Yale’s Singapore college has become embroiled in a row about academic freedom after axing a course on dissent, with the controversy fueling a wider debate on whether universities are compromising their values to expand abroad.
The Yale-NUS College, a partnership with the National University of Singapore, opened in 2013, drawing criticism from advocates and its own faculty over the decision to set up in the city-state, due to its restrictions on civil liberties.
Such fears intensified last month when the liberal arts college axed a week-long course called “Dialogue and Dissent in Singapore” two weeks before it was scheduled to start, prompting concerns the school was censoring some topics.
The course featured talks by anti-government advocates, a visit to Speakers’ Corner in a city park — the only place in Singapore where demonstrations are allowed — and a documentary about Hong Kong democracy activist Joshua Wong (黃之鋒).
Among reasons for the cancelation, Yale-NUS said students could have been at risk of breaking the law, but the row raised fresh questions about whether the Ivy League institution’s liberal arts traditions can thrive in Singapore.
Scrapping the course “is precisely why many doubted the Yale-NUS collaboration could be faithful to international standards of academic freedom,” Human Rights Watch Asia deputy director Phil Robertson said.
“Such restrictions ... handicap the quality of education that students get in Singapore and advances censorship and control that is anathema to innovation and learning,” he said.
The group has often criticized Singapore for using draconian laws to stifle dissent and restricting rights to free speech and peaceful assembly.
Yale sought to draw a line under the scandal, ordering a probe that found no evidence that academic freedom was violated and said the cancelation was in part due to a lack of academic rigor.
Yale-NUS president Tan Tai Yong (陳大榮) said the college remains “fully committed” to academic freedom and insisted it “has a thriving culture of open discussion,” but added that it has to be careful with activities that could cross legal boundaries.
As the controversy escalated, Singaporean Minister of Education Ong Ye Kung (王乙康) said in a speech to parliament that the government supported the cancelation.
“Academic freedom cannot be carte blanche for anyone to misuse an academic institution for political advocacy,” he said, adding that the government would intervene “when the situation calls for it.”
More broadly, the row focused attention on risks taken by higher-education institutes as they increasingly set up overseas, often in countries with booming economies, but where political freedoms might be more limited than in the West.
The number of branch campuses set up by institutions overseas jumped from 84 in 2000 to 249 in 2015, according to data compiled by the Cross-Border Education Research Team, hosted at the State University of New York at Albany and Pennsylvania State University.
“It is always challenging for universities from countries such as the UK, US and Australia to open campuses overseas, particularly in countries with more authoritarian systems,” said Kris Olds, an expert in the globalization of higher education from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Universities adopt different approaches, ranging from making changes that suit the local legal and political context to focusing on certain disciplines less likely to run into problems concerning academic freedom, he said.
A number of foreign universities have set up in Singapore, which is aiming to be a regional leader in education.
Yale-NUS is the first college established by the elite US institution outside its campus in New Haven, Connecticut, but it is not a traditional branch campus. It describes itself as an “autonomous college” within NUS.
In its report into the cancelation of last month’s course, Yale said it could have led to international students — nine out of the course’s 16 participants — breaking tough laws against protests.
Only citizens and those holding permanent residency status are allowed to protest at Speakers’ Corner.
Course instructor Alfian Sa’at, a prominent Singaporean playwright and political advocate, disputed the report’s allegations that he had rejected proposed changes to the syllabus and had been reckless to expose foreign students to arrest.
Some were more concerned that the high-profile row could have a chilling effect on academia.
FRENCH AID: Paris has sent a navy ship and aircraft from Reunion Island with some pollution control equipment, but rough seas are spreading the oil spill The operator of a Japanese bulk carrier which ran aground off Mauritius in the Indian Ocean yesterday apologized for a major oil spill, which officials and environmentalists say is creating an ecological disaster, as police prepared to board the ship. The MV Wakashio, operated by Mitsui OSK Lines, struck the reef on Mauritius’ southeast coast on July 25. “We apologize profusely and deeply for the great trouble we have caused,” Mitsui OSK Lines executive vice president Akihiko Ono said at a news conference in Tokyo. The company would “do everything in their power to resolve the issue,” he said. At least 1,000 tonnes of
Three Micronesian sailors stranded on a remote Pacific island have been found alive and well after a rescue team spotted their giant SOS message written into the sand on a beach. Australian and US military aircraft found the three men on tiny Pikelot island, nearly 200km west of where they had set off. Rescuers said that the men were “in good condition” with no significant injuries. The men had been missing for three days after their 7m skiff ran out of fuel and strayed off course. Authorities in the US territory of Guam raised the alarm on Saturday after the men failed to complete
A cat that went missing on a family holiday on the shores of Loch Lomond, Scotland, has been identified 12 years later. Tortoiseshell-and-white Georgie spent October half term in 2008 with her owners at the Rowardennan campsite, but vanished as they were due to return home to Greater Manchester, England. After a search of the site the Davies family departed without Georgie, hoping the three-year-old microchipped feline would be located by someone. Over the intervening 12 years, she remained close to the Queen Elizabeth Forest Park site, being fed and cared for by campsite staff and holidaymakers. After the COVID-19 pandemic hit and lockdown
LIFELONG LOSS: Jiro Hamasumi, who was not quite born when an atomic bomb hit Hiroshima, lost his father and other relatives, but said he thinks about his father daily As Japan marks 75 years since the devastating attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the last generation of nuclear bomb survivors is working to ensure their message lives on after them. The “hibakusha” — literally “person affected by the bomb” — have for decades been a powerful voice calling for the abolition of nuclear weapons. There are an estimated 136,700 left, many of whom were infants or soon to be born at the time of the attacks. The average age of a survivor now is a little over 83, according to the Japanese Ministry of Health, lending an urgency as they share their testimonies