Minister of Culture Lung Ying-tai (龍應台) yesterday praised the creativity and capability students have shown in the Sunflower movement, but said that the thinking behind their actions is not strong and is contradictory.
She urged the students who have occupied the legislative chamber since March 18 to press the government to reconsider the cross-strait service trade agreement to end their occupation and go home.
The student movement has developed into a mass civil movement, with about 500,000 people joining a rally on Sunday.
Photo: Chien Jung-fong, Taipei Times
Lung made the remarks during a question-and-answer session at the legislature’s Education and Culture Committee yesterday.
“Social movements have two aspects, action and the theory behind the action. Regarding the action, the students’ ability to organize activities and to promote the events domestically and internationally, their division of labor and the images they have tried to create are incredibly perfect, which is an accumulation of waves of student movements in Taiwan over sixty years. I grade them 100 points. Not only myself, but I believe you also love these young people,” she said.
“I wish those young, talented people worked for the culture ministry,” Lung added.
However, Lung said there was a lack of well-thought-through theory behind the movement, saying that the theory was “weak, full of contradictions and not mature.”
The rule of law is a backbone of democracy, but the students have broken the rule of law, she said.
“They claim to be defenders of democracy, but a democracy must be supported by rule of law. It doesn’t make sense that they are defending democracy through breaking the rule of law,” Lung said.
She said that the students staged the movement as a reaction to the Chinese Nationalist Party’s (KMT) attempt to pass the pact without due process, but the students themselves have violated procedural justice.
The students are against the government’s “black box,” or opaque, signing of the trade pact, but the most “black box” operations are inter-party negotiations in the legislature, Lung said.
“The students who have been in the legislature do not see it,” she said.
“I would like to hear from the students which clause of the agreement they oppose, and why, and how the students would rebut the arguments from experts and economists who support the pact,” she said.
There are a total of 2,235 bills waiting to be reviewed in the legislature, Lung added.
“Let the legislators who are paid with public money go back to their work and return the assembly hall to the legislature,” she said.
Responding to criticism from Lung that student activists occupying the legislative floor are “strong in action, but weak in their thinking,” student leader Lin Fei-fan (林飛帆) said that Lung is the one who is weak in her thinking.
“What Lung said about uscontradicts her comments about the Wild Lily student movement [野百合學運],” Lin said yesterday.
The chief mechanic in an air force unit from which an F-16 and its pilot went missing last week died on Sunday evening in what might have been a suicide, the Ministry of National Defense said yesterday. The ministry in a statement confirmed media reports that the mechanic, surnamed Huang (黃), “hurt himself” at a military barracks. Huang was taken to Hualien Armed Forces General Hospital after he was found unresponsive in the barracks, but doctors could not revive him, the ministry said. Huang served in the 26th Tactical Fighter Group of the 5th Tactical Fighter Wing, the same unit as the missing
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) last night said that it had no comment about reports that a senior US Navy officer had arrived in Taipei for a visit. Several media outlets reported that Rear Admiral Michael Studeman, director of intelligence of the US Indo-Pacific Command, arrived at Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport) on a special charter flight at about 7pm. The schedule of a “senior US official” in Taiwan would not be made public, the ministry said in a news release, without confirming the visit or the official’s identity. Interactions and exchanges between Taiwan and the US are common, and visits
NON-TYPICAL: Apart from Atsani, storms in autumn missed Taiwan, rainfall has been lower and average temperatures have been higher, a CWB forecaster said The current water shortage is expected to worsen in the next few months, with the Central Weather Bureau (CWB) yesterday forecasting a colder, dryer winter than normal. With winter starting next week, the bureau at a media briefing outlined the expected conditions through February and reviewed autumn’s significant weather events. Weather Forecast Center director Lu Kuo-cheng (呂國臣) said that autumn this year had three major characteristics: First, 13 tropical storms and typhoons formed from September to this month, up from 11 in the same period last year, Lu said. Apart from Atsani, for which sea and land alerts were issued in Taiwan, the tropical
The US’ inclusion of Taiwan in its Indo-Pacific Strategy is geared toward weakening Beijing’s influence in Southeast Asia, as well as providing a Blue Dot Network to counter China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a senior Executive Yuan member said yesterday. Taiwan and the US would be seeking further collaboration on infrastructure construction and energy, said the source, who spoke on condition of anonymity. The US and Taiwan signed a memorandum of understanding on the Framework to Strengthen Infrastructure, Finance and Market Cooperation on Sept. 17, which would see the Ministry of Finance and the US Department of the Treasury establishing respective task