The Taiwan High Court on Monday filed a request for a constitutional interpretation by the Council of Grand Justices on desecration of the flag, saying the Criminal Code penalizing such actions might infringe on freedom of speech, freedom of thought and proportionality.
The request was prompted by the case of independence advocates Chen Yi-ting (陳儀庭), Chen Miao-ting (陳妙婷) and three others, whose conviction for cutting up a dozen flags in 2015 was overturned on appeal by the New Taipei City District Court.
New Taipei City prosecutors appealed the overturned conviction.
Photo: George Tsorng, Taipei Times
High Court judges Chou Ying-wen (周盈文), Lin Meng-huang (林孟皇) and Lin Hai-hsiang (林海祥) decided to suspend the appeal trial to allow time for a constitutional interpretation.
The Criminal Code’s prohibition of purposeful and public vandalism of the flag under Article 160 could be an infringement on the right to free speech and thought that is stipulated by Article 11 of the Constitution, the judges said.
The penalty of less than one year in prison might also clash with the principle of proportionality guaranteed by Article 23 of the Constitution, they said.
Although the flag should be honored as the nation’s symbol, its meaning to each citizen might vary and the spirit of liberty, equality and fraternity is better preserved via the toleration of dissent, not its punishment, they said.
On Oct. 10, 2015, the two Chens and three other members of the Taiwan Nationalist Party cut up flags that were displayed along Zhongzheng Bridge (中正橋) in New Taipei City. There were arrested and in their first trial were sentenced to 20 days imprisonment, commutable to a NT$20,000 fine.
The two Chens and fellow defendant Wu Hsin-en (吳馨恩) appealed the conviction, arguing that their action was a legitimate form of expression and damaging the flag was an expression of criticism on the Republic of China’s colonial repression of Taiwanese.
The New Taipei City District Court ruled in the defendants’ favor at the retrial, adding that political speech should be afforded the highest level of constitutional protection, prompting the prosecutors to appeal to the High Court.
Chen Yi-ting on Monday said that decriminalizing flag desecration would allow activists more freedom to criticize the political order.
National Taiwan University professor of law Chen Chih-lung (陳志龍) said that desecrating the flag was made a crime under the Republic of China’s Criminal Code during the 1930s due to the influence on China of Nazi Germany and other fascist states.
Most Western countries have decriminalized flag burning and other forms of protest targeting the national flag, he said.
Protesters who vandalize the flag do not cause real harm or damage and their actions are often motivated by deep and sincerely held convictions, which should be protected as a matter of conscience, he said.
“The Taiwan High Court did not need to suspend the trial or file for a constitutional interpretation, because it is already empowered to rule out the applicability of the Criminal Code to this case,” the professor said.
National Chengchi University associate professor of law Bruce Liao (廖元豪) said the US Supreme Court had struck down state laws penalizing flag desecration as violating free speech in the case Johnson v Texas.
For this reason, he would like to see the Council of Grand Justices rule on the issue, Liao said.
Charging protesters with damaging public property to the actual cash value of the flag would be more appropriate recompense for their actions, he added.
RETHINK? The defense ministry and Navy Command Headquarters could take over the indigenous submarine project and change its production timeline, a source said Admiral Huang Shu-kuang’s (黃曙光) resignation as head of the Indigenous Submarine Program and as a member of the National Security Council could affect the production of submarines, a source said yesterday. Huang in a statement last night said he had decided to resign due to national security concerns while expressing the hope that it would put a stop to political wrangling that only undermines the advancement of the nation’s defense capabilities. Taiwan People’s Party Legislator Vivian Huang (黃珊珊) yesterday said that the admiral, her older brother, felt it was time for him to step down and that he had completed what he
Taiwan has experienced its most significant improvement in the QS World University Rankings by Subject, data provided on Sunday by international higher education analyst Quacquarelli Symonds (QS) showed. Compared with last year’s edition of the rankings, which measure academic excellence and influence, Taiwanese universities made great improvements in the H Index metric, which evaluates research productivity and its impact, with a notable 30 percent increase overall, QS said. Taiwanese universities also made notable progress in the Citations per Paper metric, which measures the impact of research, achieving a 13 percent increase. Taiwanese universities gained 10 percent in Academic Reputation, but declined 18 percent
CHINA REACTS: The patrol and reconnaissance plane ‘transited the Taiwan Strait in international airspace,’ the 7th Fleet said, while Taipei said it saw nothing unusual The US 7th Fleet yesterday said that a US Navy P-8A Poseidon flew through the Taiwan Strait, a day after US and Chinese defense heads held their first talks since November 2022 in an effort to reduce regional tensions. The patrol and reconnaissance plane “transited the Taiwan Strait in international airspace,” the 7th Fleet said in a news release. “By operating within the Taiwan Strait in accordance with international law, the United States upholds the navigational rights and freedoms of all nations.” In a separate statement, the Ministry of National Defense said that it monitored nearby waters and airspace as the aircraft
UNDER DISCUSSION: The combatant command would integrate fast attack boat and anti-ship missile groups to defend waters closest to the coastline, a source said The military could establish a new combatant command as early as 2026, which would be tasked with defending Taiwan’s territorial waters 24 nautical miles (44.4km) from the nation’s coastline, a source familiar with the matter said yesterday. The new command, which would fall under the Naval Command Headquarters, would be led by a vice admiral and integrate existing fast attack boat and anti-ship missile groups, along with the Naval Maritime Surveillance and Reconnaissance Command, said the source, who asked to remain anonymous. It could be launched by 2026, but details are being discussed and no final timetable has been announced, the source