After years of fruitless bickering over the legalization of surrogate motherhood, a panel made up of 20 members of the public advising the Department of Health met last weekend to thrash out a position on the issue.
"Before the public says yes or no to such personal issues, we need to ensure that every voice is heard," said Lin Kuo-ming (
Since the first of the nation's test-tube babies was born 19 years ago, the government has introduced regulations for artificial insemination to bring the country's legal system up to speed with medical advances and social change.
The Guidelines for the Ethics of Human Procreation and Reproductive Technologies (
In both laws, however, the controversial issue of surrogate motherhood was omitted.
The department played down the exclusion, asserting that "surrogate motherhood, at odds with current social mores and the legal system, and involving complex obligations and rights, should be temporarily left out," in an explanation on its Web site.
Despite the department's claim, some academics have urged the public to look deeper into the debate. The ethical and legal conundrum revolves around whether it is justified realizing the dreams of childless couples at the cost of reducing human relations to financial transactions.
"If reproduction is one of the basic human rights, then the means of human reproduction should be included, by definition," said Chiu Ching-hwa (邱清華), honorary president of the Society of Law and Medicine. "The public aversion to surrogate motherhood comes from one simple idea -- we might endorse this right to reproduction, but we don't want this right to become a marketable good or service."
Perhaps the biggest surprise in this debate is that some feminists have themselves become the most vocal opponents. Some oppose legalization, contending that surrogate motherhood is a materialization of the female body by medical technology.
"When not an act of love or charity, bearing a baby for another woman implies that the uterus has become more a tool to earn money than an intimate space for a fetus," said Huang Hsu-ying (黃淑英), chairwoman of the League of Taiwan Women.
Some feminists also argue that the notion of the surrogate mother, far from liberating women from the century-old myth of lineage and consanguinity on which patriarchy is founded, entrenches hegemony instead.
"Why must a woman take up the role of childbearer? By reconsolidating the link between `woman' and `childbearer,' surrogate motherhood can turn out to be the accomplice of patriarchy," Huang said.
But for those women in agony over their infertility, theories of female oppression by technology and the female body as a "discourse" of ideology do not address the harsh reality they suffer.
Chen Gau-tzu (陳昭姿), chief pharmacist at Taipei's Koo Foundation Sun Yat-sen Cancer Center, and who once sought another woman to have a baby for her, rebutted the feminists' argument as "healthy women oppressing unhealthy women in the name of feminism."
Chen said that signing a contract for pregnancy is probably the most self-aware and autonomous decision a surrogate mother and a custodial mother can make.
"Speaking from personal experience," Chen said, "I can tell you that the decision is well thought out. After all, it is a matter of life, not a war between ideologies."
Many people have suggested adoption as a less contested solution for couples wanting children, but Chen said there was no reason why one option should be legalized and another removed by the government and condemned by the public.
"We just want to keep options open. Whether to adopt or to use a surrogate mother is a question of personal preference, an issue of mutual consent. How can the public deny women their rights?" Chen said.
The panel, composed of 12 women and eight men randomly chosen from 92 applications, attended classes on the debate during the weekend-long meeting. Lin said that professors of sociology, law and medicine offered a range of perspectives. The panel's position is expected to serve as a litmus test for public reaction to surrogate motherhood.
The Taipei Department of Health yesterday said it has launched a probe into a restaurant at Far Eastern Sogo Xinyi A13 Department Store after a customer died of suspected food poisoning. A preliminary investigation on Sunday found missing employee health status reports and unsanitary kitchen utensils at Polam Kopitiam (寶林茶室) in the department store’s basement food court, the department said. No direct relationship between the food poisoning death and the restaurant was established, as no food from the day of the incident was available for testing and no other customers had reported health complaints, it said, adding that the investigation is ongoing. Later
REVENGE TRAVEL: A surge in ticket prices should ease this year, but inflation would likely keep tickets at a higher price than before the pandemic Scoot is to offer six additional flights between Singapore and Northeast Asia, with all routes transiting Taipei from April 1, as the budget airline continues to resume operations that were paused during the COVID-19 pandemic, a Scoot official said on Thursday. Vice president of sales Lee Yong Sin (李榮新) said at a gathering with reporters in Taipei that the number of flights from Singapore to Japan and South Korea with a stop in Taiwan would increase from 15 to 21 each week. That change means the number of the Singapore-Taiwan-Tokyo flights per week would increase from seven to 12, while Singapore-Taiwan-Seoul
BAD NEIGHBORS: China took fourth place among countries spreading disinformation, with Hong Kong being used as a hub to spread propaganda, a V-Dem study found Taiwan has been rated as the country most affected by disinformation for the 11th consecutive year in a study by the global research project Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem). The nation continues to be a target of disinformation originating from China, and Hong Kong is increasingly being used as a base from which to disseminate that disinformation, the report said. After Taiwan, Latvia and Palestine ranked second and third respectively, while Nicaragua, North Korea, Venezuela and China, in that order, were the countries that spread the most disinformation, the report said. Each country listed in the report was given a score,
POOR PREPARATION: Cultures can form on food that is out of refrigeration for too long and cooking does not reliably neutralize their toxins, an epidemiologist said Medical professionals yesterday said that suspected food poisoning deaths revolving around a restaurant at Far Eastern Department Store Xinyi A13 Store in Taipei could have been caused by one of several types of bacterium. Ho Mei-shang (何美鄉), an epidemiologist at Academia Sinica’s Institute of Biomedical Sciences, wrote on Facebook that the death of a 39-year-old customer of the restaurant suggests the toxin involved was either “highly potent or present in massive large quantities.” People who ate at the restaurant showed symptoms within hours of consuming the food, suggesting that the poisoning resulted from contamination by a toxin and not infection of the