Chinese fishmeal plants leave Gambian fishers all at sea

Scientists and campaigners warn that factories in coastal villages are wreaking environmental and economic havoc

By Hannah Summers  /  The Guardian

Sun, Mar 24, 2019 - Page 7

Before the arrival of fishmeal factories in the Gambia, Musa Duboe would catch red snapper and barracuda to be sold at the local market. However, his income had begun to dwindle due to depleted stocks.

Then in 2016, the Chinese-owned Golden Lead fishmeal plant began operating out of the coastal town of Gunjur, increasing demand for fish to export for overseas aquaculture.

“Now work is booming again, as we can sell our catches to both the factory and locals,” said Duboe, 33, who was taking advantage of a rare patch of shade among the brightly hand-painted canoes used by the artisanal fishers.

“Our net catches all kinds of fish. Sometimes, we meet demand with just one catch — other times we need five catches, with a catch being as big as up to 400 bowls of fish. My work is a lot more profitable and I can fully provide for my family, thanks to the factory buying more fish than I could previously sell on the local market,” he said.

While Duboe and other fishers who predominantly supply the fishmeal plants might be enjoying short-term gains, the forecast for the Gambia’s fishing industry and the community that it serves is less rosy.

Overseas business interests and attractive global prices for fishmeal are driving demand for species such as sardinella, and, as a result, are taking a crucial source of protein from the plates of the poorest Gambians, while leaving large swaths of the community out of work.

The fishmeal business is wreaking havoc on the environment, local employment, food security and the tourism economy, scientists, Gambian activists and locals have said.

On the frontline of those losses are local female fish processors who buy from the artisanal fishers and smoke the fish, or sell it fresh at the local market. They also supply to a network of third parties who take the fish from the coast to inland markets, or for export to countries such as Mali or Ivory Coast.

However, with the factories taking the lion’s share of the catches, trade has plummeted for these women and others working in the supply chain.

Matilda Jobe, 29, is a fish seller working at the beach in Gunjur, one of the biggest fish-landing areas along the Gambia’s 80km Atlantic coast.

Jobe, a widow and single mother, has been struggling to feed her young children since the opening of Golden Lead. With demand pushing up prices, the fish is too expensive, or if the catches are small, the fishmeal factories take priority.

“Sometimes we go empty-handed, but we keep fighting for our children,” she said. “My husband died some years ago and I need to provide for them. They need a good education, so they can do better than us.”

Locals who once enjoyed fish as part of their daily diet are now struggling to afford it. Vast quantities of small fish diverted from the market for human consumption are instead being processed to feed animals and farmed fish.

Fishmeal constitutes about 68 percent of the feed used for farmed fish, with 5kg of fresh fish needed to make 1kg of fishmeal, the Coalition for Fair Fisheries Arrangements said.

Golden Lead is one of three Chinese-owned fishmeal plants operating out of the Gambia. Two others — the JXYG factory in Kartong and the Nassim fishmeal company in Sanyang — have both re-opened in the past few months after temporary closures following complaints about waste disposal.

Community members in May last year reported to the Gambian Ministry of Fisheries and Water Resources that the ecotourism industry in Kartong was under threat due to the discharge of toxic waste. The JXYG factory, which denies dumping waste in Kartong, was asked to cease operations by the Gambian National Environment Agency, but local sources have said that it was given the green light to continue production following an out-of-court settlement.

Factory owners have promised to bring employment to the Gambia, but because the processing of fish for fishmeal is a simple operation — fish is boiled and minced before being dried — the average plant does not employ more than 30 people.

“It’s very difficult to get any information from the factories about how much fish they are using or fishmeal they produce,” Gambia Artisanal Fisheries Development Agency head and marine biologist Dawda Saine said. “They are not providing any data.”

Speaking anonymously, one employee at the factory in Kartong said that the plant processes a maximum of 500 tonnes of fresh fish per day.

“My job is to powder the remaining fish that can’t be processed by the machine,” he added.

He has worked at the factory since it first opened in 2017 and earns about 3,000 Gambian dalasi (US$60) a month, but has never had a contract.

There are seven Chinese workers doing skilled jobs at the factory, while the local workers are employed as security guards and fish transporters, he said.

Experts have said that the production of fishmeal is not only weakening food security in northwest Africa, but is contributing to the existing pressures of overfishing in the region.

New research shows stocks of round sardinella, a fish that migrates along the Atlantic coast between the Gambia and Morocco, have plummeted due to overfishing.

“The main cause of this increased effort is the development of a fishmeal industry in the region,” said Ad Corten, a marine biologist who set up the Food and Agricultural Organisation working group on small pelagic fish in northwest Africa.

Sometimes, landings are so big that even the fishmeal plants cannot take them, and as a result, considerable quantities of fish might be dumped at sea, or on land.

Footage uploaded to YouTube shows Gambian fishers from the town of Tanji protesting against the discarding of round sardinella refused by one of the Chinese factories.

Locals reported that Senegalese fishers had been trying to land a catch at a Gambian fishmeal plant, but the load was rejected. Instead, the fruits of their labor were left to rot. Sometimes, they are discarded at sea, but on this occasion they were sent to the factory by lorry and, after being rejected, were abandoned in the bush.

“We are seeing dead fish thrown back into the sea causing massive environmental pollution,” Gunjur Youth Movement advocate and local small business owner Sulayman Bojang said.

“The beaches that were once beloved by tourists are covered in reeking fish carcasses. The toxic water reaches local farming and harvests go to waste. We want to stop exploitation at the hands of the fishmeal plants, but with the Gambia being one of the poorest countries in the world, we stand no chance against the Chinese corporations,” he said.

Those who speak out against the Chinese factories have said that they risk harassment and intimidation by that authorities, and Bojang is among a number of protesters who have been arrested.

The Environment Concern Group Gunjur has been collecting evidence of environmental pollution. In 2017, environmental groups contacted the local authority to complain that trucks being turned away from the factory were dumping fish, with rotting carcasses littering the road, beaches and bush.

They also documented that manual workers paid to collect the fish when they are landed and take them to the factory were complaining of skin and eye irritations — and local children were reported to be suffering from coughs and chest infections.

After waste was dumped in a local lagoon, turning the water red — and with dead birds and crabs found at the site — the National Environment Agency filed a lawsuit against Golden Lead, but in July 2017, the case was settled out of court.

Gambian microbiologist Ahmed Manjang, who works as a senior researcher at the King Fahad Medical Centre in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, makes regular visits home to help local advocates in Gunjur.

Manjang quoted the Gambian trade minister at the time as having said that prosecuting the factory could deter potential foreign investment in the area.

Dissatisfied with the agreement that the company had made as part of the settlement, the community filed a lawsuit on Aug. 17, 2017, but there has only been one hearing of the case, which remains adjourned.

Meanwhile, anecdotal reports of dead marine life have been increasing.

“We have seen a spike in the number of dead turtles washed up on our beaches and dead dolphins spotted floating at sea,” Manjang said.

On Nov. 21, a baby whale was found dead on the beach outside the factory.

“Scientifically, we cannot link the deaths of marine life to the factory, but these are unusual phenomenon and we think the pollution is to blame,” Manjang said.

The effects on tourism have also been devastating, he said.

“We had quite a bit of investment in ecotourism around Kartong, but people do not want to stay there because of the foul smell,” Manjang said. “These businesses are involved in the lawsuit.”

Despite a temporary ban placed on the local Nassim fishmeal company, operations have resumed, in the face of strong opposition from those working in the tourism industry.

The opposition includes local restaurant owners who say that customers have been leaving before finishing their meals when the factory is operating, due to the stench.

The government is protecting the factories, Manjang said.

“It fears that if we start prosecuting the Chinese, they will withdraw investment from the country. They already pump a lot of money into local cultural events in the community,” he said.

“The factories are killing the women’s processing business and they cannot afford school fees for their children,” he added. “We are not here to ruin opportunities. We need to educate people and fight against what in the long-term will affect everybody.”

The JXYG factory in Kartong, which employs 35 people, denied operating in a way that disadvantaged those in the local fishing community and causing pollution in the area.

The company said that it had a new plant to treat the waste and that there had been no complaints since the plant was reopened after a temporary, four-month closure.

Treated waste would be pumped back into the sea using new pipes that had not yet been laid, it added..

Attempts to contact the Gambian government, including the Ministry for Fisheries and the Ministry for Trade, Industry and Employment, did not receive a response. The factory manager at the Nassim Fishmeal Company in Sanyang declined to comment.

Golden Lead denies outcompeting local fish sellers and said it has a zero tolerance approach to pollution.

Golden Lead plant director Huang Jojo, director of the Golden Lead fishmeal plant in Gunjur, previously said that the factory was in no way responsible for the dumping of fish in the local area, adding that the factory does not pump chemicals into the sea but follows guidance from the National Environment Agency on waste management.

Additional reporting by Mustapha Manneh