Thu, Sep 18, 2003 - Page 6 News List

Egyptian partner gives cold comfort to embattled Israel

AFP , CAIRO

Twenty-five years after Egypt and Israel signed the historic Camp David peace accords, their strained marriage seems colder than ever.

In addition, the broader regional peace that was to have been built on the keystone of Camp David appears more elusive than ever.

"Egypt no longer has an ambassador in Tel Aviv, political ties are bad, economic exchanges are frozen and the Egyptian people are increasingly hostile toward Israel," Egyptian researcher Emad Gad said.

Gad, who specializes in Israeli-Egyptian relations for the Al Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies, said Cairo newspapers have recently stepped up their attacks on Israel.

The government newspaper Al-Ahram on Sunday called for the Israeli ambassadors in Egypt and Jordan to be expelled if Israel follows through on threats to exile Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

Gad said that though the Camp David Accords allowed Egypt to recover the Sinai desert from Israel, they have failed to end Egyptian hostility toward Israel.

"Most of today's students were born after the return of Egyptian territory [in 1982], and that has not stopped them from listing Israel as the number one enemy," he said.

The Camp David Accords, signed on Sept. 17, 1978 at the White House, comprise two parts.

The first was a bilateral arrangement which paved the way six months later for the first peace treaty between Israel and an Arab country; the second was a framework agreement for self-rule in the West Bank and Gaza.

The second part was never implemented, though the Palestinians and Israelis struck a secret deal at Oslo more than 14 years later that paved the way for a measure of Palestinian autonomy similar to that outlined at Camp David.

Relations improved in the years after Oslo under Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, but took a turn for the worse after Rabin was assassinated in 1995 and right-winger Benjamin Netanyahu was elected prime minister in 1996.

Since hardliner Ariel Sharon became premier in March 2001, ties have hit rock bottom.

Israel's ambassador to Egypt, Gideon Ben-Ami, said the peace treaty that emerged from Camp David is durable, even though it has failed to produce the desired benefits.

"The treaty managed to survive the ups and downs of the volatile Middle East peace process, and to prove its irreversibility," Ben-Ami told reporters in a written response to a query by e-mail.

But he added that "Egyptian-Israeli current relations are by far unsatisfactory, primarily due to the consequences and shock-waves of the second intifada and Egypt's obvious solidarity with the Palestinian side."

"Naturally, one feels disappointed and frustrated with the linkage made by the Egyptians between the tiresome progress on the Palestinian track, and normalization, as we Israelis conceive it," Ben-Ami said.

Sharon said last month that Egypt could not be involved in the Middle East peace process if it did not release Israeli national Azzam Azzam, jailed in Egypt for spying -- a way to deny Egypt the key mediating role it cherishes.

This story has been viewed 1940 times.
TOP top