A draft law intended to give Aborigines better intellectual property protection has come under fire from some of those it was designed to protect.
Some critics argue that the law, drafted within the framework of modern intellectual property rights jurisprudence, does not accord with basic Aboriginal cultural concepts.
Others argue that the law would stop the spread of Aboriginal cultural artifacts and thus limit outside appreciation of these cultures at a time when their best hope of survival lies in wider cultural dissemination.
PHOTO: CHEN CHENG-CHANG, TAIPEI TIMES
The draft of the Protection of Traditional Aboriginal Intellectual Property Rights Law (原住民族傳統智慧創作保護法) was released by the Executive Yuan's Council of Aboriginal Affairs (原住民委員會) last Wednesday.
Director of the Council's Planning Department Jeng Tian-tsair (
The bill was drafted by Tsai Ming-cheng (蔡明誠), a National Taiwan University professor, at the request of the Council for Aboriginal Affairs.
Currently, the folklore of Taiwan Aborigines, including traditional ceremonies and art forms, is treated as ordinary intellectual property -- "property that results from original creative thought," according to Webster's Dictionary -- which includes, as well as copyright material, patents and trademarks. All are currently protected mainly under the Copyright Law (著作權法).
The current law is said by advocates of new legislation to give inadequate protection to Aborigines because it does not cover rituals and other expressions of Aboriginal folklore, such as tattoos. The current law grants automatic protection from the moment of creation of the property, while the Aborigines' concept of "creation" is different, allowing for reinterpretation, variation and the continuing development of cultural phenomena.
Different concept of property
Aborigines also adhere to a radically different concept of ownership from that covered by the current law. In the Aboriginal view, folklore is a group creation, belonging to the tribe in question, rather than to any sole individual, particularly as it is seen to have its origins in a collective Aboriginal heritage.
"Under copyright law, property rights are protected for 50 years after creation. Traditional folklore surely exists for more than 50 years. But is it reasonable not to protect folklore?," asks Chang Chung-hsin (
Chang goes on to cite the case of Kuo Ying-nan (郭英男), better known under the name of Difang, and his wife, as a landmark example of folk-song copyright infringement. Seven years ago, the Amis tribe's (阿美族) "Elders' Drinking Song" (飲酒歡樂歌), sung by Difang, was plagiarized by the German rock band, Enigma. The rhythm was remixed into another song, "Return to Innocence" which was adopted as a theme tune during the 1996 Atlanta Olympic Games. EMI and Magic Stone records (acting for Difang) settled out of court and agreed to give Difang and his wife credit for the song in future recordings. EMI paid substantial compensation. The money was used by Magic Stone to set up a fund for conserving recordings of Amis music last year.
Under the draft bill, Aboriginal intellectual property would be forever protected. Protected items would include religious ceremonies and other rituals, music, dance, sculpture, needlework, totems, clothing and, expressly, "other expressions of folklore."
Also under the bill, transfer of ownership is forbidden. Others may be granted use if an agreement is reached between the tribe in question and the party seeking to use the material.
Unlike ordinary copyright law, under which protection commences automatically upon creation of the property, the draft bill requires that items be registered and judged by a screening committee of experts before protection may be granted.
Omass Roladeng (
Avoiding mass production
Referring to his business producing Paiwan beads, Omass adds, "Sometimes we reject orders from foreigners as we haven't the capacity to fill them. Expanding production is risky because of the possibility of faking, which would cost us dearly. A better law, however, will surely defend our rights and conserve our culture," Omass said.
There is opposition to the bill among Aborigines, however.
"The draft bill isn't comprehensive. Medical items, such as special herbs and medicinal remedies should also be protected," said anthropologist Taipou Sasala (趙貴忠).
Jack Chang (張俊傑), Atayal (泰雅族) member of a famous independent band, Fei Yu Yun Bao (Fly Fish Cloud Leopard, 飛魚雲豹音樂工團) also opposes the bill. "Surely this bill can only block, not protect the spread of our culture," he asserts.
His comments are the prelude to a litany of objections. "Our folklore," he goes on, "is something totally different from the intellectual products that abound in the modern world. They have hit upon the concept of intellectual property rights to conserve our culture, but this is not the way to go. How to conserve our culture should be determined by Aboriginal traditions, not by modern law.
Pointing to the ravages inflicted upon Aboriginal life by powerful commercial interests, he rails. "Also, such a bill would only protect Aboriginal singers backed by big record companies. The commercialization of Aboriginal music, rather than the mere theft of folklore, is the biggest threat to our culture. Only big record companies can take advantage of the law."
Finally, highlighting perhaps a fundamental divergence of Aboriginal views about the role of the culture, he says, "We should encourage the spread of our songs, not set limits to prevent people from singing them. Improper protection will simply curb the development of our culture."
The government is aiming to recruit 1,096 foreign English teachers and teaching assistants this year, the Ministry of Education said yesterday. The foreign teachers would work closely with elementary and junior-high instructors to create and teach courses, ministry official Tsai Yi-ching (蔡宜靜) said. Together, they would create an immersive language environment, helping to motivate students while enhancing the skills of local teachers, she said. The ministry has since 2021 been recruiting foreign teachers through the Taiwan Foreign English Teacher Program, which offers placement, salary, housing and other benefits to eligible foreign teachers. Two centers serving northern and southern Taiwan assist in recruiting and training
WIDE NET: Health officials said they are considering all possibilities, such as bongkrekic acid, while the city mayor said they have not ruled out the possibility of a malicious act of poisoning Two people who dined at a restaurant in Taipei’s Far Eastern Department Store Xinyi A13 last week have died, while four are in intensive care, the Taipei Department of Health said yesterday. All of the outlets of Malaysian vegetarian restaurant franchise Polam Kopitiam have been ordered to close pending an investigation after 11 people became ill due to suspected food poisoning, city officials told a news conference in Taipei. The first fatality, a 39-year-old man who ate at the restaurant on Friday last week, died of kidney failure two days later at the city’s Mackay Memorial Hospital. A 66-year-old man who dined
‘CARRIER KILLERS’: The Tuo Chiang-class corvettes’ stealth capability means they have a radar cross-section as small as the size of a fishing boat, an analyst said President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) yesterday presided over a ceremony at Yilan County’s Suao Harbor (蘇澳港), where the navy took delivery of two indigenous Tuo Chiang-class corvettes. The corvettes, An Chiang (安江) and Wan Chiang (萬江), along with the introduction of the coast guard’s third and fourth 4,000-tonne cutters earlier this month, are a testament to Taiwan’s shipbuilding capability and signify the nation’s resolve to defend democracy and freedom, Tsai said. The vessels are also the last two of six Tuo Chiang-class corvettes ordered from Lungteh Shipbuilding Co (龍德造船) by the navy, Tsai said. The first Tuo Chiang-class vessel delivered was Ta Chiang (塔江)
EYE ON STRAIT: The US spending bill ‘doubles security cooperation funding for Taiwan,’ while also seeking to counter the influence of China US President Joe Biden on Saturday signed into law a US$1.2 trillion spending package that includes US$300 million in foreign military financing to Taiwan, as well as funding for Taipei-Washington cooperative projects. The US Congress early on Saturday overwhelmingly passed the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act 2024 to avoid a partial shutdown and fund the government through September for a fiscal year that began six months ago. Under the package, the Defense Appropriations Act would provide a US$27 billion increase from the previous fiscal year to fund “critical national defense efforts, including countering the PRC [People’s Republic of China],” according to a summary