For five days, Oscar Pistorius endured a withering cross-examination at his murder trial from a prosecutor who pounced on apparent inconsistencies in his testimony. Yet, legal analysts said on Tuesday, expert witnesses who are to testify for the defense could undermine the prosecution’s efforts to prove Pistorius killed girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp on purpose after an argument.
The demeanor of the Olympian, often fumbling for answers and occasionally breaking into sobs, contrasted with that of prosecutor Gerrie Nel, who called Pistorius a liar and unleashed volleys of barbed questions.
Social media buzzed that Pistorius is in deep trouble — a South African talk-show host wryly observed that the double-amputee runner had not “covered himself with glory” when his cross-examination ended on Tuesday — but experts said the trial has a long way to go.
Photo: AFP
“Until the defense presents the rest of their case, you can’t really evaluate the significance of any potential concessions that he may have made,” said Kelly Phelps, a senior lecturer in the public law department at the University of Cape Town.
The trial, which began on March 3 and is expected to hear testimony until the middle of next month, reached a key stage last week when Pistorius took the stand to testify about the circumstances of Steenkamp’s killing in his home before dawn on Feb. 14 last year. The Paralympic champion, 27, says he shot the 29-year-old model through a closed toilet door after mistaking her for an intruder, but Nel catalogued what he said were conflicts in Pistorius’ story that prove he made it up.
The prosecution provided a “very clear narrative for the first time” of what it says happened on the night of Steenkamp’s death, Phelps said. The judge, she said, must decide whether Pistorius’ inconsistencies were a result of his clumsily trying to polish a story that is true in its fundamentals, or instead revealed an “elaborate cover-up plot” after he murdered his lover.
Phelps said the prosecution accused Pistorius of changing his account mostly on “smaller details,” but that he had stuck to the “core parts of his story.”
Some commentators have speculated that Pistorius could face a lesser homicide charge that still carries long prison time in the event of a conviction.
Still, during cross-examination, Pistorius gave a sometimes muddled account of the shooting. He said he feared for his life, but also did not intentionally shoot at anyone, prompting Nel to query if his defense was self-defense or “involuntary action.”
Inconsistencies in the athlete’s testimony include his statement that Steenkamp did not scream when he shot her, but later saying his ears were ringing with the first of four gunshots and he would not have heard screams.
A vital part of the prosecution’s case is the testimony of neighbors who said they heard a woman’s terrified screams on the night that Steenkamp died; the defense says they actually heard Pistorius screaming in a high-pitched voice.
Pistorius’ credibility was further challenged by earlier testimony against him for three unrelated gun charges in which he denied any wrongdoing when questioned by Nel. Possibly in his favor was his lack of anger on the witness stand despite the prosecution’s picture of him as overbearing and arrogant.
Nevertheless, Marius du Toit, a former state prosecutor, magistrate and now criminal defense lawyer in South Africa, said Nel exceeded his goals in his cross-examination, even goading Pistorius into faulting his legal team while trying to clarify testimony. For example, chief defense lawyer Barry Roux said Pistorius fired two quick bursts — the gun owner’s terminology for such a burst is “double tap” — but Pistorius said he fired four shots in rapid succession.
However, Du Toit said the defense, which plans to call up to 17 witnesses, could still make it hard for the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Pistorius is guilty of premeditated murder, which carries a penalty of 25 years to life in prison. Du Toit said he was not convinced that the prosecution had shown that he intended to kill, adding that Pistorius fired roughly level with Steenkamp’s mid-section. Prosecution witnesses said the first bullet likely struck her in the hip.
“If you wanted to kill someone, you would shoot in the chest or the head,” Du Toit said, adding that it was “not all lost” for Pistorius even though the defense has a lot of hard work to do.
That work started right after Pistorius finished testifying. Roux, the defense lawyer, had the runner read out a Valentine’s Day card from Steenkamp that she allegedly brought him just before he killed her. In it, she tells Pistorius that she loves him.
Roux then called forensic expert and former police officer Roger Dixon, who contradicted parts of the prosecution’s case. Dixon said he conducted tests in Pistorius’ bedroom that proved it was very dark there at night, supporting Pistorius’ statement that he could not see Steenkamp in his bedroom on the night he killed her, and describing some aspects of the police investigation as “unprofessional.”
A sumo star was born in Japan on Sunday when 24-year-old Takerufuji became the first wrestler in 110 years to win a top-division tournament on his debut, triumphing at the 15-day Spring Grand Sumo Tournament in Osaka despite injuring his ankle on the penultimate day. Takerufuji, whose injury had left him in a wheelchair outside the ring, shoved out the higher-ranked Gonoyama at the Edion Arena Osaka to the delight of the crowd, giving him an unassailable record of 13 wins and two losses to claim the Emperor’s Cup. “I did it just through willpower. I didn’t really know what was going
The US’ Ilia Malinin on Saturday produced six scintillating quadruple jumps, including a quadruple Axel, in the men’s free skate to capture his first figure skating world title. The 19-year-old nicknamed the “Quad god,” who is the only skater to land a quadruple Axel in competition, dazzled with an array of breathtakingly executed jumps starting with his quad Axel and including a quadruple Lutz in combination with a triple flip and a quadruple toe loop in combination with a triple toe. He added an unexpected triple-triple combination at the end to earn a world-record 227.79 in the free program for a championship
Shohei Ohtani’s interpreter is being criminally investigated by the IRS, and the attorney for his alleged bookmaker said Thursday that the ex-Los Angeles Dodgers employee placed bets on international soccer — but not baseball. The IRS confirmed Thursday that interpreter Ippei Mizuhara and Mathew Bowyer, the alleged illegal bookmaker, are under criminal investigation through the agency’s Los Angeles Field Office. IRS Criminal Investigation spokesperson Scott Villiard said he could not provide additional details. Mizuhara, 39, was fired by the Dodgers on Wednesday following reports from the Los Angeles Times and ESPN about his alleged ties to an illegal bookmaker and debts well
HSIEH MAKES QUARTERS: Taiwan’s Hsieh Su-wei and Elise Mertens of Belgium won in the women’s doubles and face Bethanie Mattek-Sands and Sofia Kenin of the US Top-ranked Iga Swiatek and US Open champion Coco Gauff were knocked out of the women’s singles at the Miami Open on Monday, while Taiwan’s Hsieh Su-wei advanced in the women’s doubles. Swiatek lost to Ekaterina Alexandrova 6-4, 6-2, hours after third seed Gauff fell in three sets to No. 23 Caroline Garcia 6-3, 1-6, 6-2. Alexandrova beat a top-ranked player for the first time and advanced to face Jessica Pegula, a 7-6 (7/1), 6-3 winner over Emma Navarro, in the quarter-finals. Alexandrova recorded her second win over Swiatek, following a 2021 victory in Melbourne. Swiatek had won their three matches since. “We played quite