The radiation leak in Japan immediately recalls memories of accidents at the Chernobyl, Ukraine, and Three Mile Island, US, power stations, and how it unfolds will be a critical test for international acceptance of nuclear energy.
The Fukushima incident, brought on by the biggest earthquake ever recorded in Japan, took a turn for the worse on Saturday after a blast blew the roof off the facility.
There are direct comparisons with the 1979 disaster at Three Mile Island in the US — in both cases a cooling fault led to a buildup of pressure in the radioactive core and resulted in a relatively small radiation leak.
Both use water to control the temperature as uranium degrades in a nuclear chain reaction at the reactors’ core, creating steam which drives a turbine to generate electricity.
The stricken Japanese reactor north of Tokyo has little parallel, however, with the Soviet plant at Chernobyl, where fundamental design faults led to a deadly series of explosions in 1986, causing hundreds of deaths among emergency workers and contamination across Ukraine and beyond throughout Europe.
Japan’s nuclear agency said the problem at Fukushima rated a four on a seven-point scale of gravity, less severe than Three Mile Island, which was a 5, and well short of Chernobyl, a full 7.
In Japan, the earthquake and possibly the following tsunami overwhelmed mains and back-up power to the coolant pumps.
At Three Mile Island in Pennsylvania, human and technical error caused a confused response to a similar failure, leading to over-heating, a meltdown of the nuclear core and a write-off of the reactor. However, unlike in Chernobyl, there was no breach of a pressure vessel, the shell which insulates the heart of a reactor, nor any major radiation leak.
Comparing the problems at Fukushima with Three Mile Island, Robin Grimes, director of the Centre of Nuclear Engineering at Imperial College London, said: “There are parallel situations in terms of some of the processes that have occurred, but not parallel because in one case it was due to the safety processes in place and in this case it was natural disaster.”
In addition, he said, there was no evidence that the core at Fukushima had melted, as happened at Three Mile Island.
That would, if it happened, lead to a greater buildup of radiation within the pressure vessel. Nor was there any sign yet that inner protective shields were damaged, Grimes said.
He said an increase in radiation in the surrounding area of eight times the normal, natural level was an indication that damage to the reactor was limited so far.
The plants at Fukushima and Three Mile Island use water cooling technology in common with most nuclear reactors. Their use of water is slightly different, however.
The Japanese reactor applies heat from the nuclear reactions in the fuel rods directly to water, creating steam which drives an electricity-generating turbine. At Three Mile Island, water under pressure transfers heat to a separate system in a less direct process for producing steam.
In Chernobyl, in a safety check gone wrong, the operators deliberately prevented a shutdown of the reactor in a rapidly escalating fiasco. Runaway nuclear fission reactions created a buildup of pressure and a massive and deadly radiation leakage as explosions ripped through a too-feeble reactor shell.
Three Mile Island did not result in a serious leak, but was still damaging at the time for the reputation of nuclear power.
The Fukushima reactor dates to the early 1970s, older than many still in use, and the industry has since developed “even safer” reactors better equipped to cool naturally, Grimes said.
Opponents of nuclear power have been swift to use the problems at Fukushima to reinforce arguments that the hazards of atomic energy outweigh the benefits.
Supporters say that the ability of Japan’s dozens of reactors to survive frequent earthquakes shows their worth, particularly to countries like Japan, which lack their own reserves of oil, gas and coal.
“We must remember that there are 55 reactors in Japan and this was a huge earthquake,” said Paddy Regan, professor of Nuclear Physics at the University of Surrey near London. “As a test of the resilience and robustness of nuclear plants, it seems they have withstood the effects very well.”
SECONDARY OBJECTIVE: One of the researchers said the discovery would not lead to a ‘complete solution’ and that plastic should not be released into the environment A bacterium that feeds on toxic plastic has been discovered by scientists. The bug not only breaks the plastic down, but uses it as food to power the process. The bacterium, which was found at a waste site where plastic had been dumped, is the first that is known to attack polyurethane. Millions of tonnes of the plastic are produced every year to use in items such as sports shoes, diapers, kitchen sponges and as foam insulation, but it is mostly sent to landfills, because it is too tough to recycle. When broken down it can release toxic and carcinogenic chemicals, which
Tokyo and the Osaka area in western Japan hunkered down yesterday as officials urged people to stay indoors to prevent a potential emergency, but some were carrying on as normal. Tokyo Governor Yuriko Koike’s plea for the tens of millions of people in the capital and surrounding regions to avoid non-essential, non-urgent outings until April 12, and particularly this weekend, followed a surge in coronavirus infections this week that she said put Tokyo on the brink of an emergency. Koike urged people to avoid the national pastime of congregating to drink and watch cherry blossoms as they hit their peak in the
IN CUSTODY: The alleged ringleader allegedly forced victims to carve ‘slave’ into their bodies and send him degrading images that were shared with scores of others A sexual blackmail ring that operated on the app Telegram and targeted dozens of women, including underage girls, has rocked South Korea and triggered demands for authorities to crack down on the rising number of sexual offences online. Police yesterday took the unusual step of naming the man who allegedly ran an online network that lured at least 58 women and 16 girls into what authorities called “virtual enslavement” by blackmailing them into sending degrading and, in some cases, violent sexual images of themselves. Cho Ju-bin faces charges of violating the Child Protection Act, the Privacy Act and the Sexual Abuse Act,
LEGISLATION PRAISED: The southern jet stream wind system appears to have stopped moving southward and might be moving back to normal, scientists said International cooperation on ozone-depleting chemicals is helping to return the southern jet stream to a normal state after decades of disruption, a study shows. Scientists say the findings prove that there is the capacity to heal damaged climate systems if governments act promptly and in coordination to deal with the causes. The southern jet stream is a powerful wind that shapes weather patterns and ocean currents in the southern hemisphere, particularly in the summer. Up until about 2000, it had been shifting from its usual course and moving southward at a rate of 1° of latitude each decade, affecting storm tracks and rainfall