It was a surreal scene, 22 floors above a midtown Manhattan street. The four Pacers involved in last month's brawl -- Ron Artest, Jermaine O'Neal, Stephen Jackson and Anthony Johnson -- pleaded their cases Thursday for six hours before an independent arbitrator, hoping to get their suspensions reduced.
The hearing was conducted in the law firm of the NBA Players Association, Dewey Ballantine, three blocks from the league headquarters. No representative from the NBA attended.
"The fact that the NBA has elected not to participate was somewhat of a shock," said Billy Hunter, the executive director of the players union.
Artest was suspended for the season (73 games), Jackson for 30 games, O'Neal for 25 and Johnson for 5.
The arbitrator, Roger Kaplan, said it would be at least a week before he would rule on each player's case.
The league has said that an arbitrator has no jurisdiction to hear an appeal and that commissioner David Stern has the sole authority to determine punishments and hear an appeal about on-court incidents.
"It just means that the arbitrator got to hear our side and not any opposition or rebuttal that the NBA would care to introduce," Hunter said.
"They obviously have taken the position that they would challenge him in US District Court, assuming he ends up ruling in our favor."
The two sides will likely meet in federal court after Kaplan makes his rulings on both the suspensions and whether he had the right to hear the grievance in the first place.
The players gave their testimony along with Joe Smith, a bodyguard for O'Neal. A video was played isolating the players' actions from different angles of the Nov. 19 brawl that erupted late in the game against the Detroit Pistons and spilled into the stands.
Five players and five fans were charged Wednesday with misdemeanor assault and battery. One fan was also charged with a felony for throwing a chair.
"You can see the context of why people fear for their safety, why players feel for their own safety and why they feel for the safety of their own players they are trying to protect," said Jeffrey Kessler, a partner at Dewey Ballantine.
Hunter said Stern punished the players to make a point, and that he was influenced by what Hunter called the "shadow of alleged player image in the NBA."
"He wanted to demonstrate to both the fans and to the sponsors that he was not going to permit the NBA to implode," Hunter said. "That somebody was in charge. If it meant that one or two players had to be sacrificed in order to get that message out there, he was inclined and willing to do it."
Hunter said Stern did not have the sole right to hear an appeal because the brawl did not have to do with the "flow of the game."
For example, Hunter said, if a player exposed himself in the middle of the court, that would constitute an off-court incident because it had "nothing to do with the game itself."
In 1995, the collective bargaining agreement was amended to give the union an opportunity to appeal Stern's suspension regarding the "preservation of the integrity of the game" in a situation where the financial impact on a player is US$25,000 or less.
All four Pacers were suspended without pay.
The union's lawyers argued that the commissioner did not make a "reasonable" ruling in protecting the integrity of the game.
The only precedent for a player being fined for a violent incident with a fan was in 1994 when Vernon Maxwell was suspended 10 games and fined US$25,000 for going into the stands after a fan.
"All the players involved were extremely saddened by the entire incident," said Michael Curry, the president of the players union.
"One thing I caution everybody to understand is players react. And when you react, you don't have a chance to rewind and show the situation over and over again, as we all have had a chance to see on TV. A lot of their behavior was reaction to what was going on."
The league has already filed a complaint in federal court against the players and the union, claiming an arbitrator had no jurisdiction.
A sumo star was born in Japan on Sunday when 24-year-old Takerufuji became the first wrestler in 110 years to win a top-division tournament on his debut, triumphing at the 15-day Spring Grand Sumo Tournament in Osaka despite injuring his ankle on the penultimate day. Takerufuji, whose injury had left him in a wheelchair outside the ring, shoved out the higher-ranked Gonoyama at the Edion Arena Osaka to the delight of the crowd, giving him an unassailable record of 13 wins and two losses to claim the Emperor’s Cup. “I did it just through willpower. I didn’t really know what was going
The US’ Ilia Malinin on Saturday produced six scintillating quadruple jumps, including a quadruple Axel, in the men’s free skate to capture his first figure skating world title. The 19-year-old nicknamed the “Quad god,” who is the only skater to land a quadruple Axel in competition, dazzled with an array of breathtakingly executed jumps starting with his quad Axel and including a quadruple Lutz in combination with a triple flip and a quadruple toe loop in combination with a triple toe. He added an unexpected triple-triple combination at the end to earn a world-record 227.79 in the free program for a championship
Shohei Ohtani’s interpreter is being criminally investigated by the IRS, and the attorney for his alleged bookmaker said Thursday that the ex-Los Angeles Dodgers employee placed bets on international soccer — but not baseball. The IRS confirmed Thursday that interpreter Ippei Mizuhara and Mathew Bowyer, the alleged illegal bookmaker, are under criminal investigation through the agency’s Los Angeles Field Office. IRS Criminal Investigation spokesperson Scott Villiard said he could not provide additional details. Mizuhara, 39, was fired by the Dodgers on Wednesday following reports from the Los Angeles Times and ESPN about his alleged ties to an illegal bookmaker and debts well
MLB on Friday announced a formal investigation into the scandal swirling around Shohei Ohtani and his former interpreter amid charges that the Los Angeles Dodgers superstar was the victim of “massive theft.” The Dodgers on Wednesday fired Ippei Mizuhara, Ohtani’s long-time interpreter and close friend, after Ohtani’s representatives alleged that the Japanese two-way star had been the victim of theft, which was reported to involve millions of dollars and link Mizuhara to a suspected illegal bookmaker in California. “Major League Baseball has been gathering information since we learned about the allegations involving Shohei Ohtani and Ippei Mizuhara from the news media,” MLB