Tue, Jun 24, 2014 - Page 12 News List

When 15 is too old

Brazil’s youth ‘factories’ belie a romantic image

By Toby Davis  /  Reuters, Brazil

Neco, coach and the coordinator of Brazil’s Sport Club Do Recife youth system, speaks to Reuters in Recife on June 18. Young players are the financial lifeblood of Brazilian clubs. The production line that grooms them into saleable assets starts at a tender age.

Photo: Reuters

Brazil is deadly serious about developing young soccer players in a factory-like environment, shattering the romantic image of bare-footed youngsters honing their skills on ramshackle streets and sandy beaches.

Young players are the financial lifeblood of Brazilian clubs and the production line that grooms them into saleable assets starts at a tender age.

“It is designed to be a factory. At the big clubs in the south, the kids are professionals at 13,” Henrique Schlithler, CEO of Brazil’s Sport Club Do Recife, told Reuters.

Schlithler was describing the new training facilities he hopes will produce a stream of talented players to be nurtured and then sold off to fund their continued growth.

Standing in the club’s storied trophy room, where each piece of silverware seems to have its own intriguing tale, Schlithler paints a picture of the hard economics that underpin youth development in the country of the World Cup hosts.

It is incongruous with the mythical image of children knocking about on the streets, freely learning skills that will one day wow the world.

“They are paid 2,000 euros a month, their fathers are given jobs and their families apartments. You hear stories of people listing their profession as ‘athlete’s father’,” Schlithler said.

“At this club we only give scholarships and selling the really young players is not part of our culture.”

But last season’s promotion back to Brazil’s top flight means the club is changing, he says, before describing the “factory” he hopes will bankroll a new chapter in their history.

“If someone comes with a couple of million euros for a player, we’ll sell,” he said.

The competition for the best youngsters is cutthroat, with talents changing hands swiftly and the beady eyes of scouts always on the lookout for those who are likely to attract the most interest.


As Schlithler explains, Brazil’s biggest clubs are not among the 20 richest in the world, where the financial might of the European behemoths ensures some players leave the country without kicking a ball in their own league.

“When these diamonds appear, there are too many people around,” he said. “If we have a top player it is maybe two weeks [before the bigger clubs snatch them].

“For us, we see Brazilian players who have never played in Brazil and we are like, ‘who is that guy?’”

In the 2012-13 season, there were 138 Brazilian players in the top five European leagues, more than any other country, according to the CIES Football Observatory Group. Some estimates pitch the number playing professionally around the world at 10,000.

Last year the players’ union, FIFPro, published concerns on the exploitation of minors in South American football, following reports of children being bought by agents and transferred to Europe.

Although Schlithler said his club had no interest in selling players at such a young age, he is aware of the need to bring them into the professional environment as early as possible.

“Even 13 is sometimes too old,” he said. “In the south they will start them at seven … If someone comes to me and says ‘I know a great player, he is 15’. I say ‘forget it. He is too old’.”


In the shadow of the club’s hulking concrete stadium, daubed in their red and black colors, a group of youngsters kick and head the ball over a volleyball net with deft touches and neat flicks.

This story has been viewed 2236 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top