Sun, Nov 19, 2006 - Page 7 News List

Judge rejects bid to halt spying lawsuits


A federal judge rejected requests from US government and telecommunications firm lawyers to immediately freeze domestic spying lawsuits while an appeals court considers whether national security would be threatened in trying them on Friday.

In the first case involving the White House's authorization of the warrantless wiretapping program, San Francisco District Court Chief Judge Vaughn Walker refused to put on hold the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) suit against telecommunications giant AT&T for its alleged role in the program.

EFF sued AT&T for helping the National Security Agency (NSA) to spy on millions of customers by sharing telephone and e-mail data without obtaining warrants.

The NSA conducted the program as part of "war on terror" attempts to uncover threats against the country.

In July Walker rejected arguments by government lawyers that the suit be tossed out on the basis that it is groundless and that its hearing could threaten national security.

The judge ruled the interests of justice outweighed the need to protect "state secrets".

The case is being closely followed as a model after a total of 48 lawsuits on the same issue, involving Verizon, Sprint, Bell South, and AT&T, were ordered consolidated before Walker.

On Friday government and telecommunications company lawyers asked Walker to immediately put the EFF-AT&T case on hold while their appeal to a separate court to overturn Walker's July ruling is heard.

But Walker again turned them back, leaving the matter to another Dec. 21 hearing.

"I do think that there are matters we can proceed on regarding these cases," Walker told the dozens of attorneys whose suits were consolidated before him.

"We would have to insure perfection with regard to each question to make sure each answer doesn't reveal state secrets," Assistant US Attorney Carl Nichols argued in pushing the freeze.

"The entire process is fraught with risk," he said.

EFF attorney Cindy Cohn adamantly countered that the NSA practice of snooping on telephone and e-mail communications was now far from secret and that aspects of the cases could safely proceed while the appeal was considered.

"I feel a little like it's Groundhog Day," Cohn told the judge, referring to a comedy film in which the lead character continuously relives the same day.

"I'm having to repeat the same arguments over and over again," she said.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top