The US Supreme Court on Wednesday took aim at a US government regulation that banned an Alaskan moose hunter from riding his hovercraft through a conservation area in a case that touches upon simmering tensions over US federal control of public lands.
Long-time hunter John Sturgeon contends the US federal government cannot prevent him from traveling through the federal Yukon-Charley Rivers National Preserve in Alaska on his hovercraft to access moose-hunting grounds.
At issue is whether the US National Park Service has the authority to issue a regulation than bans hovercraft use, a legal question that could have implications for other park service regulations including limits on oil and gas extraction.
Sturgeon was traveling on the Nation River in 2007 when park service rangers detained him and said he could not use his hovercraft. He contends the regulation has no force because the river is owned by the state of Alaska, which allows hovercraft.
People in some parts of the US, especially the west, have complained about too much federal control of public lands. The cause was embraced by armed protesters who on Jan. 2 took over buildings at a federal wildlife refuge in Oregon and continue to occupy them.
The state of Alaska filed court papers supporting Sturgeon, saying that in a 1980 law the US Congress specifically limited park service jurisdiction over land within a conservation area that is not federally owned.
The rule banning hovercraft, which travel on a cushion of air, has been in place since 1996.
During Wednesday’s oral arguments, none of the nine justices expressed agreement with the rationale of a 2014 ruling by the San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals backing the US federal government.
The appeals court said park service regulations are limited in scope only if they are Alaska-specific. That would mean national regulations, like the hovercraft ban, could be interpreted more expansively to cover land within a conservation area not federally owned.
“It’s a ridiculous interpretation, is it not?” Justice Samuel Alito of the ruling.
The justices appeared to struggle with how to resolve the case. Justice Stephen Breyer hinted at this frustration when, while asking about the complicated law in question, he broke off and said amid chuckles in the courtroom: “Who drafted this?”
Breyer suggested the case be returned to lower courts.
Alaska said the ruling could impact park service efforts to regulate oil and gas extraction on its land in that state and elsewhere.
A ruling is due by the end of June.
FRENCH AID: Paris has sent a navy ship and aircraft from Reunion Island with some pollution control equipment, but rough seas are spreading the oil spill The operator of a Japanese bulk carrier which ran aground off Mauritius in the Indian Ocean yesterday apologized for a major oil spill, which officials and environmentalists say is creating an ecological disaster, as police prepared to board the ship. The MV Wakashio, operated by Mitsui OSK Lines, struck the reef on Mauritius’ southeast coast on July 25. “We apologize profusely and deeply for the great trouble we have caused,” Mitsui OSK Lines executive vice president Akihiko Ono said at a news conference in Tokyo. The company would “do everything in their power to resolve the issue,” he said. At least 1,000 tonnes of
They stand as eyesores to most passers-by and potential public health risks to authorities, decaying buildings wrapped in tangles of exposed wire, studded with protruding leaky plastic pipes, vegetation billowing from cracks and terraces where particulates from polluted air have accumulated over time. With skyscrapers and ultramodern developments on every side, some of these “nail houses” are also sitting on land worth millions of dollars in Shenzhen’s inferno of a property market, where new-unit and second-hand home prices rival London. In battles over land and development, the nail house phenomenon has become widespread throughout China over the past two decades, with owners
An Italian alpine resort on Friday remained on high alert over fears that a vast chunk of a glacier on the slopes of the Mont Blanc massif could plummet in high temperatures. “No one gets through! No cars, bikes or pedestrians,” was the message at a checkpoint where an automatic barrier and two guards blocked the small road snaking up into a lush valley below the Planpincieux glacier, near the town of Courmayeur and the Italian-French border. The blockade has largely been greeted with contempt by the locals, one of whom said: “It’s a joke.” The huge ice block measuring around 500,000 cubic
The Foreign Correspondents’ Club of Hong Kong (FCC) yesterday said that reporters in the territory were experiencing “highly unusual” visas problems, and called on the US and China to stop using the media as a political weapon. Journalists have been caught up in US-China tensions, with both sides placing limits or expelling reporters from their territories in the past few months. Now the spat is filtering into Hong Kong, a regional press hub nominally in charge of its own immigration policies. The FCC said in a statement that multiple media firms had reported delays getting visas in recent months. “The delays have affected journalists