by evidence in the record."
The government is aiming to recruit 1,096 foreign English teachers and teaching assistants this year, the Ministry of Education said yesterday. The foreign teachers would work closely with elementary and junior-high instructors to create and teach courses, ministry official Tsai Yi-ching (蔡宜靜) said. Together, they would create an immersive language environment, helping to motivate students while enhancing the skills of local teachers, she said. The ministry has since 2021 been recruiting foreign teachers through the Taiwan Foreign English Teacher Program, which offers placement, salary, housing and other benefits to eligible foreign teachers. Two centers serving northern and southern Taiwan assist in recruiting and training
WIDE NET: Health officials said they are considering all possibilities, such as bongkrekic acid, while the city mayor said they have not ruled out the possibility of a malicious act of poisoning Two people who dined at a restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Department Store Xinyi A13 last week have died, while four are in intensive care, the Taipei Department of Health said yesterday. All of the outlets of Malaysian vegetarian restaurant franchise Polam Kopitiam have been ordered to close pending an investigation after 11 people became ill due to suspected food poisoning, city officials told a news conference in Taipei. The first fatality, a 39-year-old man who ate at the restaurant on Friday last week, died of kidney failure two days later at the city’s Mackay Memorial Hospital. A 66-year-old man who dined
RESTAURANT POISONING? Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang at a press conference last night said this was the first time bongkrekic acid was detected in Taiwan An autopsy discovered bongkrekic acid in a specimen collected from a person who died from food poisoning after dining at the Malaysian restaurant chain Polam Kopitiam, the Ministry of Health and Welfare said at a news conference last night. It was the first time bongkrekic acid was detected in Taiwan, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝) said. The testing conducted by forensic specialists at National Taiwan University was facilitated after a hospital voluntarily offered standard samples it had in stock that are required to test for bongkrekic acid, he said. Wang told the news conference that testing would continue despite
‘CARRIER KILLERS’: The Tuo Chiang-class corvettes’ stealth capability means they have a radar cross-section as small as the size of a fishing boat, an analyst said President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) yesterday presided over a ceremony at Yilan County’s Suao Harbor (蘇澳港), where the navy took delivery of two indigenous Tuo Chiang-class corvettes. The corvettes, An Chiang (安江) and Wan Chiang (萬江), along with the introduction of the coast guard’s third and fourth 4,000-tonne cutters earlier this month, are a testament to Taiwan’s shipbuilding capability and signify the nation’s resolve to defend democracy and freedom, Tsai said. The vessels are also the last two of six Tuo Chiang-class corvettes ordered from Lungteh Shipbuilding Co (龍德造船) by the navy, Tsai said. The first Tuo Chiang-class vessel delivered was Ta Chiang (塔江)