The debate over healthcare reform that has gripped the US and led to a government shutdown is of small concern in rural Pennsylvania’s Amish country for a very simple reason: In addition to eschewing cars and many other modern technologies, the descendants of 18th-century German immigrants who practice the Amish and Old Order Mennonite religions have effectively opted out of “Obamacare,” along with most other US federal safety net programs.
A little-known provision of the law with roots in a 1950s battle over Social Security exempts these communities from the individual mandate, an element of the US’ Affordable Care Act that requires most Americans to purchase health insurance of some kind.
However, it is not the idea of health insurance the Amish reject, as the close-knit communities essentially insure themselves.
“We have our own healthcare,” said a retired Amish carpenter, who like other Amish interviewed for this story, asked that his name not be used because of a traditional aversion to publicity and bringing attention to oneself.
“They [hospitals] give you a bill,” he said. “If you can’t pay it, your church will.”
About 280,000 people live in Amish communities scattered throughout the US, with the largest populations in the states of Pennsylvania, Ohio and Indiana, according to research by Elizabethtown College in Pennsylvania.
While practices vary by community, most Amish fund their healthcare through a system that merges church aid, benefit auctions and discounts from local hospitals negotiated by promising quick cash payment for lower rates.
“The way they come together to pay for healthcare is amazing,” said Jan Bergen, chief operating officer at Lancaster General Health. “It’s a tithing. Their sense of responsibility extends beyond themselves and to the community.”
The Amish exemption to Obamacare dates back nearly 60 years to when the US Congress extended the Social Security tax to the self-employed and to farmers. Many Amish refused to pay. The US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) moved to enforce the law, sometimes with disastrous public relations consequences.
“There was an Amish guy who refused to pay Social Security. IRS agents confiscated his horses while he was out in the field plowing,” said Donald Kraybill, author of The Amish and professor at Elizabethtown College.
In 1965, Congress passed a law giving certain Amish and Mennonite religious orders the right to opt out of Social Security, Medicaid and a host of other government benefits.
“The basic religious reason driving their resistance is that, as a religious faith, the church community should take care of its own members,” Kraybill said. “If there’s a disaster like a tornado, fire or hospital bill, the community should come together for that.”
The Obamacare exemption is an extension of the Social Security exemption.
“We don’t want government paying for our things,” an Amish man from Kinzers, Pennsylvania, said. “We want to pay our own way.”
The man from Kinzers said his community relies on two funds. Nearly every family contributes monthly to a hospital aid fund, while large bills are also paid with free-will offerings.
Some Amish carry benefit cards, which identify them as members of a community, but do not bear names or photographs, to help hospitals keep track of those discounts.
“It simply says they’re a participant,” said Eric Buck, president of Preferred Health Care, which manages the Old Order Group coverage plan for Lancaster County Amish.