Tue, Jul 30, 2019 - Page 14 News List

Han Kuo-yu criticized for tree climb stunt
韓國瑜爬樹看防疫 提出發泡劑填樹洞惹議

Kaohsiung Mayor Han Kuo-yu poses for a photograph while climbing a tree in Kaohsiung on Wednesday during an inspection of dengue fever prevention work.

Photo: CNA

The dengue fever epidemic in Kaohsiung continues to worsen: as of Wednesday, 45 cases of the viral disease have been confirmed in the municipality. Last week, Kaohsiung Mayor Han Kuo-yu, together with officials from Kaohsiung City Government Department of Health, carried out a “hands-on” review of the city’s epidemic prevention measures. Han’s inspection tour included examining guttering on the roofs of buildings but also took in tree hollows, which can turn into a vector source for mosquitoes carrying the disease if water accumulates inside.

Han, who has a short and stocky physique, scaled a tree by himself to inspect a tree hollow. Han told the assembled press pack that workers should use expanding insulation foam and prune trees to prevent the spread of dengue fever, sparking controversy online.

Kaohsiung City Councilor Huang Jie posted on Facebook that it would have been better if Han had used the opportunity to demonstrate to the public the importance of removing containers of stagnant water and tidying up within residential areas. Huang said this would be a far more effective method of epidemic prevention and added a more pragmatic course of action would be for the mayor to assume overall command back at Kaohsiung City Hall from where he could supervise the allocation of manpower and resources. Huang expressed concern that filling up tree hollows with expanding insulation foam could pose an existential threat to the city’s woodpecker population.

Responding to the news last Thursday, Kaohsiung Love Trees Society director Chuang Chieh-jen said a far more significant vector source of dengue fever is ditches and drains within the city where water has been allowed to accumulate over the long term. Chuang said using expanding insulation foam will simply damage the trees’ trunks and cause rot and decay. Chuang suggested using sand to fill hollows or alternatively drilling small holes to allow accumulated water to naturally drain away.

Chuang added that the primary cause of tree hollows is the pruning of branches of a 5cm diameter thickness or greater, which causes ulceration to the tree trunk. Chuang called on Han to review his administration’s policy on tree pruning and ban the pruning of branches between 5-10cm in diameter.

Responding to criticism, the director of the Public Works Bureau’s Maintenance Office, Wang Miao-chen, said that the expanding insulation foam used was non-absorbent and said tree hollows often form naturally as a way to protect the bark of the trunk and are not created by pruning. Wang said foam will not cause the trunk to rot and added that using foam is a feasible, effective and long-lasting solution. Kaohsiung’s frequent thunder and rain storms means that using expanding foam can save manpower and resources, said Wang.

Answering questions last week, Han said that climbing a tree shows he attaches great importance to tackling the epidemic, adding he trusts that officials and contractors will be able to see that he is taking the problem seriously and has the resolve to get a grip of the situation.

“If experts believe this will damage the trees, I will take their views on board,” but for the time being we will continue to employ this method.

Han added he climbed the tree for the good of the city’s residents, that he feels no shame and that any criticism or parodies of him are water off a duck’s back.

This story has been viewed 2588 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top