I didn't expect to enjoy this book about Douglas MacArthur (discussed in parallel with Japan's Emperor Hirohito). He was, after all, a die-hard right-winger in politics, a gutsy military commander given to wading ashore under enemy fire wherever he had the opportunity, and giving rise to endless variations on his "Old soldiers never die" aphorism.
But this new general survey, written without footnotes and aiming for a popular readership, turns out to be a remarkably compulsive read. This is partly because it proves the truth of something I've always believed — that there are no black and whites in human nature, only endless shades of gray, plus a huge range of idiosyncracies.
But why a new book on MacArthur now? No new information appears to have emerged, and the answer instead probably lies in the author's relentless energy. He's already written books about the rise and fall of communism, a perceived drift to global disorder, the US War of Independence, Latin America's struggles for independence, Greater Japan's rise and fall, the life and death of Clive of India, and much else — 11 substantial books in all. Clearly life for Robert Harvey is a nightmare when he's not poring over stacks of historical volumes and then tapping away into the night on his computer.
MacArthur was both adored and loathed. He seemed bigger than presidents, and was notorious for ignoring their orders. He was already US chief of staff in the 1930s, left to take up a comic-opera position in the Philippines under Manuel Quezon, then was recalled by Washington to mastermind the entire US war in the Pacific. From there he became, in 1945, effective leader of an occupied Japan, and the only American ever to have ruled, as a species of proconsul, a temporarily subject people.
Nor was this the end. In 1950 he again led US forces, nominally under UN control, in the resistance to North Korea's invasion of the south, carrying out an amphibious landing behind enemy lines at Inchon, considered one of the most audacious actions in all military history. It was equaled, experts believe, only by his masterly retreat onto the Bataan Peninsula following the Japanese invasion of the Philippines. (His famous promise "I will return" came after he was ordered to leave for Australia while his men were marched away to prison camps).
In some ways MacArthur lurched from one extreme to another. In 1932 he confronted WWI veterans who'd encamped in Washington DC to claim early payment of a promised bonus (known as the Bonus Marchers). It was the time of the Great Depression, but MacArthur's high-handed approach (against former servicemen, no less) almost led to killings by the military of US citizens on US soil. On the other hand, he was alone in the US high command to oppose the dropping of atom bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He'd been against a land invasion too, believing that a naval blockade would quickly and bloodlessly bring an exhausted and dispirited Japan to its knees.
Again, in the Korean War he called for a policy of hot-pursuit of Chinese Communist forces across the Yalu River into China, and even proposed the laying of nuclear waste to seal off the Korean peninsula. But on the other hand, as military ruler of Japan after 1945 — and the "shogun" of the book's title — he astonished the Japanese by his conciliatory policies (in fact dictated by the Truman administration in Washington). Far from punishing a nation that had caused untold US deaths in four years of terrible warfare, he promoted democracy, women's rights, the marginalization of the military, and the eventual emergence of the world's second largest economy. "At least 200,000 Japanese came to see MacArthur depart," writes Harvey, "many of them openly crying."
RSS