China has long sought to recover treasures it says were looted by foreigners, but a tycoon’s US$1.6 million deal for the return of seven white marble columns from Norway is raising unusual debate on the issue.
Critics have openly challenged the motives of real-estate developer Huang Nubo (黃怒波), whose donation to the KODE Art Museums of Bergen paved the way for the return of the Old Summer Palace relics, and some argued they should not be “bought back.”
“They robbed us and then returned the marbles to us — I can’t work out if I’m happy or not,” Beijing student Guo Peida said at the ruins of the palace in Beijing, looted by invading Anglo-French forces in 1860.
Plundered or acquired art is a worldwide issue, with the Egyptian Rosetta Stone, the Elgin Marbles taken from the Parthenon in Greece to Britain 200 years ago and Nigeria’s Benin Bronzes just a few examples.
The subject is especially political in China, where the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) consistently seeks to bolster its legitimacy by reminding citizens of the “century of national humiliation” the country suffered at the hands of foreign powers from the mid-19th-century.
“The rhetoric has sometimes been more heated and its claims more nationalist in their justification” in China, said James Cuno, president and chief executive of the J. Paul Getty Trust, whose Getty Museum has a stunning collection of antiquities from around the world.
Chinese authorities and collectors have been actively buying up works considered of national importance, said Cuno, author of Who Owns Antiquity?
“There have also been a number of high-profile restitution cases,” he said. “There is every indication that this will only increase as Chinese nationalism and economic development continue to rise.”
However, while China’s leaders cast themselves as righteous guardians of the country’s cultural patrimony, critics point out that vast numbers of relics, buildings and examples of heritage have been destroyed at the hands of the communist authorities, in both the chaos of the 1966-1976 Cultural Revolution and the tide of construction and urbanization that has swept the country in recent years.
Mao Zedong’s (毛澤東) upheaval included a campaign against the “Four Olds” — “old customs, old culture, old habits and old ideas” — and in an online debate on the columns, a commenter named Pei Shi wrote: “Actually, most of China’s domestic relics were wrecked in the wave of unprecedented looting and destruction that took place ... during the Cultural Revolution.”
Author Jasper Becker has also described China’s campaign to blame foreigners for the loss of its cultural heritage as drawing “the astonishment of many familiar with its past record.”
No one knows exactly how many treasures China lost or sold to outsiders over the years, although some estimates put them in the tens of thousands.
Among them are a vast numbers of manuscripts from Dunhuang, where Hungarian-British archeologist Aurel Stein and subsequent foreign adventurers paid to remove ancient texts from a cave in the early 20th-century.
Relics from the Old Summer Palace are particularly emotive, with the most hotly pursued items a collection of 12 bronze animal heads that formed a Chinese zodiac water clock in the imperial garden.
Five of the heads are still missing, while seven have been recovered by China, four of them on display at the Poly Art Museum, run by the state-owned China Poly Group.
Two were returned last year by Francois Pinault, the owner of Christie’s auction house — which soon afterward was granted a licence to operate independently in China.
The French billionaire only agreed to give them back after a Chinese collector sabotaged their auction in 2009 by successfully bidding US$40 million and then refusing to pay, which he called a “patriotic act.”
Huang and the Norwegian museum have agreed to send the marble plinths to Peking University, the businessman’s alma mater, rather than the former palace.
However, Liu Yang (劉陽), of the Yuanmingyuan Society of China, said the two places were “completely different” and questioned whether Huang was “really acting out of patriotism.”
According to some, the wider issue is a marker for Beijing’s changing geopolitical clout.
Yao Le (姚樂), of the Jiangsu Provincial Academy of Social Science, wrote in the state-run Global Times newspaper that keeping the Old Summer Palace site in “wrecked” condition rather than restoring it ensured it remained “better at stirring feelings of national humiliation and patriotism.”
“The recovery of relics should be a state action, which ought to be achieved by justice without paying for them,” he said. “Only when China becomes powerful enough that all the countries that took our relics have a favor to ask at the cost of returning our relics will we really be able to be satisfied and shamelessly celebrate.”
An Australian university student who has never visited China and has only a modest social media following would seem an unlikely target for the Chinese government. However, when a Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman personally denounced Drew Pavlou at a news conference, it was just the next phase in an extraordinary campaign against the 21-year-old that has fueled concerns over China’s targeting of critics overseas. Pavlou first placed himself in the superpower’s sights when in July last year he organized a small sit-in at the University of Queensland, where he studies, to protest against various Chinese government policies. Since then, the Global
‘ASKED TO MOVE OUT’: Indonesian coast guard personnel argued with a Chinese vessel over territorial claims after it entered the country’s exclusive economic zone An Indonesian patrol ship confronted a Chinese coast guard vessel that spent almost three days in waters where Indonesia claims economic rights and that are near the southernmost part of China’s disputed claims to the South China Sea. The Indonesian Maritime Security Agency on Friday night detected Chinese ship 5204 entering Indonesia’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in what Indonesia calls the North Natuna Sea. The agency sent a patrol ship that closed within 1km of the Chinese coast guard vessel and they communicated to affirm their position and their nation’s claims to the area, Indonesian Maritime Security Agency head Aan Kurnia said. “We
BEFORE WINTER COMES: Snow cuts off roads into Ladakh for four months or more each year, so the crunch is on to get food, tents and high-altitude equipment to Leh From deploying mules to large transport aircraft, the Indian military has activated its entire logistics network to transport supplies to thousands of troops for a harsh winter along a bitterly disputed Himalayan border with China. In the past few months, one of India’s biggest military logistics exercises in years has brought vast quantities of ammunition, equipment, fuel, winter supplies and food into Ladakh, a region bordering Tibet that India administers as a union territory, officials said. The move was triggered by a border standoff with China in the snow deserts of Ladakh that began in May and escalated in June into hand-to-hand
Since her personal telephone number was posted online, Hong Kong democracy advocate and Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions chairperson Carol Ng has received menacing calls from strangers and been bombarded with messages calling her a “cockroach.” She is not alone. A sophisticated and shady Web site called HK Leaks has ramped up its “doxxing” — where people’s personal details are published online — of Hong Kong democracy advocates, targeting those it says have broken Hong Kong’s National Security Law. Promoted by groups linked to the Chinese Chinese Communist Party and hosted on Russia-based servers, HK Leaks has become the most prominent “doxxing”