Silent and enigmatic, China’s emblematic Terra-cotta Warriors are at the center of a bitter row, with patriots and academics dismissing as impossible theories they could have been inspired by Greek sculpture.
The 8,000-man clay army, crafted in about 250 BC for the tomb of China’s first emperor, Qin Shi Huang (秦始皇), is a UNESCO world heritage site, a major tourist draw and a symbol of ancient Chinese artistic and military sophistication in a country that proclaims itself a 5,000-year-old civilization.
Questioning their origins touches on deep sensitivities, as many take pride in China’s early discovery of world-changing inventions, from gunpowder to the compass and movable type.
At the same time, its history with the West is fraught with a sense of humiliation over the colonies and concessions established in the 19th century.
However, theories proposed by art historian Lukas Nickel of the University of Vienna — and trumpeted in a recent documentary by National Geographic and the BBC — claim that Greek innovations in artistic naturalism, and perhaps even Greek artisans themselves, directly influenced the sculptures.
After the documentary aired earlier this month, netizens blasted the BBC and questioned how the Greeks could have impacted ancient China.
“Couldn’t it be that Chinese people went first to Greece and influenced their sculpture?” one wrote.
At the tomb, tourists from across China crammed observation platforms to view the ranks of soldiers, jostling for space to snap selfies against their serious, stony facades as guides briskly narrated the story of their discovery by farmers in the 1970s.
Several visitors were incredulous at theories of foreign influence.
Dong Shenghua of Beijing said this was “impossible,” pointing to the Asian features of the statues and the sophistication of the craftsmanship, which is “so good we can’t even make them today.”
“We have 5,000 years of history, how many does England have?” he asked.
Ma Dongling, from Guangxi, said inspiration could not have come from abroad, as China was “very innovative” at the time.
“The emperor was the first in the world to do this,” Ma said.
The tomb’s lead archeologist, Zhang Weixing (張衛星), was similarly dismissive, saying the materials, technology and ceramics techniques used for the Warriors were all Chinese.
“To say that the Qin tombs and ancient Greece had contact has no substantial evidence at all,” he told reporters. “It merely exists in the scholar’s conjecture.”
Qin Shi Huang “not only innovated the Terra-cotta Warriors, he also created a series of innovations” including standardized weights and measures, national roads and a unified currency, he said.
“Who influenced whom, it’s tough to say. Ancient Greek sculpture had already also been influenced by Egypt,” Zhang added.
For evidence, Nickel points to historical records suggesting the first Qin emperor made casts of huge bronze statues seen in China’s far west, realistic detailing of muscle and bone on some figures and the absence of an extensive prior sculptural tradition in China.
Further research could show that foreign empires might have provided a model for the Qin state itself, he told reporters.
“I think it’s perfectly possible that there’s much more influence in thought about statecraft, in how to run an empire, than people have been so far willing to admit,” he added.
Nickel points to the rise of empires in central Asia before the Qin Dynasty, with the Achaemenids in Persia followed by Alexander the Great and the Seleucids.
“When I look at the map of Eurasia, what the Chinese do fits perfectly in the big picture,” he said.
However, basing theories about transmission of cultural ideas on stylistic similarities in objects fails to convince some Chinese scholars, he acknowledged.
“This is an argument that works mainly in Europe and America,” Nickel said.
In China, researchers rely more on textual evidence for proof, and so were “very hesitant to believe there were interactions before the mid second century BC, when the Chinese emperor of the Han Dynasty sent an envoy to central Asia,” he said.
The idea of early Sino-Western exchanges threatens to undermine a cornerstone of Chinese identity: the Qin Dynasty — while brutal in many respects, with book burnings and executions of literati — laid the foundation for China as a unified nation state that has persisted for two millennia.
“That is the moment when China is being made,” Nickel said. “Saying there is such a link, it always brings up memories of colonialism, of Western domination of East Asia, which is totally understandable.”
Zhang insisted the disagreement was based on academic rigor.
“If he was an archeologist we could discuss this issue,” he said. “Archeologists put more importance on historical documents and unearthed objects.”
Li Xiuzhen, another academic at the tomb, told reporters that while there might have been cultural contact, that did not imply influence and the warriors were completely Chinese.
“The Terracotta Army is unique in the world,” she said, adding that it was the “creation of the Qin people.”
CONFRONTATION: The water cannon attack was the second this month on the Philippine supply boat ‘Unaizah May 4,’ after an incident on March 5 The China Coast Guard yesterday morning blocked a Philippine supply vessel and damaged it with water cannons near a reef off the Southeast Asian country, the Philippines said. The Philippine military released video of what it said was a nearly hour-long attack off the Second Thomas Shoal (Renai Shoal, 仁愛暗沙) in the contested South China Sea, where Chinese ships have unleashed water cannons and collided with Philippine vessels in similar standoffs in the past few months. The China Coast Guard and other vessels “once again harassed, blocked, deployed water cannons, and executed dangerous maneuvers” against a routine rotation and resupply mission to
GLOBAL COMBAT AIR PROGRAM: The potential purchasers would be limited to the 15 nations with which Tokyo has signed defense partnership and equipment transfer deals Japan’s Cabinet yesterday approved a plan to sell future next-generation fighter jets that it is developing with the UK and Italy to other nations, in the latest move away from the country’s post-World War II pacifist principles. The contentious decision to allow international arms sales is expected to help secure Japan’s role in the joint fighter jet project, and is part of a move to build up the Japanese arms industry and bolster its role in global security. The Cabinet also endorsed a revision to Japan’s arms equipment and technology transfer guidelines to allow coproduced lethal weapons to be sold to nations
Thousands of devotees, some in a state of trance, gathered at a Buddhist temple on the outskirts of Bangkok renowned for sacred tattoos known as Sak Yant, paying their respects to a revered monk who mastered the practice and seeking purification. The gathering at Wat Bang Phra Buddhist temple is part of a Thai Wai Khru ritual in which devotees pay homage to Luang Phor Pern, the temple’s formal abbot, who died in 2002. He had a reputation for refining and popularizing the temple’s Sak Yant tattoo style. The idea that tattoos confer magical powers has existed in many parts of Asia
ON ALERT: A Russian cruise missile crossed into Polish airspace for about 40 seconds, the Polish military said, adding that it is constantly monitoring the war to protect its airspace Ukraine’s capital, Kyiv, and the western region of Lviv early yesterday came under a “massive” Russian air attack, officials said, while a Russian cruise missile breached Polish airspace, the Polish military said. Russia and Ukraine have been engaged in a series of deadly aerial attacks, with yesterday’s strikes coming a day after the Russian military said it had seized the Ukrainian village of Ivanivske, west of Bakhmut. A militant attack on a Moscow concert hall on Friday that killed at least 133 people also became a new flash point between the two archrivals. “Explosions in the capital. Air defense is working. Do not