Sun, Apr 29, 2012 - Page 5 News List

Under-age call girl scandal shakes Singapore

PRO AND CON:While some have complained that the trials have exposed a seamy side that would be better hidden, others have praised the rigorous prosecutions


An unfolding scandal over an under-age call girl has shaken Singapore’s political and economic elite after businessmen, civil servants and uniformed officers were charged in the case.

Prostitution is legal in Singapore, but 48 men ranging in age from their early 20s to late 40s have so far been charged under a 2008 law making it a crime to pay for sex with a girl under 18.

Singapore has long been perceived as a conservative, even prudish, city-state, but it has a thriving sex industry dating back to its beginnings as a key trading port of the then-British Empire.

The latest case has shone a spotlight on its pragmatic approach, which instead of seeking to close down the sex industry aims to tightly regulate the trade to protect minors and ward off criminal involvement.

An elementary-school principal who pleaded guilty to engaging the under-aged girl’s services became the first to be punished when a district court on Friday sentenced him to nine weeks in jail for the offense.

Among the remaining accused are five foreigners including Juerg Buergin, a 40-year-old Swiss expatriate who had worked for banking giant UBS.

The most prominent of the Singaporeans charged is Howard Shaw, a high-society figure and grandson of Runme Shaw, co-founder of cinema and property empire Shaw Organisation, which is also active in charity causes.

The gossip mill went into overdrive when it was disclosed that Shaw, a 41-year-old with two daughters from his first marriage, had sex with the teenager just a month before tying the knot with his second wife, a former beauty contestant still in her 20s.

The two appeared on a recent cover of high-society magazine Singapore Tatler as the poster couple for an article on “great romances” among the rich and famous in the city-state.

Singaporean Web sites and social media are swirling with speculation that more men will be charged even as the identity of the girl, only 17 when she had dalliances with the accused, is being concealed by court order.

People have also been sharing purported pictures and salacious descriptions of the girl, described by a defense lawyer as a “hardcore prostitute.”

However, apart from generating juicy gossip, the high-profile case has also won the authorities plaudits for their rigorous handling of the issue.

“This is the first time that cases of obtaining paid sex from a girl under the age of 18 has been exposed and enforced on such a large scale,” said rights group the Singapore committee for UN Women.

Singapore’s legalization of the sex trade makes it a “pragmatic” and “unusual” exception in a region where prostitution thrives, but is officially banned, said Reuben Wong, a political scientist at the National University of Singapore.

The under-age prostitution scandal was “an embarrassment for Singapore as a society, because it has such a squeaky clean, puritan image,” but reflected well on the state’s strict laws on the sex business, he said.

Brothels operate openly in Singapore in the notorious Geylang red light district, and self-declared prostitutes are required to undergo health checks.

“We recognize that it is not possible to eradicate it and forcing it underground will lead to the greater likelihood of involvement by triads and organized crime, the trafficking of women, and public health risks,” Ho Peng Kee, then a top official of the interior ministry, told parliament in 2009.

This story has been viewed 4511 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top