Fri, Aug 24, 2018 - Page 9 News List

Search continues for evidence of tribal massacre in the Amazon

A paddle and bad recording of a barroom conversation were all investigators had to go on when claims surfaced last year of killings deep in Brazil’s Javari Valley

By Dom Phillips  /  The Guardian, SAO PAULO DE OLIVENCA, Brazil

If the alleged massacre had happened, it was unlikely that this established settlement would still be there, because isolated groups flee danger, he said.

That conclusion was shared by 44-year-old Daniel Mayaruna, an indigenous man from Javari who was also on the expedition.

Daniel saw a community of his “relatives” in good shape, but said the abandoned mining barge just 10km away was profoundly worrying.

“There are a lot of isolated relatives in this region and my concern is that garimpeiros could kill them,” he said.

Adam Mol, a Polish volunteer doctor, shot video footage of the village.

“We didn’t find any indications of a massacre,” Mol said.

Accusations of massacres are not unknown in the Javari Valley.

In August, Pereira, who is responsible for monitoring its isolated groups, led an expedition in the south of the reserve, following reports by an indigenous man of another mass killing.

Mol went with him and took a drone — equipment that FUNAI did not have; the agency has been decimated by budget cuts under the austerity regime of Brazilian President Michel Temer.

As the expedition headed along the Jutai River, around the area where the killing allegedly took place, they came across a small camp on the side of the water that an isolated group had just vacated, leaving an axe, bow, arrows and other artifacts behind.

Then Mol’s drone spotted the main village just a kilometer away, with people, communal thatched buildings and plantations.

They retreated, reasoning that the indigenous group would have moved had they suffered a massacre.

“The drone footage gave us the intel we needed,” Mol said.

Both cases underline just how hard it is to investigate allegations of possible crimes in such remote regions.

In Tabatinga, federal prosecutor Pablo Beltrand said the tip-off of the supposed Jutai River massacre was “not such a reliable report” and presented “contradictions.”

Beltrand has just received FUNAI’s report on the expedition and is analyzing it.

The agency had been reluctant to share sensitive information, such as the location of isolated groups.

That the isolated tribe has stayed in the region is “something to be considered in the investigation,” Beltrand said.

He has yet to conclude his inquiry.

However, he has little to go on — a paddle, a conversation, an anonymous denunciation.

Meanwhile, smaller wooden mining barges are now reportedly being built beside a river in Sao Paulo de Olivenca. The garimpeiros might yet return.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top