The images could have come from one of Hieronymus Bosch's nightmarish paintings of hell: dusty roads filled with frightened refugees, many of them already ill, covered in boils and coughing up blood; dogs and rats running wild on deserted streets; fields littered with the bodies of cows and sheep; plague pits filled with the corpses of men, women and children; survivors pointing accusatory fingers at Jews and Muslims and outsiders; others flagellating themselves in an effort to appease the heavens.
This was Europe in the 1340s, the decade of the advent of the Black Death, and in his harrowing new book, The Great Mortality, John Kelly gives the reader a ferocious, pictorial account of the horrific ravages of that plague.
He notes that on the Foster scale, a kind of Richter scale of human disaster, "the medieval plague is the second-greatest catastrophe in the human record," with only World War II producing "more death, physical destruction and emotional suffering."
He also points out that a Cold War-era study by the US Atomic Energy Commission found that the Black Death comes closest to achieving the cataclysmic results of all-out nuclear war "in its geographical extent, abruptness of onset and scale of casualties."
The author of several earlier books on science and medicine, Kelly was led to tackle the subject of the Black Death by the current AIDS epidemic and by the specter of newly emerging diseases like Ebola fever, Marburg, SARS and avian flu.
His book is heavily indebted to the work of earlier scholars, including such classic works as Johan Huizinga's Waning of the Middle Ages (first English translation, 1924) and more recent books like Norman F. Cantor's In the Wake of the Plague (2001) and David Herlihy's Black Death and the Transformation of the West (1997).
As a result, this volume's chief interest lies in its overview and synthesis of more academic studies and Kelly's ability to turn his research into an emotionally accessible narrative, animated by wrenchingly vivid tableaus and alarming firsthand witness accounts -- accounts that give the reader an intimate sense of day-to-day life in medieval Europe and the terrible ways in which the Black Death disrupted it.
Kelly recounts stories of individual heroism -- people risking their own lives to minister to the ill or ensure a dignified burial -- but his book is filled with far more incidents of cowardice, infamy and inhumanity: pogroms instituted against the Jews, who were scapegoated for spreading the plague; the abdication of responsibility on the part of many officials and community leaders; and the exploitation of the needy and grief-stricken by con men and opportunists.
When it comes to analyzing reactions to the Black Death, Kelly tends to come up with conclusions that are predictable, reductive or obvious -- or all three.
For instance, he argues that different countries reacted differently to the plague: that civic order tended to prevail in England, while "the Black Death seems to have stirred some netherworld deep within the turbulent Teutonic soul," giving birth to pogroms in Central Europe and the bizarre phenomenon of the Flagellants in Germany.
He also makes the sweeping and largely unsubstantiated claim that "London's moral state" fell precipitously in the wake of the plague, and that "a similar moral decline was evident elsewhere in post-plague Europe and the Middle East."
RSS