Voting to start for top UN body seats

SECURING VOTES::Rwanda and Argentina are both set to win temporary seats on the Security Council, with South Korea lobbying hard for a coveted slot as well


Thu, Oct 18, 2012 - Page 7

The UN General Assembly is to vote today to elect five new non-permanent members to the Security Council, with Argentina and Rwanda widely expected to win seats, while three others are up for grabs.

Buenos Aires and Kigali are essentially a lock to take their places on the 15-member council, as no other countries in their respective regions have declared any intention to vie for a spot on the most powerful UN body.

There is, however, competition in Asia — with South Korea leading the charge — and the so-called Western European and Others Group, in which Australia and Finland are the frontrunners over Luxembourg.


For the Asia-Pacific seat, South Korea has the clear advantage over Bhutan and Cambodia. Seoul has highlighted its participation in 19 peacekeeping operations since it joined the world body in 1991.

Cambodia in contrast has not led an active campaign, diplomats said, while Bhutan has no formal diplomatic ties with any of the council’s five permanent members — Britain, China, France, Russia and the US.

In the other group, Australia and Finland are seen as having the edge over Luxembourg, a founding member of the EU.

Australia — which has already sat on the council four times — has lobbied intensely for the place. Finland has had two terms. Luxembourg, Bhutan and Cambodia have never been on the council.

Nations must garner 129 votes, or two-thirds of the 193-nation General Assembly, to be elected. Surprises are rare, but can happen — in 2010, Canada was shocked when it lost out to Portugal and Germany.

The five countries chosen will on Jan. 1 begin a two-year term. They will replace Colombia, Germany, India, Portugal and South Africa.


The five other non-permanent members are Azerbaijan, Guatemala, Morocco, Pakistan and Togo. Their terms will be completed at the end of next year.

Only the five permanent members have veto-wielding power.

Last year, Pakistan’s election raised fears of a conflict on the council with its longtime rival India, but the two South Asian states served together without difficulty — and voted together often on issues such as Syria.

This time, Argentina would serve alongside Britain, but their longstanding dispute over the Falkland Islands is not expected to be a factor in the council’s deliberations.

If predictions are accurate, according to one diplomat, the emerging BRICS nations — Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa — will lose influence on the council, with India and South Africa leaving.


Rwanda, accused of interference in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, has the support of the US, and South Korea should play an active role in debates on North Korea.

Argentina has a particular interest in Haiti, where it has sent hundreds of peacekeepers.