Print

Mail

wiki links

One Year On: Politics - Embattled vice president faces up to tough test

By Lin Mei-chun
STAFF REPORTER
Sunday, May 20, 2001, Page 14

As Taiwan's first female vice president, Annette Lu has never been far from controversy during her initial year in office. FILE PHOTO

As a democracy activist during the dark years of martial law, Annette Lu (呂秀蓮) has fought some tough battles. Yet few have been harder than her first year as the first female vice president in Taiwan's history.

The energetic, expressive and sometimes fiery vice president has been a source of controversy at the Presidential Office. This is largely, say political critics and government officials, because she does not fully understand the role of a vice president as dictated by the Constitution, and also in part because of her headstrong nature. Lu's determination to achieve something for her country comes into conflict with the relative powerlessness of her position.

A firm independence advocate, Lu has excoriated Beijing's hard-line stance on Taiwan. Domestically, she lashed out at the government's rescue work over the Pachang Creek (八掌溪) tragedy last July, saying it had been too slow and President Chen Shui-bian's (陳水扁) apology had come too late to assuage public anger.

In the past year, Lu has also reportedly transgressed her authority by calling high-ranking officials from the Cabinet to her office to discuss national affairs. Staying in the background is something that Lu is, perhaps, just temperamentally incapable of doing.

"In the past, some vice presidents also served as premier -- because they were men, everyone took it for granted. Now for the first time a woman has become vice president and everyone tries to downgrade the role," Lu, a staunch feminist and women's rights activist, has said.

Annette Lu Age: 57 Experience: Political prisoner (jailed for five years for her part in the Kaohsiung Incident) Women's rights activist. Promoter of Taiwan's entry to the UN Legislator, Taoyuan County Commissioner. Successes: Soft diplomacy (a trip to Latin America last September). Failures: Frayed relations with the media Criticized for exceeding her authority. Grade: C-

Governmental officials, however, bridle at suggestions that gender is a consideration regarding their problems with what they see as a wayward vice president.

"She always plays the sexism card whenever she doesn't get her own way, but that just blurs the real focus of the matter," said an official at the Presidential Office, who requested anonymity.

He pointed out that Lu's discontent was the result of her inadequate understanding of her constitutional role.

"Vice presidents have no real power according to the Constitution. What [Lu] ought to accept is the reality that the presidency can't be shared, nor is a vice president a co-president. There can't be two suns in the sky, and there can't be two emperors in an empire," the official said.

"The job of a vice president is to assist the president, not to outshine the president. This is not only a practice in Taiwan, but also a common rule of the game in all democratic countries."

Offering similar views, Hwang Jau-yuan (黃昭元), an associate law professor at National Taiwan University, noted that the Constitution has only one ordinance to state the power of vice presidents, which says, "in the event the office of the President should become vacant, the vice president shall succeed until the expiration of the original presidential term."

"Accordingly, under the Constitution, vice presidents are the first candidates to succeed the president if this becomes necessary, but they are by no means leading figures in governmental operations," Hwang said.

Lu's lack of political tact has shown itself by her lodging open protests against the government in an effort to gain more power. Political commentators see this as a result of Lu's tough, uncompromising personality.

"Simply because there is no distinct regulation to categorize the authority of vice presidents in the Constitution, it is essential for Lu to remain in harmony with President Chen, because it is totally up to him to determine how much power he is willing to bestow upon his deputy," said Chin Heng-wei (金恆煒), editor in chief of Contemporary Monthly.

"But it is obvious that there is a serious schism between the two heads of the state, and these frayed relations are not due to her gender, but her character," Chin said.

Rising to prominence in Taiwan last May, Lu fought her way to the top mostly on her own.

Most political commentators have a high opinion of Lu's intelligence and ability to fill a leadership role. But they also see her as obstinate, self-centered and, most important of all, reluctant to play second fiddle.

"The problem isn't her ability -- she is brilliant in her own right. But she is not a team player; she only pushes her own agenda. Intractable and egocentric, she is very difficult to get along with," said the Presidential Office official.

Chang Fu-mei (張富美), a long-time friend of Lu and chairperson of the Overseas Chinese Affairs Commission, gave the vice president her advice.

"To obtain more power, [Lu] had better first win the trust of President Chen through communication -- not by being outspoken, but by being polite," Chang suggested.

"It is a basic courtesy for partners to inform each other about what's going on in each other's domain, and it is important [for Lu] to keep tabs on her every single word to prevent the media from exaggerating or misinterpreting her utterances," Chang said.
This story has been viewed 2199 times.