Taiwan’s land is fertile ground for fruits and vegetables — as well as rumors about them.
In recent years, plants have been the subject of fake news ranging from the relatively innocuous — bogus health claims that saw entire villages drying daisies for a tonic to cure diabetes — to the politically inflammatory — false reports that local farmers had been forced to throw away tonnes of produce left unsold because of slowing exports to China under a Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) administration.
The spread of disinformation has reached greater peaks with the advent of new technologies for information and communication (NTICs). But the practice of using lies and deceit to gain power is as old as politics itself, attendees at the first Taiwan International Journalism Conference organized by Reporters Without Borders (RSF) said last Friday.
Photo courtesy of Naomi Campbell
Themed “Disinformation: Time for Solutions,” the one-day conference attracted media professionals and concerned citizens alike. Skirting clear of an expose of the individuals and organizations mongering fake news in Taiwan, it instead focused on China’s strategic aims and discussed ideas to tackle this age-old problem, against the context of the country’s particular media and political environment.
Two years ago, Taiwan became home to the first Asia bureau of RSF, a Paris-based non-profit, non-government organization that advocates for freedom of information and freedom of the press. At the conference, it became clear that these democratic underpinnings contained the seeds of both resilience and susceptibility to disinformation.
Anyone currently in Taiwan has the privilege of being a first-hand witness to a “bloody war” of disinformation in the lead up to the presidential and legislative elections on Jan. 11, Executive Yuan spokesperson Kolas Yotaka told the audience last Friday.
While China has learned from disinformation tactics used by Russia (and before that, the Soviet Union), its ambitions to annex Taiwan, shared language and cultural features and ability to dangle economic incentives have contributed to a “more refined” strategy that uses a “vast array of vectors,” said J. Michael Cole, a policy analyst, journalist and former deputy news editor at the Taipei Times.
Chinese disinformation in Taiwan has come a long way since the radio propaganda of Voice of the Strait, originally launched by the People’s Liberation Army in 1958. Today, leveraging state mouthpieces but also social media, cyber armies, content farms and artificial intelligence, China’s tactics have grown in sophistication.
Stephane Corcuff, associate professor of politics at Sciences Po Lyon, identified disinformation as a foundational element of China’s “sharp power.” Distinct from hard power and soft power, this described “an approach to international affairs that typically involves efforts at censorship and the use of manipulation to degrade the integrity of independent institutions” and “has the effect of limiting free expression and distorting the political environment,” according to the Washington-based National Endowment for Democracy, which coined the term.
Disinformation served to “Balkanize” or divide the country, Cole said, by exploiting existing polarizations and co-opting stakeholders more amenable to China’s positions. Hence, it worked most effectively when used not to brainwash the public, but to entrench existing views and sow confusion.
‘OUR SOIL IS SPOILT’
“To me, the most serious problem is that our soil,” or media environment, “is spoilt,” said Lee Chih-te (李志德), executive committee member of the Association of Taiwan Journalists (台灣新聞記者協會).
For many media practitioners present, a key question was how far the country’s media environment was conducive to legitimate journalism. Speakers made reference to the damning conditions in many local media outlets: poor fact-checking, overworked and under-trained reporters and pressures from management that went against journalism ethics.
An immediate solution is improved fact-checking by media outlets, which is now often performed by vigilante grassroot groups.
Chen Shun-hsiao (陳順孝), associate professor of journalism and communication studies at Fu Jen Catholic University, highlighted Watchout (沃草), a civil society group that performs real-time fact-checks of claims made by presidential candidates in their debates.
However, fake news continues to disseminate even after being debunked. And while media literacy is an essential response to the proliferation of fake news, it can take years, even generations, to effect change, while the threat of disinformation is immediate.
In search of more innovative and effective solutions, RSF hopes to give media consumers additional guidance through media certification, as part of its experimental Journalism Trust Initiative (JTI) developed in partnership with media organizations, Google and Facebook.
Consisting of 18 standards ranging from ownership and sources of revenue to the editorial process, the JTI is a form of industry self-regulation to help readers identify media outlets that have sound journalism practices.
Alviani added that media outlets that received the certification could receive a boost in the algorithms of social media platforms and search engines, elevating their visibility above sources of fake news.
One of the more positive developments in Taiwan has been the blooming of a multitude of independent, home-grown media outlets without the party baggage of mainstream and traditional media. However, as news consumption (and advertising dollars) moves online and onto social media, the sheer financial viability of legitimate journalism has also been cast into doubt.
Taiwan has partially succeeded in creating a sustainable business environment for journalism through subscription models — like that introduced by Apple Daily (蘋果日報) earlier this year — and independent models that relied on crowdfunding and donations — like The Reporter (報導者) — said Eve Chiu (邱家宜), chief executive of the Foundation for Excellent Journalism Award (卓越新聞獎基金會).
At the same time, media outlets cannot afford to price good-quality journalism out of reach of their readers. Speakers correspondingly called for public media institutions to play a greater role in nurturing legitimate journalism, such as by incubating and collaborating with independent media outlets that show signs of promise.
Asked whether the government’s recently proposed anti-infiltration law to combat Chinese interference in Taiwan was a form of coercion and suppression of freedom of information and the press, speakers sounded a note of confidence in the government’s response.
“From the global point of view, Taiwan is really one of the [countries most] menaced” by disinformation warfare, Corcruff said, “if not the most... so it is normal that the state is called to make a proper, immediate and very strong response.”
Looking to the continuing popular protest movement in Hong Kong, Lee said that the roots of suppression did not lie in a single piece of legislation, but in a system of political, economic and social conditions that did not meet the needs of the people.
Taiwan will have to adapt to meet new challenges such as more advanced artificial intelligence technology and the possibility of China allowing tech giants within its “Great Firewall.” Just as important for Taiwan’s response will be having a people and a government sensitive to Chinese disinformation.
“The vagaries of Taiwan’s politics always creates a possibility that parties and officials will be elected who do not regard the threat of Chinese disinformation... as a major threat to Taiwan’s democracy,” Cole said.
With listicles of local attractions including Costco and numerous children’s playgrounds, I was not expecting much. Opened on Jan. 31, the Taipei MRT’s Circular Line, or Yellow Line, made life in the nation’s capital even more convenient. But judging from Internet search results, it hasn’t opened up many new tourism opportunities, unsurprising as the route mostly crosses densely populated areas and industrial parks. Places like a sports stadium with rainbow colored bleachers perfect for Instagram selfies wouldn’t do it for me either, and it’s pointless to list attractions at the connecting stops that have existed for years. As a history nerd, there
June 1 to June 7 In February 1988, Robert Wu (吳清友) set aside NT$17.5 million to purchase two Henry Moore sculptures from London’s Marlborough Gallery. He never bought the pieces. Feeling slighted that the gallery manager initially looked down on him as a Taiwanese, he decided that night to use the money to open his own art space back home. “Without selling any art, that money could support the gallery for four years. If I feature one artist per month, that provides a stage for at least 100 artists,” Wu said in the book Eslite Time (誠品時光) by Lin Ching-yi (林靜宜).
Captain Wynn Gale — a fifth-generation Georgia shrimper — is on the side of the road on an April morning, selling shrimp at the same street corner where his dad sold shrimp. “How’s the pandemic treating you?” I ask. “Sales have dropped off by about two-thirds. No out-of-towners coming through on the I-95. No local traffic.” He sighs. “I’m going to tough it out. I can survive with what I’m selling. But that’s all I’m doing. Most shrimpers don’t have 401k retirement plans, you know?” Gale would rather be out on his boat, a 1953 trawler he had for nine years but recently
The Lunar New Year vacation had just ended when Alice Wu began to worry about COVID-19. Not long after, on Feb. 10, Wu — who didn’t give her Chinese name to speak freely for this story — received the first of several coronavirus-related sales messages through her smartphone. The pitch came from an acquaintance who represents Amway, an American multi-level marketing (MLM) company that’s been active in Taiwan since 1982. “I’ve only met her once, and I’ve never bought from her. If her sister wasn’t one of my daughter’s teachers, I’d probably block her,” says Wu, who lives in Taichung. MLM, sometimes