With a stinging attack on prosecutors, a federal judge threw out the case Friday against two civic leaders accused of bribery for lavishing US$1 million in cash, gifts and favors on Olympic officials to bring the 2002 Winter Games to Salt Lake City.
The ruling by US District Judge David Sam came midway through the trial of Tom Welch and Dave Johnson, and all but closes the book on the worst scandal in Olympic history.
The judge said that in his 18 years on the federal bench, he had never seen a case so devoid of "criminal intent or evil purpose." He said the evidence never met the legal standard for bribery, and the case "offends my sense of justice."
"Enough is enough," the 70-year-old Sam said.
The judge formally acquitted the men, which means the government cannot appeal, because retrying them would amount to double jeopardy.
Welch sat stoically, while Johnson wiped tears and gave his lawyer a long hug. The two men had faced up to 75 years in prison, though they probably would have gotten far less than that if convicted.
Welch, 59, was head of the committee of civic leaders that put together Salt Lake City's bid for the 2002 Winter Olympics; Johnson was his deputy.
Prosecutors had argued that the two committed fraud by taking money from a humanitarian program to dole out gifts and favors to the IOC who later selected Salt Lake City for the games in 1995.
The gifts included trips to Disneyland, stopovers at Paris hotels, guns, car repairs, bathroom furnishings, a Rolex watch, basketball tickets, shopping sprees, and college scholarships for IOC members' relatives.
Welch and Johnson insisted they committed no crime, arguing that the gifts were merely business as usual in the Olympic bidding process and that other countries did it, too. Both refused to accept plea bargains.
They were the only people charged in a scandal that resulted in the expulsion or resignation of 10 IOC members.
"Several times during the history of this case, I have heard [prosecutors] represent themselves as protectors of moral values here in the state of Utah,'' the judge said after the prosecution had completed its case. "How commendable and noteworthy. But when considered in light of the evidence of the government's evidence in this case, how misplaced."
Prosecutor Richard Wiedis said the judge had been "too hard" on the government.
"In our view, the evidence that the jury was permitted to hear was more than sufficient for the case to go to verdict," the Justice Department said in a statement. "We continue to believe that the citizens of the United States, especially the people of the state of Utah, had the right to have this criminal case decided by a jury."
The humanitarian program that paid for most of the gifts was actually meant for impoverished athletes from developing countries, but just 10 percent of the money "went to sports equipment -- soccer balls for athletes who needed and deserved them," the prosecutor said.
Even if the case had reached the jury, the prosecution would have been in trouble. At least eight jurors polled informally after the verdict expressed doubts about the government's case.
"I think it was a total waste of time," juror Mark Coombs said. "I'd love to know what this costs, what the taxpayers put out for this."
The judge also threw out the case in 2001 before it reached trial, sparing Salt Lake City the embarrassment of a courtroom spectacle during the Olympic games. A federal appeals court restored the charges in April, saying the government deserved a chance to put on its case.
Throughout the trial, Sam repeatedly ruled against prosecutors on evidence and frequently shut down their lines of questioning. He also loudly admonished them for arguing with his bench rulings.
Max Wheeler, Johnson's lawyer, said the government did little but "put lots of money in front of this jury and ask them to speculate as to the purpose of those payments. We have not heard from a single witness of a person being bribed."
Some of the government's own witnesses disputed the bribery allegations. They included Olympic trustee Spencer Eccles, the patriarch of a wealthy Utah banking clan, who donated US$500,000 for the Olympic pursuit. He turned on prosecutors Monday, calling their case "ill-conceived."
Welch lawyer Bill Taylor said there was no evidence that the two men lied to anyone about their spending.
A sumo star was born in Japan on Sunday when 24-year-old Takerufuji became the first wrestler in 110 years to win a top-division tournament on his debut, triumphing at the 15-day Spring Grand Sumo Tournament in Osaka despite injuring his ankle on the penultimate day. Takerufuji, whose injury had left him in a wheelchair outside the ring, shoved out the higher-ranked Gonoyama at the Edion Arena Osaka to the delight of the crowd, giving him an unassailable record of 13 wins and two losses to claim the Emperor’s Cup. “I did it just through willpower. I didn’t really know what was going
The US’ Ilia Malinin on Saturday produced six scintillating quadruple jumps, including a quadruple Axel, in the men’s free skate to capture his first figure skating world title. The 19-year-old nicknamed the “Quad god,” who is the only skater to land a quadruple Axel in competition, dazzled with an array of breathtakingly executed jumps starting with his quad Axel and including a quadruple Lutz in combination with a triple flip and a quadruple toe loop in combination with a triple toe. He added an unexpected triple-triple combination at the end to earn a world-record 227.79 in the free program for a championship
Shohei Ohtani’s interpreter is being criminally investigated by the IRS, and the attorney for his alleged bookmaker said Thursday that the ex-Los Angeles Dodgers employee placed bets on international soccer — but not baseball. The IRS confirmed Thursday that interpreter Ippei Mizuhara and Mathew Bowyer, the alleged illegal bookmaker, are under criminal investigation through the agency’s Los Angeles Field Office. IRS Criminal Investigation spokesperson Scott Villiard said he could not provide additional details. Mizuhara, 39, was fired by the Dodgers on Wednesday following reports from the Los Angeles Times and ESPN about his alleged ties to an illegal bookmaker and debts well
MLB on Friday announced a formal investigation into the scandal swirling around Shohei Ohtani and his former interpreter amid charges that the Los Angeles Dodgers superstar was the victim of “massive theft.” The Dodgers on Wednesday fired Ippei Mizuhara, Ohtani’s long-time interpreter and close friend, after Ohtani’s representatives alleged that the Japanese two-way star had been the victim of theft, which was reported to involve millions of dollars and link Mizuhara to a suspected illegal bookmaker in California. “Major League Baseball has been gathering information since we learned about the allegations involving Shohei Ohtani and Ippei Mizuhara from the news media,” MLB