The publishers of this new book state in their accompanying promotional material "This is the first book to be published in English on the 2/28 Incident and White Terror." If true, it's an astonishing state of affairs. And Representing Atrocity in Taiwan itself isn't an account of those events either, but rather a consideration of how they were subsequently treated (when they were treated at all) by Taiwan's writers and filmmakers. This means the publishers are tacitly claiming there is still no English-language account at all of those terrible years.
Can this really be the case? There is George H. Kerr's Formosa Betrayed, though it's largely a personal memoir. And a look through Sylvia Li-chun Lin's bibliography here uncovers another title that appears to fit the bill: A Tragic Beginning: The Taiwan Uprising of February 28, 1947 by Tse-han Lai (賴澤涵), Raymond H. Meyers and Wei Wou (魏萼) (Stanford University Press, 1991). There's certainly some English material online, including Formosa Betrayed complete, even though the continuing unavailability of crucial documents is frequently lamented.
It's easy to understand why a full account of the years 1947 to 1987 is difficult. With any discussion of the 2/28 massacre forbidden, as it was prior to 1987, and any discussion of the disappearances and executions that followed it very dangerous, there must be a shortage of factual material. On the other hand Taiwan now enjoys what this author calls "unprecedented civil liberties that guarantee the freedoms of speech, press and congregation." And the world - which often in reality means the English-speaking world - surely needs as complete an account as possible of atrocities Lin compares in brutality to the Holocaust, the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the regime of Pol Pot.
Much of this book, though, is concerned with the contradictions that accompany the straightforward depiction of any historical event. Lin deals in depth with the widespread criticism of Hou Hsiao-hsien's (侯孝賢) film A City of Sadness (悲情城市) that erupted when it was released in 1989. This focused on the absence of any depiction of the central events of 2/28, as well as on the fact that the film showed local Taiwanese attacking Chinese of mainland extraction without any parallel portrayal of the much more serious assaults by the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) military on the local population that prompted such reactions.
Lin argues that individuals remember different things and have separate viewpoints, and so there is no one "true" picture. Artists, too, tend to avoid producing anything that might look like propaganda, as any work showing the evils of 2/28 and the White Terror directly might appear to be. But this hasn't prevented writers and directors elsewhere from creating far more explicit historical depictions than have apparently appeared to date in Taiwan.
Lin argues books and films touching on these years allowed their audiences "to confront the fact that no historical experience can ever be completely recaptured on screen (or in writing)." This seems a rather sophisticated point for people who lost family members through state brutality to take on board. What ordinary people consider as "the truth" is something more basic and simple than this.
It's widely felt, for example, that Solzhenitsyn depicted such simple truth in books like The First Circle and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, that Tolstoy unambiguously showed the callousness of the 19th-century Russians in Chechnya in Hadji Murad, and that Orwell's Animal Farm offered an appropriate fable for what happened in the former Soviet Union under communism. Films such as Eisenstein's Battleship Potemkin and October displayed the Russian Revolution with little regard for dissenting viewpoints, and The Killing Fields showed the agony of Cambodia in the 1970s very directly.
Despite Lin's sympathetic analyses of what Taiwan's artists have managed to come up with, it can still be argued that something far more hard-hitting, and of epic stature, in literature and film, is both possible and desirable.
Sylvia Lin also points to women as popular images of suffering, even though, as she says, most of Taiwan's political victims were men, and looks at the issue of ethnicity in representations of Taiwan's history. Lin is, incidentally, a Taiwanese translator and scholar working in the US at the University of Notre Dame, Illinois, and is married to perhaps the most illustrious translator from Chinese into English that we have, Howard Goldblatt.
So - still no full account in English of Taiwan's years of state terror, and still no Taiwanese novels or films that depict the period's horrors head-on? This would appear to be the fundamental situation, only partially revealed by this nonetheless scrupulous and carefully argued book.
Possibly the reality is that modern Taiwan is simply too proud of its recent achievements to want to look back. The one-party state wasn't without its supporters, after all. "Most Taiwanese citizens," Lin writes of that earlier period, "accepted the government's position that these dissidents were in fact threatening national security and should be severely punished. The democratic ideal that a nation's citizens should be free to voice dissenting views without fear of persecution was completely alien to the majority of the Taiwanese, who deemed the fight for such rights as being seditious."
Despite such fighting talk, Representing Atrocity in Taiwan isn't the rallying cry this state of affairs ideally calls for. Instead, it looks scrupulously and honestly at the artistic results of the situation. So what is still needed is some young Taiwanese writer, some modern Emile Zola untouched by the academic proprieties, to bewail from the rooftops the continuing lack of a full account of such a hideously cruel, and indeed horrific, past, pointing the finger of accusation where he or she will.
A few weeks ago I found myself at a Family Mart talking with the morning shift worker there, who has become my coffee guy. Both of us were in a funk over the “unseasonable” warm weather, a state of mind known as “solastalgia” — distress produced by environmental change. In fact, the weather was not that out of the ordinary in boiling Central Taiwan, and likely cooler than the temperatures we will experience in the near-future. According to the Taiwan Adaptation Platform, between 1957 and 2006, summer lengthened by 27.8 days, while winter shrunk by 29.7 days. Winter is not
A sultry sea mist blankets New Taipei City as I pedal from Tamsui District (淡水) up the coast. This might not be ideal beach weather but it’s fine weather for riding –– the cloud cover sheltering arms and legs from the scourge of the subtropical sun. The dedicated bikeway that connects downtown Taipei with the west coast of New Taipei City ends just past Fisherman’s Wharf (漁人碼頭) so I’m not the only cyclist jostling for space among the SUVs and scooters on National Highway No. 2. Many Lycra-clad enthusiasts are racing north on stealthy Giants and Meridas, rounding “the crown coast”
March 25 to March 31 A 56-year-old Wu Li Yu-ke (吳李玉哥) was straightening out her artist son’s piles of drawings when she inadvertently flipped one over, revealing the blank backside of the paper. Absent-mindedly, she picked up a pencil and recalled how she used to sketch embroidery designs for her clothing business. Without clients and budget or labor constraints to worry about, Wu Li drew freely whatever image came to her mind. With much more free time now that her son had found a job, she found herself missing her home village in China, where she
In recent years, Slovakia has been seen as a highly democratic and Western-oriented Central European country. This image was reinforced by the election of the country’s first female president in 2019, efforts to provide extensive assistance to Ukraine and the strengthening of relations with Taiwan, all of which strengthened Slovakia’s position within the European Union. However, the latest developments in the country suggest that the situation is changing rapidly. As such, the presidential elections to be held on March 23 will be an indicator of whether Slovakia remains in the Western sphere of influence or moves eastward, notably towards Russia and