NASA was warned nine years ago that the space shuttle could fail catastrophically if debris hit the vulnerable underside of its wings during liftoff -- the very scenario that may have brought down Columbia.
After receiving the warning, NASA made changes in materials and flight rules to lessen the risk of debris breaking loose, Paul Fischbeck, an engineering professor at Carnegie Mellon University who conducted the 1994 analysis, said Tuesday.
"There are very important tiles under there. If you lose the tiles on those stretches ... it can cause the shuttle to be lost," he said.
The underside of the left wing is where NASA is focusing its investigation into Saturday's disaster, which killed seven astronauts.
A spokesman at NASA's Johnson Space Center, David Drachlis, said Tuesday night that no one was available to comment on the report.
Also Tuesday, the space agency sent teams to check out reports of shuttle debris found as far west as California and Arizona -- material that could shed light on the earliest stages of Columbia's breakup. Later in the day, authorities in Texas said a 1.8m to 2.1m section of what they believe to be part of a shuttle wing was found in a pond east of Nacogdoches.
In Vernon Parish, Louisiana, a woman out walking found a small, ragged piece of fabric with a Star of David, Sheriff Sam Craft said. The symbol, in a circle between blue and silver bars, is the flag of the Israeli Air Force and is presumably from the suit of Israeli astronaut Ilan Ramon.
Investigators also are getting new military images of the spacecraft's fiery, dying streak across the country from an Apache helicopter.
Fischbeck and a colleague at Stanford University studied the damage caused by debris during the first 50 shuttle launches and concluded that on average, 25 thermal tiles per flight sustained damage of at least 2.5cm.
He said his risk analysis showed that the most vulnerable spots on the shuttle were the undersides of both wings close to the fuselage, and right under the crew compartment. To reach that conclusion, he weighed three factors: which tiles were most likely to be hit by debris, which tiles endured a lot of heat on atmospheric re-entry, and which tiles had critical systems underneath them.
It is not clear exactly where under the wing Columbia was hit, but just before the shuttle break up, temperature spikes were detected around the left wheel well, which is close to the fuselage, and on the left side of the fuselage itself.
Fischbeck said NASA "took a lot of our advice to heart" and made improvements such as changing the foam insulation on the top of the booster rockets and allowing less ice to be present on the fuel tanks before liftoff. Ice forms on the tank because of the super-cold liquid hydrogen and oxygen inside.
The investigation into the Columbia disaster is focusing on the possibility that a 1kg, 20cm chunk of foam insulation from the shuttle's external fuel tank fell off during liftoff and hit the left underside of the wing, causing damage to the thermal tiles that doomed the ship.
Fischbeck stressed that no one knows with absolute certainty yet whether the debris brought down Columbia or where precisely that debris hit.
Fischbeck's report looked at damage to the tiles from the insulating foam on the external fuel tank and the booster rockets, as well as from ice. He said while the tiles under the right wing had a slightly higher likelihood of being struck, "if the ones under the left wing were hit, then they were equally damaging to the orbiter."
Fischbeck said during the first 50 shuttle flights, from 1981 through 1992, the damage per flight ranged from three tiles to 150 tiles.
The foam and the tiles have been a source of concern at NASA practically from the start.
Over the years, foam insulation often damaged the tiles. In fact, soon after NASA stopped using Freon in the foam, for environmental reasons, Columbia sustained significant tile damage during a 1997 liftoff because of flyaway foam, according to a report by NASA engineer Gregory Katnik.
Katnik raised the possibility at the time that the new foam concoction was not compatible with the severe conditions of takeoff. The foam recipe apparently was altered somewhat after the 1997 incident.
"The thing of this is, almost since Day One, the insulation has been a pain. Pieces break off," said Seymour Himmel, a retired NASA executive who served two decades on an aerospace safety panel and looked into the potential dangers of the foam.
While the foam is a lightweight, polyurethane, spray-on material that goes on like shaving cream, it hardens like plastic foam. Given the speed at which shuttles hurtle into space during takeoff, it can have a devastating effect. Moreover, the black, silica glass fiber tiles that cover the belly of the shuttle are famously fragile, so much so that even a bump or nudge can cause cracks or dings.
NASA has said that during Columbia's mission, its engineers carefully analyzed the potential damage done by the foam and concluded that the crew was in no danger.
On Monday, Michael Kostelnik, deputy associate administrator for spaceflight, said that the chunk that fell from the tank and hit Columbia's tiles was ``probably the largest piece we've had'' of any shuttle mission.
Even some of the pros have trouble accepting the notion that foam could have resulted in the catastrophe.
"I can see it scratching or even gouging a couple of tiles. But God, the idea that it could compromise the system ... I just have a hard time believing that," said astronaut Mike Mullane, who rode Atlantis into orbit in 1988.
He recalled that a tip of one of his booster rockets broke off during launch and slammed into the belly of the shuttle, damaging a few hundred tiles. One came off entirely. Yet Atlantis and its crew of five still made it safely home.
RETHINK? The defense ministry and Navy Command Headquarters could take over the indigenous submarine project and change its production timeline, a source said Admiral Huang Shu-kuang’s (黃曙光) resignation as head of the Indigenous Submarine Program and as a member of the National Security Council could affect the production of submarines, a source said yesterday. Huang in a statement last night said he had decided to resign due to national security concerns while expressing the hope that it would put a stop to political wrangling that only undermines the advancement of the nation’s defense capabilities. Taiwan People’s Party Legislator Vivian Huang (黃珊珊) yesterday said that the admiral, her older brother, felt it was time for him to step down and that he had completed what he
ROLLER-COASTER RIDE: More than five earthquakes ranging from magnitude 4.4 to 5.5 on the Richter scale shook eastern Taiwan in rapid succession yesterday afternoon Back-to-back weather fronts are forecast to hit Taiwan this week, resulting in rain across the nation in the coming days, the Central Weather Administration said yesterday, as it also warned residents in mountainous regions to be wary of landslides and rockfalls. As the first front approached, sporadic rainfall began in central and northern parts of Taiwan yesterday, the agency said, adding that rain is forecast to intensify in those regions today, while brief showers would also affect other parts of the nation. A second weather system is forecast to arrive on Thursday, bringing additional rain to the whole nation until Sunday, it
CONDITIONAL: The PRC imposes secret requirements that the funding it provides cannot be spent in states with diplomatic relations with Taiwan, Emma Reilly said China has been bribing UN officials to obtain “special benefits” and to block funding from countries that have diplomatic ties with Taiwan, a former UN employee told the British House of Commons on Tuesday. At a House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee hearing into “international relations within the multilateral system,” former Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) employee Emma Reilly said in a written statement that “Beijing paid bribes to the two successive Presidents of the [UN] General Assembly” during the two-year negotiation of the Sustainable Development Goals. Another way China exercises influence within the UN Secretariat is
CHINA REACTS: The patrol and reconnaissance plane ‘transited the Taiwan Strait in international airspace,’ the 7th Fleet said, while Taipei said it saw nothing unusual The US 7th Fleet yesterday said that a US Navy P-8A Poseidon flew through the Taiwan Strait, a day after US and Chinese defense heads held their first talks since November 2022 in an effort to reduce regional tensions. The patrol and reconnaissance plane “transited the Taiwan Strait in international airspace,” the 7th Fleet said in a news release. “By operating within the Taiwan Strait in accordance with international law, the United States upholds the navigational rights and freedoms of all nations.” In a separate statement, the Ministry of National Defense said that it monitored nearby waters and airspace as the aircraft