Shimon Peres, now 83, finds himself, yet again, facing an election. Once more he is in the humiliating position of wanting to be president of Israel and unsure whether those in the Knesset who say they support him will then vote against him in secret.
It happened last in July 2000, when Moshe Katsav, a relatively unknown Likud machine politician, shocked everyone by beating Peres for the presidency. Katsav, now charged with rape and sexual misconduct, is expected to resign soon, and Peres has made it clear that he wants the job.
Peres is one of the defining figures of the still-young Israeli state, often abroad speaking on its behalf. His contradictions are encapsulated in his two largest accomplishments: he was crucially responsible both for the Israeli nuclear weapons program and for the 1993 Oslo accords, for which he shared a Nobel Peace Prize with Yitzhak Rabin and Yasser Arafat.
But Peres is also one of Israel's most mocked figures, considered an eternal loser and dreamer who has harmed his career and reputation through selfishness, timidity, vanity and political deafness.
Israelis will gleefully volunteer that Peres, who was elected to head a Socialist youth group in 1945, has never won another election in his own right, though he has been prime minister twice.
Michael Bar-Zohar's Shimon Peres: The Biography is an effort by a friend and former assistant to give a more balanced and judicious picture of this complicated politician, who has spent most of his life working for Israel's defense and is best known for failed efforts to reach peace. Peres cooperated fully with Bar-Zohar, providing diary material and long interview sessions.
But Peres deserves better, and so do we.
Bar-Zohar, a noted biographer of David Ben-Gurion, first wrote this book in Hebrew with the title Like the Phoenix, and it was published in Israel in December 2005. He has apparently translated it himself and tried to adjust it for a non-Israeli audience.
In English the the book is indifferently written and oddly unbalanced. It spends too much time on Peres' youth in prewar Poland and his fumbling efforts to fit into kibbutz life (including changing his name from Persky to Peres, meaning a kind of bearded vulture).
Bar-Zohar diligently details Peres' various jobs as a young man — most interestingly, working for Ben-Gurion and buying arms overseas — and his decision not to volunteer to fight, as even his wife did, in the war of independence, the war that created Israel and, even more important, created "Israelis." Peres felt he was serving the nation in a more important way; to his credit, Bar-Zohar calls this "one of the worst mistakes in his life."
Peres had a large role in securing vital military equipment from France and in building Israel's defense and aerospace industry, as well as its nuclear capability, by doing deals with right-wing governments in France and apartheid South Africa. Bar-Zohar both overestimates Peres' importance to the state and rarely steps back to assess his performance.
Oddly, the book essentially concludes in 1996, after the extraordinary triumph of the Oslo accords and the Nobel Peace Prize ended so abruptly with the assassination of Rabin and Peres' failure, once again, to win the prime ministership in his own right.
A four-page chapter — really a postscript in a book of around 500 pages — tries to cover the next decade, when Peres lost the presidency to Katsav, lost the Labor Party leadership to Amir Peretz in another shocking result, became a crucial ally to his old friend Ariel Sharon in the pullout from Gaza and then left the Labor Party altogether to join the new Kadima.
RSS