China’s state broadcaster China Central Television (CCTV) last week offered a look inside Xinjiang’s controversial internment camps.
In the 15-minute segment, journalists visit the Hotan City Vocational Skills Education and Training Center, where they teach students Mandarin, China’s various legal codes and job-relevant skills, according to a city official, reciting almost verbatim a description previously given in Chinese state media.
Students are shown learning cosmetology, baking, sewing, woodworking and more. The cafeteria is decorated with balloons and bunting, and all the dorms have air conditioning.
Photo: AP Video / CCTV
One young woman tells an interviewer woodenly: “If I wasn’t here studying, I don’t even want to imagine where I’d be. Maybe I would have followed those religious extremists into a life of crime. The government and party found me in time and saved me.”
Over the past few weeks, China has launched its most aggressive defense against international criticism of its policies in the far western territory of Xinjiang, home to about 12 million Muslim minorities. Researchers and advocacy groups say China’s campaign in the name of rooting out extremism is rife with human rights abuses, namely the use of re-education camps and the mass surveillance and detention of Uighurs, Kazakhs and other Muslims.
After months of denying the existence of such camps, officials appear to be trying a new tack: normalizing the camps as places for “free vocational training” that are more similar to summer camps than de facto prisons where people can be kept indefinitely without due process.
“The Chinese Communist Party is losing precious control of the narrative,” said Timothy Grose, who focuses on ethnic policy in China at Rose Hulman Institute of Technology in Terre Haute, Indiana. “In a few weeks’ time high-ranking officials have gone on record to angrily deny the existence of a network of re-education centers while accusing the ‘West’ of inciting unrest ... to proudly showcasing them as an example of the party’s altruism.”
Xinhua news agency on Tuesday last week released a lengthy interview with Xinjiang Governor Shohrat Zakir, the most any senior official has publicly spoken about the camps.
The governor said in addition to vocational training, there were basketball and volleyball courts and arts competitions.
He called this proof of the Hotan center’s “humane management and care” and avoided using the term “education,” a term that harkens back to China’s use of education through labor, a system started in the 1950s and abolished in 2013, after being declared incompatible with China’s commitment to rule by law.
State-run Global Times has published numerous editorials hailing the vocational centers.
An editorial on Wednesday said: “Since the vocational training centers were set up, the situation in Xinjiang has changed for the better. They may not operate flawlessly, but aim to stop impetuous killings and comfort people frightened by violent terrorist activities.”
On Twitter, Global Times editor-in-chief Hu Xijin (胡錫進) said he did not believe the trainees “go there voluntarily,” but “they have been given sincere help of education and training to enable them to return to normal life eventually.”
The publicity campaign comes ahead of a panel at the UN Human Rights Council early next month when other governments can question China on its policies. Xinjiang is expected to be a major topic, especially after the UN’s Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) in August cited estimates of 1 million Muslim minorities detained, raising global scrutiny.
“China was caught off guard at August’s UN CERD review at just how strongly the committee raised the situation in Xinjiang. The government realizes it can’t just deny everything ahead of next month’s UN review and so is now engaging in a propaganda campaign to justify mass arbitrary detention of ethnic Muslims,” said Frances Eve, a researcher with Chinese Human Rights Defenders.
Analysts say the campaign might have revealed important clues about the direction of China’s policies in Xinjiang. Recasting the camps as vocational training centers is more palatable not only to international audiences, but also to those in Xinjiang, according to Adrian Zenz, a researcher who focuses on Xinjiang.
“If they ramp up vocational skills training, it could be an indication they are moving to reintegrate some of these detainees and eventually release them,” he said.
In Zakir’s interview, he said some students could be released by the end of the year.
“There are deeper signs the party seeks to legalize, standardize and ultimately normalize this educational process” said James Leibold, an academic who specializes in Chinese ethnic policies at La Trobe University in Melbourne. “I think the ultimate aim is the creation of a vocational, patriotic education system for adult minorities in Xinjiang.”
In other ways, China’s internal messaging about Xinjiang has remained consistent. Within China, officials describe Uighurs and other residents as having been “infected with religious extremism,” where re-education is the cure.
CCTV’s program on the Hotan training center, in Mandarin and aimed at Chinese viewers unfamiliar with the camp system, emphasizes how beneficial they are.
“It’s almost an inoculation,” said Shelley Zhang, a writer for the satirical YouTube show China Uncensored, who analyzed the segment. “It’s helpful to first get your message, your narrative in people’s heads first, and television is a great medium for this.”
Yet even CCTV’s careful camera placement failed to hide the center’s more correctional side. Using satellite imagery, researcher Shawn Zhang found what he believes is the same reeducation camp. The segment was shot in the one building that is not surrounded by a razor-wire fence.
The compound features security checkpoints and watchtowers.
Additional reporting by staff writer
Republican US lawmakers on Friday criticized US President Joe Biden’s administration after sanctioned Chinese telecoms equipment giant Huawei unveiled a laptop this week powered by an Intel artificial intelligence (AI) chip. The US placed Huawei on a trade restriction list in 2019 for contravening Iran sanctions, part of a broader effort to hobble Beijing’s technological advances. Placement on the list means the company’s suppliers have to seek a special, difficult-to-obtain license before shipping to it. One such license, issued by then-US president Donald Trump’s administration, has allowed Intel to ship central processors to Huawei for use in laptops since 2020. China hardliners
A top Vietnamese property tycoon was on Thursday sentenced to death in one of the biggest corruption cases in history, with an estimated US$27 billion in damages. A panel of three hand-picked jurors and two judges rejected all defense arguments by Truong My Lan, chair of major developer Van Thinh Phat, who was found guilty of swindling cash from Saigon Commercial Bank (SCB) over a decade. “The defendant’s actions ... eroded people’s trust in the leadership of the [Communist] Party and state,” read the verdict at the trial in Ho Chi Minh City. After the five-week trial, 85 others were also sentenced on
Conjoined twins Lori and George Schappell, who pursued separate careers, interests and relationships during lives that defied medical expectations, died this month in Pennsylvania, funeral home officials said. They were 62. The twins, listed by Guinness World Records as the oldest living conjoined twins, died on April 7 at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, obituaries posted by Leibensperger Funeral Homes of Hamburg said. The cause of death was not detailed. “When we were born, the doctors didn’t think we’d make 30, but we proved them wrong,” Lori said in an interview when they turned 50, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported. The
RAMPAGE: A Palestinian man was left dead after dozens of Israeli settlers searching for a missing 14-year-old boy stormed a village in the Israeli-occupied West Bank US President Joe Biden on Friday said he expected Iran to attack Israel “sooner, rather than later” and warned Tehran not to proceed. Asked by reporters about his message to Iran, Biden simply said: “Don’t,” underscoring Washington’s commitment to defend Israel. “We are devoted to the defense of Israel. We will support Israel. We will help defend Israel and Iran will not succeed,” he said. Biden said he would not divulge secure information, but said his expectation was that an attack could come “sooner, rather than later.” Israel braced on Friday for an attack by Iran or its proxies as warnings grew of