Telecommunications company Vodafone’s report on government surveillance of its subscribers in 29 countries reveals more than first meets the eye — and is raising questions from Dublin to Delhi about how much spying on e-mail and telephone chats happens in secret.
In Friday’s report, Vodafone said most countries required the company’s knowledge and cooperation to hear telephone calls or see e-mails, but at least six governments have given their security agencies the power of direct access.
Vodafone did not identify the countries that have tapped into its network, but the report provided some clues. An 88-page appendix reveals that five countries — Albania, Egypt, Hungary, Ireland and Qatar — have provisions that allow authorities to demand unfettered access. In vague language, the report also indicated similar powers could exist in India and the UK, too.
In too many cases, Vodafone said, governments kept both the company and wider society in the dark about what was happening, with laws explicitly forbidding government disclosure of any details of its electronic eavesdropping.
Ireland, a European hub for many social media and communications companies, refused to tell Vodafone anything about how its national police accessed its wireless and Internet services. The Irish situation is muddied further by the fact that its laws on the subject date to 1983 and 1993, when mobile and e-mail communication were still in their infancy.
The Irish government defends the need for electronic surveillance to combat Irish Republican Army factions and Ireland’s criminal underworld.
However, Ireland’s civil liberties watchdog accused the government of legal laziness over the past two decades of telecommunications innovation.
“Our interception laws were drafted in a pre-digital age and are plainly no longer fit for purpose,” Irish Council for Civil Liberties director Mark Kelly said.
Kelly said he has asked the government to confirm whether it operates “direct access pipes into the networks of telecoms operators.”
Other European countries are far more open. In Germany, for example, the government publishes annual statistics. In 2012, the most recent year of disclosure, Germany said it made 18,026 requests to telephone companies to hear 23,687 calls.
Wiretapping of telephones and accessing of call records for law-enforcement purposes is a decades-old and accepted practice even in the most open democracies. With backing from courts, police can request cooperation from telephone companies to access communications.
However, in developing countries, such as the Congo, Ghana and Lesotho, Vodafone said it cannot support wiretapping, because governments have not requested the technology.
By publishing its report, and highlighting its efforts to seek explanations from governments, Vodafone is entering the international debate about balancing the rights of privacy against security.
Rather than being stuck with responsibility and backlash when citizens realize their data has been scooped up without their permission, Vodafone is pushing for a debate.
“The government always argues that they have to weigh freedom and security, and security always overrides freedom,” Delhi-based People’s Union for Democratic Rights activist Gautam Navlakha said.
Navlakha said India’s government tapped the lines of every telephone company in the country and used the power to gain information in a society where “everything leaks.”
Vodafone’s report comes one year after former NSA systems analyst Edward Snowden revealed that US and other countries’ intelligence agencies indiscriminately gathered and stored data from telephone calls and Internet communications.
Norway’s Telenor Group, which operates across Eastern Europe and Asia, backed Vodafone’s report, saying governments have the ultimate responsibility to act.
Several Silicon Valley companies have attempted to restore consumers’ trust by publishing data on electronic spying and raising pressure on US President Barack Obama to curb the US government’s Internet-based surveillance programs.
Twitter Inc, LinkedIn Corp, AOL Inc, Google Inc, Apple Inc, Yahoo Inc, Facebook Inc and Microsoft Corp are pushing for tighter controls over electronic espionage in hopes of protecting their industry’s livelihood. The companies are also encrypting e-mails and other personal information transmitted across their services to make the data more difficult if it is intercepted by government spies.
“Companies are recognizing they have a responsibility to disclose government access,” Washington-based Information Technology and Innovation Foundation senior analyst Daniel Castro said. “This is new.”
Vodafone’s report is also seen as a response to the company’s embarrassing role in the Egyptian protests that ousted former Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak from power in 2011. As those protests raged, the government forced Vodafone to bombard its Egyptian subscribers with propaganda text messages.
The company said it had no choice but to comply, but was severely criticized for its actions.
Human Rights Watch senior researcher Cynthia Wong said Vodafone experienced “a hard lesson” in Egypt.
“Even if the government is the ultimate problem, they realized they needed to take steps to mitigate harm to their users,” she said.
On the streets of Cairo, citizens interviewed on Saturday said they assumed every Egyptian regime sought to spy on them, particularly Mubarak’s successors.
“Mubarak underestimated social media and the youth,” market researcher Iman Fouad, 26, said as he sipped a lunchtime coffee.
He said many Egyptians assumed that security services monitored messages on Facebook and Twitter.
“In Egypt and most of the Arab countries, where they have this obsession with security and knowing what everyone is up to, I can believe it. They are afraid of another revolution,” Fouad said.
A 54-year-old engineer, Ahmed Tarshouby, said the best policy for any telephone user was to talk without fear.
“I talk as I want. I insult as I want,” Tarshouby said as he sat on a sidewalk, smoking a shisha pipe. “I don’t have any problem with them monitoring. I would say anything. I have no secrets.”