Mon, May 27, 2013 - Page 7 News List

US immigration reform bill faces difficult passage

Reuters, WASHINGTON

The biggest proposed overhaul of US immigration laws in a generation won bipartisan approval from a powerful US Senate committee last week, but there is a strong chance that Republicans in the US House of Representatives will end up killing it.

The problem: House Republicans are far from convinced by arguments from party leaders that passage of the bill would help Republicans draw support from Hispanic voters. Many also believe any kind of amnesty for the estimated 11 million immigrants who are in the US illegally is just plain wrong.

“There is no evidence to support this idea that Republicans will pick up a lot of votes if we give amnesty to 11 million folks,” Republican Representative Tim Huelskamp said

One possibility is that the House will vote for watered-down reform, including more visas for highly skilled workers.

However, it likely will not include a way for the undocumented to stay legally and eventually get on a special pathway to US citizenship.

Senate Democrats and even several Senate Republicans say there is no way a comprehensive immigration bill could win final congressional approval without a pathway to citizenship.

“It’s a non-starter,” said Democratic Senator Charles Schumer, a member of the Gang of Eight senators who wrote the bipartisan Senate bill.

Several House Republican lawmakers say that even if the party would gain votes by supporting sweeping reform, that is no reason to back otherwise objectionable legislation.

“I don’t think we should be worried about the political impact, but instead what is in the best interest of America,” Republican Representative Mo Brooks said.

Besides, “people who are going to break our laws, I don’t want them in this country,” he said.

This kind of opposition from House Republicans may pose the biggest threat to White House-backed legislation set to come next month before the full Senate, which Obama’s Democrats hold, 55-45.

Republicans control the House, 233-201 with one vacancy. Most Republicans have traditionally opposed legalization as a form of amnesty that rewards law breaking and they see as providing an incentive for further illegal border crossing.

The bill that passed the Senate Judiciary Committee, 13-5, on Tuesday last week — with support from three Republicans — includes putting illegal residents on a 13-year pathway to citizenship, provided they pay back taxes and a fine, learn English, hold a job and pass criminal background checks.

The measure, backed by business and labor, also would bolster border security and help fill the need for high and low-skilled workers.

After Hispanics gave US President Barack Obama 71 percent support in last year’s presidential election, the Republican National Committee endorsed comprehensive immigration reform in March, saying that without reaching out to the fastest-growing large segment of the US voting population, the party could say goodbye to the presidency for generations to come.

Two months later, many Republicans remain unconvinced, particularly in the House, where only 39 of the 233 members come from districts that are 20 percent or more Hispanic, according to a recent study by Alex Engler in the Georgetown Public Policy Review.

Huelskamp recalled a private strategy meeting earlier this year where political pollsters offered their findings and advice to House Republicans.

This story has been viewed 1173 times.
TOP top