Miral, Julian Schnabel’s fourth feature film, based on an autobiographical novel by Rula Jebreal (who wrote the screenplay), recounts the linked and partial life stories of four Palestinian women, beginning in the last days of the British mandate and ending in the 1990s, when it looked as if peace between Israelis and Palestinians might finally be on the horizon. That the film, an international co-production involving France, India, Israel and Italy, has been greeted with a flurry of controversy may show just how far that horizon has receded.
Accusations of a pro-Palestinian or anti-Israeli bias on Schnabel’s part are further evidence that the discussion of Middle East politics may be more polarized and poisonous than ever. To the extent that Miral espouses an ideology, it is the tolerant, somewhat wistful humanism that is the default setting of Western liberalism. The film concludes on a note of cautious optimism, with the signing of the Oslo Accords, and while embracing that agreement may be naive or nostalgic, it hardly seems offensive or even especially provocative.
But to say that Schnabel’s film is innocuous is not to say that it’s any good. Like so many other well-intentioned movies about politically contentious issues, it is hobbled by its own sincerity and undone by a confused aesthetic agenda. A grand, complex human drama is reduced to platitudes and pretty pictures, as some fine actors become ciphers of suffering and resilience in a strained and superficial pageant.
Photo courtesy of CatchPlay
This is especially disappointing given that Schnabel’s great gift as a filmmaker has always been his ability to infuse real-life narratives with color, surprise and vivid emotion. All of his movies have been based on the lives of real people, but none of the films have succumbed to the wooden literalism of the conventional Hollywood biopic. Basquiat, about the reckless and brilliant young painter who had been a friend of Schnabel’s, was at once a pop parable and a knowing, mischievous art-world satire. Before Night Falls, with Javier Bardem as the Cuban writer Reinaldo Arenas, turned a grim story of oppression into a sexy, lyrical fable. And in The Diving Bell and the Butterfly Schnabel took the memoir of Jean-Dominique Bauby, a French magazine editor paralyzed by a stroke, and transformed it into an ecstatic exploration of sensory liberation.
The common thread running through these stories, and Miral as well, is the conflict between confining circumstances and the innate human desire for freedom. Miral (Freida Pinto), a young Arab woman growing up in Jerusalem during the first intifada of the 1980s, is embroiled in this struggle on a number of fronts. Her protective father (Alexander Siddig) wants her to stay away from political activism, as does Hind Husseini (Hiam Abbass), director of the orphanage and girls’ school where Miral has spent much of her childhood. Her defiance of them is normal adolescent rebellion played out against a backdrop of turmoil.
Miral’s story is the last and longest of four chapters that make up the film, each one bearing the name of a woman. Nadia (Yasmine Al Massri) is Miral’s mother, who flees an abusive home only to wind up in an Israeli prison, where she meets Fatima (Ruba Blal), serving several life sentences for an abortive act of terrorism. Encompassing all of them is the story of Hind, a remarkable real-life figure in Palestinian history, here unfortunately reduced to stiff, self-effacing saintliness.
Photo courtesy of CatchPlay
Some of the fault lies with Jebreal’s script, which consists almost entirely of rousing thematic statements: “You are my hope,” “We must continue the struggle,” “This is a difficult period of transition,” and so on. The awkwardness of the dialogue reaches an apex of absurdity when Miral and her boyfriend, a militant named Hani (Omar Metwally), debate the relative merits of a two-state solution between passionate kisses. The problem is not that love and politics don’t mix — of course they do! — but rather that people don’t generally sound as if they were quoting from the letters section of Foreign Affairs while they’re making out.
What is worse is that the historical particulars of the story are sacrificed to Schnabel’s restless, preening stylishness. His camera movements are gorgeous, and the colors and textures produced by the cinematographer, Eric Gautier, are rarely less than ravishing. But the compulsive pursuit of beauty — and of beauties — makes Miral feel like an epic perfume commercial.
There are a few moments that catch the pulse of experience in ways that match the excitement of Schnabel’s earlier work, notably a series of encounters between Miral and a Jewish Israeli woman (played by Schnabel’s daughter Stella) who is dating one of Miral’s cousins. For the most part, though, the film combines flat-footed storytelling with florid and distracting technique, producing more bafflement than catharsis or illumination. (For a successful marriage of Palestinian history and cinematic ingenuity, see The Time That Remains, Elia Suleiman’s extraordinary family chronicle.)
In the final scenes, jarringly and inexplicably, images of a funeral are accompanied by Tom Waits singing All the World Is Green on the soundtrack. (Other music in the film, almost as distracting, is by Laurie Anderson, A. R. Rahman and Ennio Morricone.) It may be possible to imagine such a juxtaposition making sense, but like so much else in Miral, this musical choice seems hasty, half-baked and arbitrary. And the movie as a whole feels like a noble effort that falls short of figuring out just what it wants to do.
The year was 1991. A Toyota Land Cruiser set out on a 67km journey up the Junda Forest Road (郡大林道) toward an old loggers’ camp, at which point the hikers inside would get out and begin their ascent of Jade Mountain (玉山). Little did they know, they would be the last group of hikers to ever enjoy this shortcut into the mountains. An approaching typhoon soon wiped out the road behind them, trapping the vehicle on the mountain and forever changing the approach to Jade Mountain. THE CONTEMPORARY ROUTE Nowadays, the approach to Jade Mountain from the north side takes an
Last week Joseph Nye, the well-known China scholar, wrote on the Australian Strategic Policy Institute’s website about how war over Taiwan might be averted. He noted that years ago he was on a team that met with then-president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁), “whose previous ‘unofficial’ visit to the US had caused a crisis in which China fired missiles into the sea and the US deployed carriers off the coast of Taiwan.” Yes, that’s right, mighty Chen caused that crisis all by himself. Neither the US nor the People’s Republic of China (PRC) exercised any agency. Nye then nostalgically invoked the comical specter
Relations between Taiwan and the Czech Republic have flourished in recent years. However, not everyone is pleased about the growing friendship between the two countries. Last month, an incident involving a Chinese diplomat tailing the car of vice president-elect Hsiao Bi-khim (蕭美琴) in Prague, drew public attention to the People’s Republic of China’s (PRC) operations to undermine Taiwan overseas. The trip was not Hsiao’s first visit to the Central European country. It was meant to be low-key, a chance to meet with local academics and politicians, until her police escort noticed a car was tailing her through the Czech capital. The
April 15 to April 21 Yang Kui (楊逵) was horrified as he drove past trucks, oxcarts and trolleys loaded with coffins on his way to Tuntzechiao (屯子腳), which he heard had been completely destroyed. The friend he came to check on was safe, but most residents were suffering in the town hit the hardest by the 7.1-magnitude Hsinchu-Taichung Earthquake on April 21, 1935. It remains the deadliest in Taiwan’s recorded history, claiming around 3,300 lives and injuring nearly 12,000. The disaster completely flattened roughly 18,000 houses and damaged countless more. The social activist and