While Taiwan is looking for an answer to its sovereignty problem, academics doubted that international treaties could provide a solid base for Taiwan's independent status.
"Big powers speak louder than international law," said Ho Szu-shen (
Many recent debates on Taiwan's sovereignty have referred to the 1951 San Francisco Peace Treaty.
Although the government is firm in its belief that Taiwan is a sovereign country, it has yet to convince much of the international community of the claim.
The San Francisco Peace Treaty, Ho said, can provide Taiwan with a legal and historical foundation for seeking justification of its sovereignty.
But the foundation, admitted Ho and other academics and officials, is not without cracks.
Moreover, Ho said, in the current international arena, national powers speak louder than international law.
If the San Francisco Peace Treaty does reveal anything significant about Taiwan's sovereignty, opinions of big countries like China and the US will still dominate the issue more than the treaty can, according to Ho.
On Sept. 5, 1951, under the leadership of countries such as the US and the UK, the allied nations of the World War IIconvened in San Francisco for a peace conference with Japan.
Lin Cheng-jung (
"Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek (
On Oct. 25, 1945, Chiang sent representatives to Taiwan and represented the allies at the ceremony accepting Japan's surrender of "the Chinese Theater's Taiwan Province," and temporarily took over control of Taiwan and the Penghu region after the departure of the Japanese Taiwan Governor's Office, Lin wrote.
However, partly due to the military conflicts between the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) that broke out after World War II and the CCP's founding ceremony of the People's Republic of China in 1949, "Chinese representatives were excluded from the San Francisco Peace Conference," Lin said.
The KMT regime led by Chiang retreated from China and ended up in exile in Taiwan and Penghu, "a region where its legal status had not been decided," said Lin, adding, "The outcome of the civil war in China resulted in a lack of consensus among the allies as to which region was the legitimate representative of China."
The US and other members of the allies bickered among one another over which government of China ought to sign a peace treaty with Japan, Lin wrote.
While Japan eventually chose to sign the treaty with Chiang's regime, "the treaty did not really view the Nationalist government as representing the only legitimate government of China," Lin wrote.
Concerning the question of Taiwan's status and jurisdiction, Article 2 of the San Francisco Peace Treaty stipulates that "Japan renounces all right, title and claim to Formosa and the Pescadores."
"Foreshadowed here is the fact that the final question of whom Taiwan belongs to remains undefined," Lin said.
Lin Man-houng (
However, Lin Chien-jung said the Treaty of Taipei, signed in accordance with the stipulations of the San Francisco Peace Treaty, did not move significantly beyond the latter in terms of its content about Taiwan's sovereignty.
Article 2 of the Treaty of Taipei says: "Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan (Formosa) and Penghu (the Pescadores) as well as the Spratley Islands and the Pacracel Islands."
The treaty does not grant sovereignty over those areas to the ROC, nor could it have done since Japan had already renounced sovereignty over Taiwan the previous year.
"So the question of whose jurisdiction Taiwan ultimately comes under is still not touched upon in the content of the Treaty of Taipei," Lin Chien-jung said.
Most people think of the contents of the 1943 Cairo Declaration or the 1945 Potsdam Declaration when discussing the issue of the jurisdiction of Taiwan after World War II, Lin Chien-jung added.
The Cairo Declaration says that "all the territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa and the Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China."
The Potsdam Declaration demanded that Japan surrender unconditionally and noted: "The terms of the Cairo Declaration shall be carried out."
"However, these `declarations' only state positions and wishes during the war, and although the functions of the declarations remain, they do not have any legal potency," Lin Chien-jung said.
In a speech delivered in July, former president Lee Teng-hui (李登輝) echoed Lin's argument about the lack of legal potency contained in the Cairo Declaration. He also said that the San Francisco Peace Treaty cannot fundamentally resolve Taiwan's sovereignty problem.
"People in Taiwan should think and try to find out the answer to Taiwan's sovereignty problem," Lee said at that time.
THE HAWAII FACTOR: While a 1965 opinion said an attack on Hawaii would not trigger Article 5, the text of the treaty suggests the state is covered, the report says NATO could be drawn into a conflict in the Taiwan Strait if Chinese forces attacked the US mainland or Hawaii, a NATO Defense College report published on Monday says. The report, written by James Lee, an assistant research fellow at Academia Sinica’s Institute of European and American Studies, states that under certain conditions a Taiwan contingency could trigger Article 5 of NATO, under which an attack against any member of the alliance is considered an attack against all members, necessitating a response. Article 6 of the North Atlantic Treaty specifies that an armed attack in the territory of any member in Europe,
FLU SEASON: Twenty-six severe cases were reported from Tuesday last week to Monday, including a seven-year-old girl diagnosed with influenza-associated encephalopathy Nearly 140,000 people sought medical assistance for diarrhea last week, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) said on Tuesday. From April 7 to Saturday last week, 139,848 people sought medical help for diarrhea-related illness, a 15.7 percent increase from last week’s 120,868 reports, CDC Epidemic Intelligence Center Deputy Director Lee Chia-lin (李佳琳) said. The number of people who reported diarrhea-related illness last week was the fourth highest in the same time period over the past decade, Lee said. Over the past four weeks, 203 mass illness cases had been reported, nearly four times higher than the 54 cases documented in the same period
Heat advisories were in effect for nine administrative regions yesterday afternoon as warm southwesterly winds pushed temperatures above 38°C in parts of southern Taiwan, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said. As of 3:30pm yesterday, Tainan’s Yujing District (玉井) had recorded the day’s highest temperature of 39.7°C, though the measurement will not be included in Taiwan’s official heat records since Yujing is an automatic rather than manually operated weather station, the CWA said. Highs recorded in other areas were 38.7°C in Kaohsiung’s Neimen District (內門), 38.2°C in Chiayi City and 38.1°C in Pingtung’s Sandimen Township (三地門), CWA data showed. The spell of scorching
A group of Taiwanese-American and Tibetan-American students at Harvard University on Saturday disrupted Chinese Ambassador to the US Xie Feng’s (謝鋒) speech at the school, accusing him of being responsible for numerous human rights violations. Four students — two Taiwanese Americans and two from Tibet — held up banners inside a conference hall where Xie was delivering a speech at the opening ceremony of the Harvard Kennedy School China Conference 2024. In a video clip provided by the Coalition of Students Resisting the CCP (Chinese Communist Party), Taiwanese-American Cosette Wu (吳亭樺) and Tibetan-American Tsering Yangchen are seen holding banners that together read: