Karen Abbott's Sin in the Second City reports on an early-20th-century phenomenon: the Everleigh Club, which opened in Chicago in 1900 and lasted 11 years as the self-proclaimed grandest whorehouse in America. In a book rife with quaint period details, Abbott presents photographs of the club's gaudy extravagance, drawings that alert innocent young women to the perils of white slavery, and memorable johns like the Everleigh customer calling himself Uncle Ned. At Christmas, Uncle Ned would plant his feet in buckets of ice, drink sarsaparilla and order the house's "butterflies" to circle him while they sang Jingle Bells.
Why, then, is this book so current? Because everything and nothing has changed. The book describes a popular culture awash in wild tales of sexual abuse (described by an ex-mayor of Toledo as "a sort of pornography to satisfy the American sense of news"), crusading reformers claiming God on their side, and deep suspicion of the threat posed by "foreigners" to the nation's Christian values.
There is even the McMansion-minded excess of one Chicago madam who, upon seeing her rivals, Ada and Minna Everleigh, in a carriage pulled by four tassel-wearing horses, insisted that her own carriage have six. And there is a touch of today's news in the way a madam with politicians for clients can wreak havoc because she can name names.
Famous as they once were, the Everleigh sisters have been sufficiently forgotten to fill Sin in the Second City with outlandish surprises. These sisters claimed to be "the only madams in history who had started out as debutantes instead of whores." Whatever their pedigree, they stopped at nothing to attract attention. They created a big-ticket Chicago institution that boasted a gold piano, designer spittoons, perfume fountains, a lavish menu, a replica of Bernini's Apollo and Daphne sculpture, mirrored ceilings and as many froufrou trappings as the place could hold. "A man who came to their house would see everything he wanted to and nothing he didn't," Abbott writes, "and he would never feel rushed or cheated, disillusioned or alone."
But he might have felt jittery about the mounting reform movement that surrounded the Everleighs' operation. Even as business boomed and the Everleighs cosseted their clients, the place was less sturdy than it looked. The excesses of the Everleigh Club, along with those at its much coarser neighboring brothels in the Levee district of Chicago, would help prompt the Mann Act, meant to prevent "white slave traffic." Such antics also spurred the creation of a branch of the US Justice Department, a Bureau of Investigation that would evolve into the FBI.
The sisters' defiance and sharp business acumen kept them on such a friendly footing with Chicago gangsters, saloon keepers and politicians that it also kept them out of jail. Any tale of their accomplishments involves their great skill at co-opting opposition. (State legislators were always entertained free.) They also successfully fended off anti-sin crusaders of many stripes, and did so without apology. Years later, when they changed their names and moved to Manhattan, their nude paintings and other erotica would be explained as relics handed down by dear old granddad.
So Abbott has a mother lode of material to work with. Even this book's minutiae, like the way the phrase "getting Everleighed" was abbreviated into "one of America's bawdiest idioms," makes for good storytelling. She provides a clear historical context for the Levee district's wild abandon as she chronicles rising demands toward reform. And she writes with frankness about the particulars of prostitution, although a misguided sense of decorum prompts her to use the word harlot incessantly. Surely there are synonyms for everything when the cast of characters includes Merry Widdo Kiddo, Michael "Hinky Dink" Kenna and Suzy Poon Tang.