With classical audiences dwindling, it's not surprising the major recording companies are pulling out all the stops to attract the young. The strategy goes back 50 years, but with their ever-increasing back-catalogues of performances already in their copyright, they have ever more to gain from preventing them slipping into oblivion. Sony BMG, for this reason presumably as well as more altruistic ones, is this month promoting the debut CD album The 5 Browns, a major bid to attract American and other teenagers to music in the classical idiom.
Desirae, Deondra, Gregory, Melody and Ryan Brown are a set of siblings in their 20s. They all learnt piano from the age of three and, far more surprisingly, all won scholarships to New York's prestigious Juilliard School of Music. This feat won them TV slots in the US on 60 Minutes and Oprah, and now sees them launched with a CD, plus a bonus 12-minute DVD.
On the DVD they play two five-pianos-at-a-time numbers and give a chatty interview with plentiful mention of how scary they found recording and how much they also enjoy hip-hop, jazz etc. The aim is clear -- to do everything possible to attract, and not to alienate, the ultra-cool younger generation.
The CD, fortunately, doesn't indulge in any significant dumbing-down. They play items from Rachmaninoff, Ravel, Debussy and Prokofiev, either all five of them together or else singly (once as a pair). The standard is high. But what matters is their youth, and to understand this you have to see them playing and talking on the all-too-brief DVD.
Utterly different is the somber new DVD of Stephen Kovacevich playing Beethoven's two last piano sonatas, together with some short encore pieces by Beethoven and Schubert. You only have to consider the music to know pretty much what to expect. Beethoven's last five piano sonatas are generally considered some of the most profound piano music ever written -- intellectual, ethereal, highly-wrought, both plumbing the depths and scaling the heights. The "Arietta" of Opus 111, for example, has been described as occupying "remote spiritual regions," after which "celestial utterances" nothing more could possibly be said. (The sonata does indeed stop here, without the conventional scherzo or finale).
Thus it is that, in a recital recorded last summer before a small audience in France, Kovacevich can be seen concentrating all his efforts, sweating profusely (or is he crying?), but finally triumphant. It's the kind of music that demands nothing less. It's hard on the listener too, so much so that you wonder for once quite what the sight of the soloist on DVD adds to the experience. Does it distract from your intellectual concentration? Possibly. Anyway, this, like the summit of Everest, is for dedicated devotees only, in this case devotees of Beethoven and the extremes of Romantic piano music in general.
Wagner believed he was Beethoven's successor. Purists have sometimes scoffed at this claim, but the most significant difference is that Wagner was a man of the theatre and Beethoven's genius, despite Fidelio, was decidedly non-theatrical. Few can imagine the reclusive voyager leaping on stage and fervently acting everyone's parts as Wagner did.
Sony Classical now offers mezzo-soprano Lioba Braun in some of Wagner's greater operatic moments, plus his cycle of art-songs, the Wesendonck-Leider. These leider are forerunners of Richard Strauss' Four Last Songs -- possibly the only occasion when this late-comer actually outdid his illustrious master. Originally set to piano accompaniment, only one of them was orchestrated by the composer. Here are all five with orchestra, the other four in the usual versions of Felix Mottl.
RSS