Wed, May 29, 2002 - Page 1 News List

Air traffic control had no role in crash

PROCESS OF ELIMINATION While investigators have ruled out weather and air traffic control instructions as being behind Saturday's plane crash, they did not share any theories about what did cause the disaster

By Monique Chu  /  STAFF REPORTER , IN PENGHU

Families of the victims of China Airlines flight CI116 throw paper money at the crash site yesterday. The Taoist ceremony featured a chao hun fan, center, which calls back the souls of the dead so they are not left to wander.

PHOTO: GEORGE TSORNG, TAIPEI TIMES

Investigators composed of US and Taiwanese aviation experts yesterday ruled out air traffic control mistakes or weather conditions as causes of Saturday's deadly China Airlines crash as they expanded the investigation's search area.

"Weather conditions and air traffic control had nothing to do with the crash," said Managing Director of the Aviation Safety Council (ASC) Yong Kay (戎凱) late yesterday afternoon after the 52-member investigation team met in the morning.

"The weather conditions over the Makung area from 3pm to 4pm on May 25 were quite good," Yong said based on related data gathered from the Central Weather Bureau, the Civil Aviation Bureau's weather center as well as the Japanese GSM5 weather satellite.

As the critical 72-hour post-crash search period passed yesterday, investigators expanded the area of search for wreckage and for the flight data recorder and cockpit voice recorder -- the so-called "black boxes" -- of the crashed plane.

"The search area today [yesterday] reached 16,129km2, with 228 vessels joining the effort," said Minister of Transportation and Communications Lin Lin-shan (林陵三).

A total of 258 vessels would be on the sea by early this morning, as another 30 Kaohsiung-based naval vessels were to joining the search team in Penghu, Lin said.

Officials, however, admitted the investigation and search efforts still have a long way to go.

"The debris retrieved so far constitutes only 0.1 percent of the crashed plane," Yong said.

Yong added that none of the wreckage found has shown any trace of fire.

Although the black boxes had yet to be found, the chances were not high that the units would fall into an oceanic trench of 150m to 200m in depth in the Taiwan Strait as currents were expected to push the units and wreckage northwest -- in the opposite direction from the location of the trench, Yong said.

Yong said that signals emitted by the two units were expected to become weaker and weaker after 20 to 25 days, although their batteries could last up to 30 days.

"If we can't recover the black boxes by the 20th day, then it could get difficult," Yong said.

Three more bodies were recovered yesterday, bringing the number of bodies found to 86 in total, leaving 140 missing.

Aside from the expansion of the scale of the search, assistance from the US side also grew yesterday as four experts from the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and two staffers from the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) joined the investigation.

A NTSB expert, who brought an underwater locator with him, embarked with an expert from the US aerospace firm Boeing and an ASC staffer to scour the area, but the search yielded no concrete results, said Tracy Jen (任靜怡), spokeswoman for the investigative team.

Experts from the Boeing, the jumbo jet's manufacturer, and from Pratt and Whitney, the engine's manufacturer, arrived in Penghu on Monday to help with the investigation.

According to Annex 13 to the International Civil Aviation Convention, the states of registry, operator, design and manufacture have the right to appoint an Accredited Representative to the investigation led by the country where the accident occurred.

The US experts yesterday also examined the wreckage that has been recovered so far, which has been placed in a warehouse at the Makung air force base.

This story has been viewed 4766 times.
TOP top