Wed, Nov 09, 2005 - Page 13 News List

Critics of flying prefer riding donkeys


Frequent fliers' reviews of air travel for this year are in. They are not good.

"Would rather take a donkey," one says.

"`Good service' translates to, `We won't bother you if you don't bother us,"' says another.

"Need air marshals to protect passengers from crew," says another.

These are among the comments in a new assessment of airline travel by Zagat Survey, the company best known for consumer reviews of restaurants and hotels.

Every business traveler knows that air service has deteriorated as major airlines have struggled for survival against low-cost competition and, in the last year, the soaring price of fuel. But even the experts say they're surprised at the virulence of dissatisfaction this year.

"I had expected it would be bad, but not this bad," Tim Zagat, the co-founder and chief executive of Zagat Survey, said Monday. "Consumers are really fed up by the way they're being treated, particularly by the major airlines." He added. "One of the reasons JetBlue does so well is that they seem to be reasonably customer-friendly."

The survey -- the first air-travel review by Zagat since 2001 -- is based on responses from more than 5,000 frequent fliers and travel-industry professionals assessing service on 22 domestic and 55 international airlines.

You can read the full survey at

Basically, it says that passengers think the major domestic airlines are "a mess," as a Zagat summary puts it. The big complaints are delays and cancellations, cramped seating, and overall poor in-flight service.

Only 2 percent of passengers complained about airline food, but that's probably because in-flight meals in coach class have pretty much gone the way of stewardesses in white gloves. "Airline food is an oxymoron," as one respondent put it.

The only major airline among the 10 carriers with the best ratings was Continental Airlines, which came in ninth and which, incidentally, is the only airline still serving traditional in-flight meals in coach. Across the board, foreign carriers were rated far more favorably than domestic ones, especially for business-class and first-class service.

I've recently been focusing on transcontinental premium service. But the stinging comments in the Zagat Survey are a reminder that most business travelers fly domestic coach, and for many of these frequent fliers, this year has been a true annus horribilus.

Take William Allen III, 57, a management consultant who is typically on the road five days a week. This year has been by far the most arduous in his 27 consecutive years of steady business travel, he said in a phone interview.

"I can't get off the road. I'm stuck. I love my work, but it's become a war zone out here, and it's got markedly worse in the last year," he said, singling out airlines -- not hotels -- as the problem.

The biggest issues he sees: Delays and route cutbacks, closely followed by unfriendly and sometimes surly service.

This story has been viewed 2765 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top