Print

Mail

wiki links

It's the story, stupid

By Glenn Whipp
NY TIMES NEWS SERVICE, LOS ANGELES
Friday, Nov 04, 2005, Page 16

Chicken Little, left, finds closure with the help of his friends. PHOTO: REUTERS

Following the commercial and critical disappointments of

Treasure Planet, Brother Bear and Home on the Range, Disney

Animation announced that it would no longer make movies in the traditional, hand-drawn way. The way of the future was

computer-generated animation.

But with its first film in the new format, the shockingly mediocre Chicken Little, Disney has just again proved what animators have been saying all along -- it's not the format, it's the story, stupid.

Given the importance Disney was placing on this film,

particularly in light of its on-again, off-again negotiations with Pixar Animation, it is remarkable that the studio has delivered a movie so plainly derivative and uninspired as this one.

The movie begins promisingly enough, outlining the day when Chicken Little (nicely voiced by Zach Braff) became a

laughingstock by telling the

denizens of his Main Street US town that the sky was falling. There's a good comic bit that manages to squeeze a little more life out of that rolling

Chicken Little Directed by: Mark Dindal Starring: Zach Braff (Chicken Little), Garry Marshall (Buck Cluck), Don Knotts (Mayor Turkey Lurkey), Patrick Stewart (Mr. Woolensworth) Running time: 77 minutes Taiwan Release: Today

boulder from Raiders of the Lost Ark and an opening-credits

sequence that nicely establishes Chicken Little's ingenuity in the face of a series of misfortunes. The kid can make lemonade out of lemons.

But he can't get past that one mistake. Chicken Little's dad (voiced by Garry Marshall) tells him it would be best for him to "disappear," prompting a lot of psychobabble about "closure" and a montage set to Jimmy Webb's

sorrowful anthem All I Know, which tries to jerk tears at a point when the characters have barely been established. Chicken Little's best friend, the ugly duckling Abby Mallard (Joan Cusack, fine as

always), tells her feathered friend that he'll never find redemption until he resolves his father issues.

What follows is an odd pastiche of Bad News Bears, ET and War of the Worlds. The sky does, indeed, fall. Chicken Little gets his closure -- and a movie deal. The film's final sequence shows how Hollywood glamorized the truth of Chicken Little's big adventure, delivering a slick "movie-by-committee." It isn't clear whether the filmmakers were aware that they were parodying their own formulaic creation. One thing is certain: Pixar's bargaining power just got stronger.
This story has been viewed 4836 times.